Cayuga County NY Church Records

USA (1,403,636) > New York (68,578) > Cayuga County (1,069) > Cayuga County Church Records (112)

USA (1,403,636) > New York (68,578) > New York Church Records (7,828) > Cayuga County Church Records (112)


NOTE: Additional records that apply to Cayuga County are also on the New York Church Records page.

Countywide Auburn Aurelius Aurora Village Brutus Cato Cayuga Fair Haven Fleming Genoa Kelloggsville King Ferry Locke Mentz Meridian Moravia New Hope Owasco Port Byron Scipio Sennett Springport Sterling Summerhill Union Springs Victory Weedsport

Cayuga County Church Records

Early history of Friends in Cayuga County, New York, 1795-1828 FamilySearch Library

History of the Cayuga Baptist Association : compiled from authentic records at the request of the association FamilySearch Library

U.S., Quaker Meeting Records (includes Scipio Monthly Meeting, Oversized Marriage Certificates) Ancestry online

Auburn Church Records

Filter By Year:

A sermon preached March 6, 1817, at the dedication of the new Presbyterian Church, in the village of Auburn FamilySearch Library

A sermon preached March 6, 1817, at the dedication of the new Presbyterian Church, in the village of Auburn Ancestry online

Central Church semi-centennial : addresses and papers prepared in connection with the celebration of the fiftieth anniversary (of the Central Presbyterian Church of Auburn) Ancestry online

Central Church semi-centennial : addresses and papers prepared in connection with the celebration of the fiftieth anniversary of the founding of the Central Presbyterian Church of Auburn, New York FamilySearch Library

Church of the Holy Family of Auburn records, 1840-1968. Archive Grid

Church records, 1840-1910 (Catholic Church. Holy Family (Auburn, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1854-1910 (Catholic Church. St. Alphonsus (Auburn, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1868-1910 (Catholic Church. St. Mary (Auborn, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1884-1910 (Catholic Church. St. Hyacinth (Auburn, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1901-1910 (Catholic Church. St. Aloysius (Auburn, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1908-1910 (Catholic Church. St. Francis of Assisi (Auburn, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Directory / First Methodist Episcopal Church, Auburn, N.Y. FamilySearch Library

First Methodist Church (Auburn, N.Y.) Records 1833-1969 Archive Grid

First Presbyterian Church (Auburn, N.Y.) Records 1802-1912 Archive Grid

First Universalist Society of Auburn records, Auburn, N.Y., 1833-1953 Archive Grid

History of the church of Christ in Auburn (1867 discourse Cornell University Library online

Records of Saint Peter's Episcopal Church, Auburn, New York WorldCat

Society for Missionary Inquiry (Auburn Theological Seminary) Records, 1822-1850 Archive Grid

The history of the First Presbyterian Church, Auburn, N.Y. : a discourse Ancestry online

The history of the First Presbyterian Church, Auburn, N.Y. : a discourse delivered Sabbath, March 7, 1869, on leaving the old church previous to its removal to give place to the new edifice FamilySearch Library

Twenty-fifth anniversary of the pastorate of Rev. Chas. Hawley, D. D., with the First Presbyterian church, of Auburn, N.Y. 1857-1882. Cornell University Library online

Twenty-fifth anniversary of the rectorship of Rev. John Brainard, D. D., in St. Peter's Church, Auburn, N.Y. 1863-1888 Cornell University Library online

Aurelius Church Records

Aurora Village Church Records

Brutus Church Records

Cato Church Records

Cayuga Church Records

Fair Haven Church Records

Fleming Church Records

Pew List Reformed Protestant Dutch Church at the Owasco Outlet, 1810 New Horizons Genealogical Services online

Records of the Reformed Protestant Dutch Church at the Owasco Outlet in the town of Fleming, Cayuga County ... 1807-1881 FamilySearch Library

Records of the Reformed Protestant Dutch Church at the Owasco Outlet in the town of Fleming, Cayuga County, N.Y. WorldCat

Records of the Reformed Protestant Dutch Church at the Owasco outlet in the town of Fleming, N.Y. (includes births, baptisms, and marriages) Ancestry online

Reformed Dutch Church at the Owasco Outlet, Fleming, Cayuaga, New York computer printout; marriages, 1829-1886 FamilySearch Library

Reformed Dutch Church at the Owasco Outlet, Fleming, Cayuga, New York computer printout; births or christenings, 1807-1881 FamilySearch Library

Subscribers List Reformed Protestant Dutch Church at the Owasco Outlet, 1810 New Horizons Genealogical Services online

Genoa Church Records

Church book of the Evangelical United Congregation in Milton and Scipio : commenced in the year of our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, 1803 FamilySearch Library

Church records of the United Evangelical and Lutheran Church of Scipio and Milton, Cayuga Co., N.Y. FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1800-1853 (First Presbyterian Church (Genoa, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1805-1842 (Presbyterian Church (Lansing, New York)) FamilySearch Library

First Presbyterian Church, Genoa, Cayuga, New York computer printout; births or christenings, 1799-1853 FamilySearch Library

United Church of Genoa, Register, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, and Deaths, 1898-1970 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry online

United Church of Genoa, Session, Register, Baptisms, and Deaths, 1855-1913 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry online

Kelloggsville Church Records

King Ferry Church Records

Locke Church Records

Mentz Church Records

Meridian Church Records

Moravia Church Records

New Hope Church Records

Owasco Church Records

Port Byron Church Records

Scipio Church Records

Filter By Year:

Church book of the Evangelical United Congregation in Milton and Scipio : commenced in the year of our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, 1803 FamilySearch Library

Church records (excerpts), 1801-1804 FamilySearch Library

Church records of the United Evangelical and Lutheran Church of Scipio and Milton, Cayuga Co., N.Y. FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1809-1898 FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1811-1865 (Presbyterian Church (Scipio Center, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Church records, 1864-1910 (Catholic Church. St. Bernard (Scipio, New York)) FamilySearch Library

Early history of Friends in Cayuga County, New York, 1795-1828 FamilySearch Library

Presbyterian Church, Baptisms, Births, 1811-1865 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry online

Presbyterian Church, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, Deaths, 1903-1928 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry online

Presbyterian Church, Scipio, Cayuga, New York computer printout; births or christenings, 1814-1820 FamilySearch Library

Sennett Church Records

Springport Church Records

Sterling Church Records

Summerhill Church Records

Union Springs Church Records

Victory Church Records

Weedsport Church Records

Churches in Cayuga County in 1926

In 1926 the federal government took a Census of Religious Bodies. The 94 churches listed here reported from Cayuga County. For more information, see our article on Using the 1926 Census of Religious Bodies.

Atwater

Palmer's – Christadelphians. Pastor: Joseph E. Palmer

Auburn

Unnamed congregation – Evangelical Lutheran Synodical Conference of America: Evangelical Lutheran Synod of Missouri, Ohio, and Other States, Missouri, Ohio and other States. Pastor: H. Th. Stiemke

Auburn Reformed Methodist – Reformed Methodist Church, N.Y. State. Pastor: Francis P. Finch

Central Church of Christ, Disciples – Disciples of Christ, New York and New Jersey State Association. Pastor: Ralph C. Walker

Christadelphian Assembly – Christadelphians. Pastor: Thomas Turner, Wm. Morrison

Church of God and Saints of Christ – Church of God and Saints of Christ. Pastor: Harry Dawkins

First – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Howard S. Anderson

First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Association. Pastor: George Montgomery Reid

First Church of Christ – Disciples of Christ, New York. Pastor: L. N. Coffey

First Church of Christ, Scientist – Church of Christ, Scientist

First Universalist in Auburn N.Y. – Universalist Church, N.Y. State Universalist Convention. Pastor: A. E. Allison

Holy Family – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: John A. Conway

Immanuel – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga County

Rochester Conf. Auburn Branch – Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Eastern States Stake. Pastor: Orin D. Jones

Roosevelt Memorial Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga County Association. Pastor: S. J. Lang

Salvation Army – Salvation Army, Western New York Division. Pastor: W. H. Cockerill

Second Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Baptist. Pastor: Edward L. James

SS. Peter and Paul – Greek Catholic Church, Ruthenian Greek Catholic. Pastor: Anthony Strockyj

St. Aloysius – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: J. B. Crowley

St. Alphonsus Church – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester Diocese. Pastor: Frederick G. Straub

St. Francis of Assisi – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester, N.Y. Pastor: Pietro Moria

St. Hyacinth's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: Jerome Holubowicz O.M.C.

St. Luke's Evangelical Church – Evangelical Synod of North America, The New York District. Pastor: Richard Stave, Ph. D.

St. Mary's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: John McGrath

St. Nicholas Russian Orthodox Greek Catholic church – Russian Orthodox Church. Pastor: Anthony Diachenko

Thompson A.M.E. Zion – African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, Western New York - Genesee District. Pastor: G. H. Coffey

Trinity Methodist – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Elmer Edward Benson

Wall St. Auburn Methodist Episcopal – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Walter Tildesley

Aurelius

Fosterville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Ralph L. Smith

Half Acre Union – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y., District Syracuse West. Pastor: F. H. Butman

Aurora Village

St. Patrick's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Stephen J. Byrne

Cato

Cato Church of Christ – Disciples of Christ. Pastor: T. T. Bass

St. Patrick's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: John M. Ball

Cayuga

Cayuga Mission – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: J. B. Crowley

Methodist Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West District. Pastor: DeWitt Proseus

Conquest

Conquest – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Herbert E. Ernway

Conquest M.P. – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: Joseph H. Richards

Fair Haven

Unnamed congregation – Federated Churches, M.E. & Presbyterian. Pastor: Arthur F. Clark

First Presbyterian – Presbyterian, Cayuga. Pastor: M. C. Pittman

M.E. Church, part of the Federated Church of Fair Haven – Methodist Episcopal, Central N.Y. Pastor: Arthur Tillotson Clark

Fleming

Fleming Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Co. Association. Pastor: J. W. Crippen

Fleming M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central, District Syracuse West. Pastor: F. H. Butman

Owasco Outlet Reformed Church – Reformed Church in America, Classis of Montgomery, Synod of Albany. Pastor: Jno. Van Allen

Geneva

St. Hilary's Church – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Edward J. Lyons

Genoa

First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: John B. Freestone

Hannibal Ctr

Emerson – Christian Church (General Convention of the Christian Church), Central Christian Conference. Pastor: John A. Dillon

Ira

Bethel and Ira – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y., District Syracuse W. Pastor: C. C. Townsend

Kings Ferry

Our Lady of the Lake – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: M. B. Groden

Locke

Locke – Methodist Episcopal Church, Syracuse West District, Central New York Conference. Pastor: L. F. Livingston

Milan Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cortland Association. Pastor: Ward Lush

Martville

Martville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Raymond W. Cox

Meridian

Meridian Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Association. Pastor: E. H. Conrad

Montezuma

Mentz – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Ralph L. Smith

Montezuma – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Ralph L. Smith

St. Michael's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: John J. Cosgrove

Moravia

Congregational Church – Congregational Churches. Pastor: Stephen S. Wood

First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: Arthur L. Warren

St. Patrick's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Arthur C. Smith

Niles

New Hope and Kelloggsville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Syracuse West, Central New York

Owasco

Owasco Reformed Church – Reformed Church in America, Classis of Montgomery, Synod of Albany. Pastor: Richard J. Blocker

St. Anne – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Arthur C. Smith

Poplar Ridge

Conservative Friends Meeting – Orthodox Conservative Friends (Wilburite), Scipio Monthly Meeting

Poplar Ridge Friends – Society of Friends (Orthodox), Scipio Monthly Meeting. Pastor: Wm. Prideaux

Port Byron

First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: Byron L. Bixby

First Methodist – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Martius D. Foster

Mission – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester

Port Byron Free Methodist Church – Free Methodist Church of North America, Susquehanna. Pastor: Earl Habecker

Scipio

Scipio Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Association. Pastor: J. W. Crippen

Scipio Universalist – Universalist Church, N.Y. State Universalist Convention. Pastor: A. E. Allison

St. Bernard's Church – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester. Pastor: Edward J. Lyons

Scipioville

Scipioville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y., District Syracuse West. Pastor: Frederick H. Butman

Sempronius

Sempronius Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cortland Baptist Association. Pastor: W. L. Bates

Sennett

First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: Almeron H. Merrill

Sterling

First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Association. Pastor: H. E. Wickerson

Sterling M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Raymond W. Cox

Summerhill

East Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Cortland County Baptist Association. Pastor: Warren T. Barnes

Summerhill Congregational Church – Congregational Churches, Central Association, N.Y. Pastor: Lewis G. Shooner

Throop

Thropsville, Church of Christ – Disciples of Christ. Pastor: Leland H. Larabee

Throopsville

First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Northern New York, Cayuga Association. Pastor: Thomas L. Lusk

Union Springs

Methodist Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West District. Pastor: DeWitt Proseus

St. Michael's – Roman Catholic Church, Rochester

Venice

Venice Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga Baptist Association. Pastor: Ward Lusk

Victory

Unnamed congregation – Federated Churches, M.E. & Presbyterian. Pastor: Herbert E. Erway

Victory Presbyterian Church – Presbyterian, Cayuga. Pastor: Herbert E. Erway

Weedsport

Brick Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y. Conference, District Syracuse West. Pastor: W. J. Stearns

First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Cayuga. Pastor: Robert Donald Williamson

St. Joseph's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Rochester. Pastor: Jos. J. Ruby

Weedsport Free Methodist Church – Free Methodist Church of North America, Susquehanna. Pastor: Earl Habecker

Weedsport M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central N.Y., District Syracuse West. Pastor: Warren J. Stearns

Town not stated

Ledyard – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York Conf., Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Herbert J. Gordon

Moravia – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York, Syracuse West. Pastor: F. T. Crumley

Spring Lake – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: Samuel S. Lucey

Venice Center – Methodist Episcopal Church, Central New York Conf., Syracuse West Dist. Pastor: Herbert J. Gordon

West Genoa – Methodist Episcopal Church, Conf. Central New York, Dist. Syracuse West. Pastor: Herbert J. Gordon

Not sure what to do next in your genealogy research? We have professional genealogist research services available.

Additions or corrections to this page? We welcome your suggestions through our Contact Us page