Cayuga County NY Church Records
USA (1,403,636) > New York (68,578) > Cayuga County (1,069) > Cayuga County Church Records (112)
USA (1,403,636) > New York (68,578) > New York Church Records (7,828) > Cayuga County Church Records (112)
NOTE: Additional records that apply to Cayuga County are also on the New York Church Records page.
Cayuga County Church Records
Early history of Friends in Cayuga County, New York, 1795-1828 FamilySearch Library
History of the Cayuga Baptist Association : compiled from authentic records at the request of the association FamilySearch Library
U.S., Quaker Meeting Records (includes Scipio Monthly Meeting, Oversized Marriage Certificates) Ancestry
Churches in Cayuga County in 1926
In 1926 the federal government took a Census of Religious Bodies. The 94 churches listed here reported from Cayuga County. For more information, see our article on Using the 1926 Census of Religious Bodies.
Atwater
Palmer's – Christadelphians. Pastor: Joseph E. Palmer
Auburn
Unnamed congregation – Evangelical Lutheran Synodical Conference of America: Evangelical Lutheran Synod of Missouri, Ohio, and Other States, Missouri, Ohio and other States. Pastor: H. Th. Stiemke
Auburn Reformed Methodist – Reformed Methodist Church, N.Y. State. Pastor: Francis P. Finch
Central Church of Christ, Disciples – Disciples of Christ, New York and New Jersey State Association. Pastor: Ralph C. Walker
Christadelphian Assembly – Christadelphians. Pastor: Thomas Turner, Wm. Morrison
Church of God and Saints of Christ – Church of God and Saints of Christ. Pastor: Harry Dawkins
First – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Howard S. Anderson
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Association. Pastor: George Montgomery Reid
First Church of Christ – Disciples of Christ, New York. Pastor: L. N. Coffey
First Church of Christ, Scientist – Church of Christ, Scientist
First Universalist in Auburn N.Y. – Universalist Church, N.Y. State Universalist Convention. Pastor: A. E. Allison
Holy Family – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: John A. Conway
Immanuel – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga County
Rochester Conf. Auburn Branch – Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Eastern States Stake. Pastor: Orin D. Jones
Roosevelt Memorial Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga County Association. Pastor: S. J. Lang
Salvation Army – Salvation Army, Western New York Division. Pastor: W. H. Cockerill
Second Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Baptist. Pastor: Edward L. James
SS. Peter and Paul – Greek Catholic Church, Ruthenian Greek Catholic. Pastor: Anthony Strockyj
St. Aloysius – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: J. B. Crowley
St. Alphonsus Church – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester Diocese. Pastor: Frederick G. Straub
St. Francis of Assisi – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester, N.Y. Pastor: Pietro Moria
St. Hyacinth's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: Jerome Holubowicz O.M.C.
St. Luke's Evangelical Church – Evangelical Synod of North America, The New York District. Pastor: Richard Stave, Ph. D.
St. Mary's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: John McGrath
St. Nicholas Russian Orthodox Greek Catholic church – Russian Orthodox Church. Pastor: Anthony Diachenko
Thompson A.M.E. Zion – African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, Western New York - Genesee District. Pastor: G. H. Coffey
Trinity Methodist – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Elmer Edward Benson
Wall St. Auburn Methodist Episcopal – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Walter Tildesley
Aurelius
Fosterville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Ralph L. Smith
Half Acre Union – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y., District Syracuse West. Pastor: F. H. Butman
Aurora Village
St. Patrick's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Stephen J. Byrne
Cato
Cato Church of Christ – Disciples of Christ. Pastor: T. T. Bass
St. Patrick's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: John M. Ball
Cayuga
Cayuga Mission – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: J. B. Crowley
Methodist Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West District. Pastor: DeWitt Proseus
Conquest
Conquest – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Herbert E. Ernway
Conquest M.P. – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: Joseph H. Richards
Fair Haven
Unnamed congregation – Federated Churches, M.E. & Presbyterian. Pastor: Arthur F. Clark
First Presbyterian – Presbyterian, Cayuga. Pastor: M. C. Pittman
M.E. Church, part of the Federated Church of Fair Haven – Methodist Episcopal, Central N.Y. Pastor: Arthur Tillotson Clark
Fleming
Fleming Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Co. Association. Pastor: J. W. Crippen
Fleming M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central, District Syracuse West. Pastor: F. H. Butman
Owasco Outlet Reformed Church – Reformed Church in America, Classis of Montgomery, Synod of Albany. Pastor: Jno. Van Allen
Geneva
St. Hilary's Church – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Edward J. Lyons
Genoa
First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: John B. Freestone
Hannibal Ctr
Emerson – Christian Church (General Convention of the Christian Church), Central Christian Conference. Pastor: John A. Dillon
Ira
Bethel and Ira – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y., District Syracuse W. Pastor: C. C. Townsend
Kings Ferry
Our Lady of the Lake – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: M. B. Groden
Locke
Locke – Methodist Episcopal Church, Syracuse West District, Central New York Conference. Pastor: L. F. Livingston
Milan Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cortland Association. Pastor: Ward Lush
Martville
Martville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Raymond W. Cox
Meridian
Meridian Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Association. Pastor: E. H. Conrad
Montezuma
Mentz – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Ralph L. Smith
Montezuma – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Ralph L. Smith
St. Michael's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: John J. Cosgrove
Moravia
Congregational Church – Congregational Churches. Pastor: Stephen S. Wood
First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: Arthur L. Warren
St. Patrick's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Arthur C. Smith
Niles
New Hope and Kelloggsville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Syracuse West, Central New York
Owasco
Owasco Reformed Church – Reformed Church in America, Classis of Montgomery, Synod of Albany. Pastor: Richard J. Blocker
St. Anne – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Arthur C. Smith
Poplar Ridge
Conservative Friends Meeting – Orthodox Conservative Friends (Wilburite), Scipio Monthly Meeting
Poplar Ridge Friends – Society of Friends (Orthodox), Scipio Monthly Meeting. Pastor: Wm. Prideaux
Port Byron
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: Byron L. Bixby
First Methodist – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Martius D. Foster
Mission – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester
Port Byron Free Methodist Church – Free Methodist Church of North America, Susquehanna. Pastor: Earl Habecker
Scipio
Scipio Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Association. Pastor: J. W. Crippen
Scipio Universalist – Universalist Church, N.Y. State Universalist Convention. Pastor: A. E. Allison
St. Bernard's Church – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Edward J. Lyons
Scipioville
Scipioville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y., District Syracuse West. Pastor: Frederick H. Butman
Sempronius
Sempronius Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cortland Baptist Association. Pastor: W. L. Bates
Sennett
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: Almeron H. Merrill
Sterling
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Association. Pastor: H. E. Wickerson
Sterling M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Raymond W. Cox
Summerhill
East Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Cortland County Baptist Association. Pastor: Warren T. Barnes
Summerhill Congregational Church – Congregational Churches, Central Association, N.Y. Pastor: Lewis G. Shooner
Throop
Thropsville, Church of Christ – Disciples of Christ. Pastor: Leland H. Larabee
Throopsville
First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Northern New York, Cayuga Association. Pastor: Thomas L. Lusk
Union Springs
Methodist Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West District. Pastor: DeWitt Proseus
St. Michael's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester
Venice
Venice Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Baptist Association. Pastor: Ward Lusk
Victory
Unnamed congregation – Federated Churches, M.E. & Presbyterian. Pastor: Herbert E. Erway
Victory Presbyterian Church – Presbyterian, Cayuga. Pastor: Herbert E. Erway
Weedsport
Brick Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y. Conference, District Syracuse West. Pastor: W. J. Stearns
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: Robert Donald Williamson
St. Joseph's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: Jos. J. Ruby
Weedsport Free Methodist Church – Free Methodist Church of North America, Susquehanna. Pastor: Earl Habecker
Weedsport M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y., District Syracuse West. Pastor: Warren J. Stearns
Town not stated
Ledyard – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York Conf., Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Herbert J. Gordon
Moravia – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West. Pastor: F. T. Crumley
Spring Lake – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: Samuel S. Lucey
Venice Center – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York Conf., Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Herbert J. Gordon
West Genoa – Methodist Episcopal Church, Conf. Central New York, Dist. Syracuse West. Pastor: Herbert J. Gordon
Additions or corrections to this page? We welcome your suggestions through our Contact Us page