Herkimer County NY Church Records
USA (1,403,636) > New York (68,578) > Herkimer County (942) > Herkimer County Church Records (67)
USA (1,403,636) > New York (68,578) > New York Church Records (7,828) > Herkimer County Church Records (67)
NOTE: Additional records that apply to Herkimer County are also on the New York Church Records page.
Herkimer County Church Records
Church Records, 1729-1930 Archive Grid
Churches in Herkimer County in 1926
In 1926 the federal government took a Census of Religious Bodies. The 93 churches listed here reported from Herkimer County. For more information, see our article on Using the 1926 Census of Religious Bodies.
Cedarville
Cedarville Universalist – Universalist Church. Pastor: E. D. Ridgeway
Cold Brook
First M.E. Cold Brook – Methodist Episcopal Church, N. New York. Pastor: M. A. Bartlett
Columbia
Columbia Reformed Church – Reformed Church in America, Classis of Montgomery, Synod of Albany
North Columbia – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: J. A. Brice
Dolgeville
First Methodist Episcopal – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York, Mohawk Dist. Pastor: Frederick R. Griffiths
First Universalist – Universalist Church. Pastor: Clinton A. Moulton
St. Joseph's – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: J. S. Slattery
Zion Lutheran – United Lutheran Church in America, Synod of New York. Pastor: J. F. K. Riebesell
Fairfield
Fairfield Central – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: D. Egbert Robson
The Church of the Messiah – Universalist Church. Pastor: W. H. Skeels
Fort Herkimer
Dutch Reformed of Fort Herkimer – Reformed Church in America, Montgomery Classis, Synod of Albany
Frankfort
First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River Association. Pastor: George N. Gates
First M.E. Ch. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York, District Mohawk. Pastor: W. K. Bradshaw
Frankfort Hill M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: N. James Polney
Italian M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York, Mohawk Dist. Pastor: Pasquale D'Elia
SS. Peter and Paul – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: P. J. Wallace
St. Mary's – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: Charles J. McCormack
West Frankfort – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York, District Mohawk. Pastor: Roger F. Williams
German Flatts
So. Ilion – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: J. A. Brice
Grant
Grant Union – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River Baptist Asso.
Graversville
Graversville M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New York. Pastor: M. A. Bartlett
Herkimer
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River Baptist Association. Pastor: Chellis E. Nichols
First Church of Christ, Scientist – Church of Christ, Scientist
First Free Methodist Church Herkimer – Free Methodist Church of North America, Susquehanna Conference. Pastor: C. E. Christman
First Methodist Episcopal – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York, Mohawk Dist. Pastor: Howard D. Holmes
First Universalist Church – Universalist Church. Pastor: W. H. Skeels
Herkimer Corps – Salvation Army, Eastern New York. Pastor: James A. Linn
Reformed Church of Herkimer, N.Y. – Reformed Church in America, Classis of Montgomery, Synod of Albany
St. Anthony's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Albany. Pastor: Charles J. McCormack
St. Francis de Sales – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: William H. White
St. Joseph's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Albany. Pastor: Joseph Blonkowski
St. Mary's – Ukrainian Greek-Catholic, U.S.A. Headquarter in Philadelphia, Pa. Pastor: John T. Krohmalney
St. Peter and St. Paul Church – Russian Orthodox Church, Russian Orthodox mission. Pastor: Paul Lisok
Trinity Ev. Lutheran – United Lutheran Church in America, New York Synod. Pastor: Philip M. Luther
Ilion
Annunciation – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: J. B. Gilloon
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River
First M.E. Ilion N.Y. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York, Mohawk Dist. Pastor: Aaron B. Corbitt
Gwylfa – Presbyterian Church in the United States of America, Oneida. Pastor: John R. Evans
Ilion Branch of Christian and Missionary Alliance – Christian and Missionary Alliance, Eastern District. Pastor: Wm. Edmonds
Indian Castle
Union Evan. Luth. on card – United Lutheran Church in America, New York Synod
Jordansville
Jordansville M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: M. T. Hibbard
Jordanville
Warren Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River. Pastor: K. N. Conrad
Little Falls
Unnamed congregation – Polish National Catholic Church of America, Eastern Diocese. Pastor: Emil Wandowski
Christ Lutheran – United Lutheran Church in America, Synod of New York. Pastor: J. F. K. Riebesell
Christian Science Society – Church of Christ, Scientist
First – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York, District Mohawk. Pastor: Joseph W. Barrett
First Baptist Church of Little Falls, New York – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River Association, New York State Convention. Pastor: Paul F. Swarthout
Holy Trinity – United Lutheran Church in America, Independent. Pastor: Thomas J. Smrcka
Manheim – Reformed Church in America, Classis of Montgomery; Synod of Albany
Sacred Heart – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Albany. Pastor: Joseph Blonkowski
St. Joseph's – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: Anthony Spina
St. Mary's Mission – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Albany, N.Y. Pastor: Edmund A. O'Connor
St. Nicholas – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese with Headquarters in Philadelphia. Pastor: John T. Krohmalney
St. Paul's – Universalist Church. Pastor: Seth Rogers Brooks
Manheim
Evangelical – United Lutheran Church in America, New York Synod
Inghams Mills – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk Association. Pastor: Karl J. Simpson
Middleville
First M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: D. Egbert Robson
St. Mary's Mission – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Albany. Pastor: Ernest P. Neville
Millers Mill
Millers Mills – Northern Baptist Convention, Oneida Baptist Association. Pastor: S. J. Ford
Mohawk
Blessed Sacrament – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: Daniel J. McCarthy
First Reformed Church of Mohawk, N.Y. – Reformed Church in America, Montgomery Classis, Synod of Albany. Pastor: Francis P. Ihrman
Mohawk - 1st M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York, Mohawk Dist. Pastor: Arthur Partington
Mohawk Universalist – Universalist Church
Newport
First Baptist Crurch of Newport, N.Y. – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River Association. Pastor: Lewis N. Powell
Main St. Methodist Episcopal – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: A. S. Haven
St. John's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Albany. Pastor: Ernest P. Neville
The Church of Reconciliation – Universalist Church. Pastor: H. W. Skeels
Norway
Norway Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River. Pastor: Lewis N. Powell
Ohio
Gray – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern N.Y. Pastor: C. H. Bowman
Ohio – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern N.Y. Pastor: C. H. Bowman
Poland
First Methodist Episcopal – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: A. S. Haven
Poland Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River. Pastor: N. E. Miller
Russia
Unnamed congregation – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River Baptist Association
Russia M.E. Society – Methodist Episcopal Church, New York. Pastor: M. A. Bartlett
Salisbury
Salisbury – Northern Baptist Convention, Mohawk River
St. Bridget's – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: J. S. Slattery
Salisbury Center
Salisbury Center – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: Albert E. Potter
Salisbury Ctr
First Universalist – Universalist Church, Mohawk Asso. New York Convention. Pastor: Clinton A. Moulton
Schuyler
First M.P. of Schuyler – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: Wm. A. Fuller
Second M.P. of Schuyler – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: Wm. A. Fuller
West Schuyler – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: Roger F. Williams
So. Columbia
South Columbia M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: M. T. Hibbard
Stark
Unnamed congregation – Methodist Episcopal Church, N.N.Y. Pastor: Edwin Crocker
Starkville – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: Edwin Crocker
Starkville
St. James Lutheran Church of Starkville – United Lutheran Church in America, Hartwick Synod
Stratford
Stratford M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: Albert E. Potter
Van Hornesville
Universalist Church of Van Hornesville – Universalist Church
West Winfield
Chepachet Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Oneida Baptist Association. Pastor: S. J. Ford
First Methodist Episcopal Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Northern New York. Pastor: Charles E. Miller
Immanuel Congregational Church – Congregational Churches, Oneida, Chenango & Delaware Association. Pastor: Edward Daniel Hughes
St. Joseph's – Roman Catholic Church, Albany. Pastor: E. P. Dalton
West Winfield Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Oneida Baptist Association. Pastor: S. J. Ford
Town not stated
Paines Hollow – Methodist Protestant Church, Onondaga. Pastor: Jacob Skinner
Additions or corrections to this page? We welcome your suggestions through our Contact Us page