USA > Indiana > White County > A standard history of White County Indiana : an authentic narrative of the past, with an extended survey of modern developments in the progress of town and county, Vol. I > Part 35
Note: The text from this book was generated using artificial intelligence so there may be some errors. The full pages can be found on Archive.org (link on the Part 1 page).
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16 | Part 17 | Part 18 | Part 19 | Part 20 | Part 21 | Part 22 | Part 23 | Part 24 | Part 25 | Part 26 | Part 27 | Part 28 | Part 29 | Part 30 | Part 31 | Part 32 | Part 33 | Part 34 | Part 35 | Part 36 | Part 37 | Part 38 | Part 39 | Part 40 | Part 41 | Part 42 | Part 43 | Part 44 | Part 45 | Part 46 | Part 47 | Part 48 | Part 49 | Part 50 | Part 51 | Part 52 | Part 53 | Part 54 | Part 55 | Part 56
BAPTISTS AND METHODISTS ORGANIZE
Elders Reese, Miner and Corbin organized the Baptist society soon after the Presbyterians formed a society. Elder Miner, of Lafayette, had charge of the society, but in his absence Elder Reese officiated, the Monticello meetings usually being held at the house of the latter.
In the winter of 1836-37 a protracted meeting was held in the school- house, which resulted in the formation of a Methodist class and the calling of Hachaliah Vreedenburg to the mission. The combined school and meeting-house was a frame building, 20 by 30 feet, with iron latches and hinges, as well as real glass for the windows. It was far above the average of such structures and remained both a temple of learning and a temple of worship for a full decade.
THE BUSY YEAR, 1836
In the meantime the material interests of Monticello were also grow- ing apace. The year 1836 was especially busy. Carpenters, blacksmiths, doctors, merchants, ministers, lawyers, speculators and mechanics of every descriptions began to appear, and the building of houses and shops was rapidly lining out the principal streets of the town.
YOUNG TOWN CONSIDERABLY SOAKED
In May, 1836, Rowland Hughes opened his tavern, having paid $5 for the license, and about the same time Parcel and Nicholson, and Ford, Walker and Company, were licensed as general storekeepers, each firm paying $10 for the privilege of selling their goods. Landlord Hughes bought the privilege of selling liquor at his hotel, and Patrick Sullivan opened a regular saloon soon afterward. Such attractions were not resisted by the Indians just above Monticello and several miles further north in what is now Liberty Township. The squaws came from the villages with their bead work and other fancy articles and the braves brought skins or venison, which were as often exchanged for bad whiskey as for good food. Sullivan was indicted several times for selling whiskey to the Pottawattamies, but Hughes was more careful to confine his traffic in strong drink to the white villagers. For a number of years, especially while the Indians lingered, Monticello had rather a bad name as a whiskey-soaked town.
BUSINESS DIRECTORY FOR 1836
In this busy year of 1836 William Sill also opened a general store, as did Reynolds and Cassel. Aside from those mentioned, the following
Courtesy of Monticello Herald
VIEW OF THE TIPPECANOE, WITH TIOGA BRIDGES IN THE DISTANCE
293
HISTORY OF WHITE COUNTY
were factors in the Monticello expansion: Peter Martin, merchant ; James Parker, sheriff; Dr. Samuel Rifenberrick, general merchandise ; Mr. Perces, grocer; Jonathan Harbolt, James McKinley, T. R. Dawson, Christian Dasher, Robert Spencer, Salmon Sherwood and John Hana- walt, carpenters; G. R. Bartley, Nathaniel White and John Ream, farmers; Joseph Skidmore and Thompson Crose, blacksmiths; Rev. Joshua Lindsey, minister, justice of the peace and postmaster; Jacob Meyers, tailor; Daniel M. Tilton, tailor and deputy postmaster; Jacob Thomas, shoemaker; Asa Allen, surveyor; Widows Bott and Reese ; Jacob Franklin, cabinet maker; William Brock, plasterer and cabinet maker; Oliver Hammon, small store, and Abraham Snyder, tanner.
At that time the town had the frame schoolhouse and the little frame courthouse. Not long after the courthouse was blown down by a heavy wind; Robert Spencer, its builder, was placed under a cloud as to his efficiency, and Jonathan Harbolt had the satisfaction of re-erecting it. Monticello had then a population of about 100 men, women and children.
FERRY ESTABLISHED
In May, 1837, Peter Martin was licensed to conduct a ferry across the river at Monticello, and was required to keep a boat large enough to carry teams and a smaller boat for persons.
SMITH, HIORTH AND THE KENDALLS
In the following spring Peter B. Smith, who had been associated with Hans E. Hiorth in the Norway water power and mills, opened a general store at Monticello, whither he appears to have transferred most of his interests. Hiorth afterward purchased a share in the business, which he probably held until his death in 1844. The Kendall brothers were the next important business men to enter the Monticello field with large stocks of general merchandise, and were leading merchants during the decade previous to 1848, when they took over the Hiorth properties at Norway, but two of them afterward returned to the county seat and re-entered business.
Jacob Beck and John Brady came as rivals of Rowland Hughes in the hotel line, about 1840, and Merriam and Company opened another store in 1844. In 1846 Messrs. Reynolds and Merriam became partners, besides whom there were engaged in mercantile affairs, William Sill, Rowland Hughes, Charles W. Kendall, Rifenberrick and Brearley, Andrew Sproule and William Sheetz and Company.
ESTABLISHMENT OF THE LOCAL PRESS
The late '40s were rather full of events which had a bearing on the progress of Monticello; the leading ones were the establishment of the Prairie Chieftain, the first newspaper of the county, and the prac- tical development of the water power under the management of the
Courtesy of C. L. Foster
RIVERSIDE MILL AND MONTICELLO RESIDENCES
295
HISTORY OF WHITE COUNTY
Monticello Hydraulic Company. The Chieftain met with a fair patron- age during the five years of its existence, and various newspapers have since succeeded one another, with more or less close connection, up to the present ; the Chieftain, which issued its first number July 3, 1849, demonstrated that Monticello and the county would support a good, earnest newspaper, and its founding was therefore an important event for both.
FIRST WATER POWER AND MILLS
The Monticello Hydraulic Company inaugurated a long line of indus- tries which accomplished much toward the early growth of the place. The act by which it was constituted was passed by the Legislature in February, 1848, and named as its incorporators Phillip Wolverton, John Burns, Ashley L. Pierce, Henry Ensmiger, Randolph Brearley, John C. Merriam, Zachariah VanBuskirk, Isaac Reynolds and Zebulon Sheetz. In 1849 the company bought small tracts of land from Mr. Sheetz and Rowland Hughes and a dam was thrown across the river. A site was then leased to Messrs. Reynolds and Brearley, who erected a large frame grist mill for merchant work, and Hoagland and Conklin built a woolen factory at about the same time. Mr. Sheetz next built a sawmill and a second establishment of that kind was established by Hoagland and Conklin, the latter being subsequently transformed into a furniture factory. Reynolds and Brearley added to their interests by erecting a large frame warehouse, which Professor Bowman leased for his school in 1859.
WOOL CENTER AND WOOLEN MANUFACTURES
The leases of the water power at Monticello controlled by the old Hydraulic Company were for ten years and carried with them small pieces of land adjacent to the dam. For many years the grist, saw and woolen mills were in profitable operation and were the means of drawing and holding many useful citizens to the town. As a wool center it became well known.
In the early years Northwestern Indiana was noted as a productive sheep country, and White County shared in its good name in that regard. Probably Peter Price became the largest, if not the first of the wool dealers at Monticello, and for a number of years before the factory was built collected large quantities of the raw material and hauled it in wagons to Delphi, LaFayette and other places on the Wabash and Erie Canal, and even as far as Michigan City. He also kept at his house west of town woolen cloths, which were either sold for cash or traded for wool.
During the Civil war the manufacture of woolen goods was a brisk industry everywhere that it could be conducted. At Monticello the prospects were so good that Kingsbury and Lynch renewed the lease of the water power necessary to run their factory for another ten years.
296
HISTORY OF WHITE COUNTY
The other establishments on the dam did the same, and all through the war that locality hummed with business. In 1866 Markle and Cowdin erected the woolen factory on the east side of the river. The Dales, Keefer and Roberts and perhaps others were afterward identified with it, but about 1880 the building was outfitted as a merchant grist mill and later was destroyed by fire.
THE TIPPECANOE HYDRAULIC COMPANY
In April, 1872, the Tippecanoe Hydraulic Company had been organ- ized as an indirect successor to the old Monticello Company. Its object was the development of the water power at or near the county seat, and its first trustees were Albert Reynolds, W. S. Ayres, Robert M. Strait, J. C. Blake and William Braden. The Monticello Lumbering and Barrel Heading Manufacturing Company was formed at about the same time, its projectors being mostly members of the Hydraulic Company.
NELSON B. LOUGHRY AND SONS
Among the first to take advantage of the improved conditions brought about by the reorganization of local hydraulic and manufacturing inter- ests was Nelson B. Loughry, a Pennsylvanian by birth, who had migrated to Lafayette with his family when forty years of age. At the time of his departure for the West he had become somewhat prominent both as a merchant and a public man. In 1858 he moved with his wife and family to Monon Township, where for about fourteen years he was engaged in milling and agriculture, in which pursuits his three sons received a thorough training. It was in 1872, the year of the organiza- tion of the Tippecanoe Hydraulic Company, that Mr. Loughry purchased the mill which had been erected in 1850 and promptly set to work to improve it. Both in this work and in the subsequent operation of the plant Mr. Loughry had the efficient assistance of his sons, Joseph E., Albert W. and Cloyd. Joseph E. had had active charge of the milling interests since 1869 and in 1872 the firm of Loughry Brothers was formed. The father died in 1890. It is needless to say, except for the benefit of strangers in that part of the state, that under the management of the three Loughry brothers it has become one of the best equipped mills in Northern Indiana. In the early period of their industrial and business career, the Loughrys also operated a furniture factory opposite their mill. They also promoted other lines of manufacture, became interested in the financial matters of Monticello and for a number of years were considered perhaps the leading men of affairs in White County, and, after all these years, they are still leaders.
BECOMES A RAILROAD TOWN
The early '50s were charged with great expectations and resulted in not a few actualities. Although the people were disappointed over the
297
HISTORY OF WHITE COUNTY
fact that the New Albany and Salem Railway did not materialize in Monticello, the Logansport, Peoria & Burlington was actually completed and Monticello made a station. The village was also incorporated in 1853, the streets were drained and graded and sidewalks built and im- proved. The county seat was made a little uneasy by the founding of Reynolds in 1854, and its rise for a number of years, but considered that its advantages over its ambitious sister to the west were made permanently superior when what is now known as the Pittsburgh, Chicago and St. Louis Railroad was completed through the township in 1859, thus giving the village a western outlet. Trains did not commence to pass over the Tippecanoe River to the eastward until January, 1860, which marked the completion of the L'ogansport, Peoria and Burlington line.
MONTICELLO IN 1852
During the period of the early '50s the churches of Monticello had obtained a foothold and no class of its citizens had a better opportunity to observe people and conditions than the ministers. One of the Metho- dist clergy, Rev. L. Nebeker, thus draws his picture: "My personal recollections of this place began in the fall of 1852, when appointed by Bishop Baker at the first session of the Northwest Indiana Conference, held at Terre Haute that year. On my arrival I was directed to Dr. Rifenberrick's for a temporary home. We were cordially received by the Doctor and his good wife, the latter still living in Greencastle as the widow of the late Rev. Daniel De Mott.
"The church was new, having been built and dedicated under the administration of the Rev. John Leach, one year intervening between his and my term, filled by Rev. R. H. Calvert. This was a year of turmoil. Mr. Calvert got into difficulty with a local preacher by the name of John Kistler and produced partisan feeling throughout the entire circuit, which reached as far west as Palestine, fifteen miles. One half of the year passed before a reconciliation could be effected.
"There were at that time in the medical profession in Monticello, Drs. Rifenberrick, Spencer (father of Dr. William Spencer), Gray, Haymond and Brearley, the last not practicing.
"In the law my recollection takes in only 'Bob' Sill and David Turpie, now of Indianapolis. Rowland Hughes, Jonathan P. Ritchey, Daniel Tilton and 'Cub' Reynolds were the merchants, all selling gro- ceries, boots, shoes and notions. Isaac Reynolds and Dr. Brearley owned and managed the mill at the west end of the dam. Crose & McElhoe were partners running a blacksmith shop. A Mr. Kiefhaber also ran one. There were two Presbyterian churches, Old and New schools, pre- sided over respectively by Rev. John Wampler and Rev. George D. Miller. These, with the Methodist, constituted the religious organizations of the place at that time.
"Here I found D. F. Barnes, now of the Michigan conference, an honored member, having a number of times been sent by that body and now leads the delegation in the next general conference. The family
298
HISTORY OF WHITE COUNTY
were in moderate circumstances and in some way connected with the woolen mill here. Young Barnes, then in his teens, had attended the winter school and at the close took part in the closing literary exercises. Noticing the lad was gifted with a fine oratorical voice and exhibited good taste and modest demeanor, I suggested the propriety of attending college.
"Daniel Dale was a character in those days. Though he lived at 'Git-away' (Burnettsville) he was frequently in Monticello. I have a very vivid recollection of my first interview with the old gentleman. He was a loud talker, rather dogmatic in manner, and spoke with a great deal of positiveness. The question of securing a railroad to this place was the topic. An east and west road going out from Logansport was under contemplation.
" 'How much will it require to secure the road through Monticello ?' I inquired. He named the amount. I said it would be hard to raise so large an amount of money, would it not ?
" 'Oh, no,' said he, 'if you can get the people together and pump an acre and a half of thunder and lightning into them, the money can be raised easily.'
"There was another son of the old gentleman, Levi, living then at Delphi, long since dead. He was an attorney and frequently visited Monticello; a kind of Lincoln style physique, and somewhat in his fond- ness for repartee-quite a plain man. On one occasion, meeting him here, I was surprised to see a reckless display of jewelry. Among other things a very large metal watch chain hung about his neck and down to his watch in the vest pocket.
"I said, 'Brother Dale, you seem to be coming out.'
" 'Yes, I have determined to be rich if it costs me all I am worth.'
"Since then I have seen a great many who seemed to have come to the same determination.
"There were, some eight or ten miles west, in the neighborhood of Ashbury Chapel, some Virginians who had entered land and were mak- ing farms. If they were not the titled F. F. V.'s they certainly were worthy of it. Abel T. Smith and William Vanscoy, with their families, will be remembered and honored by those who knew them, and their impress on society will be felt for generations by those who did not know them. *
"I shall never forget my first visit to Palestine, the western extremity of the circuit. After leaving Brother Thompson's, a little southeast of where Reynolds now stands, there was a wild stretch of six or seven miles without a human habitation. Having passed this and found a man building fence, I inquired of him for Palestine.
"'Do you see that schoolhouse up on the ridge yonder ?' pointing to a round-log building with clapboard roof weighted down with heavy poles, about a quarter of a mile away, but in plain view on an oak ridge.
" 'Yes,' I said.
" 'Well, that is Palestine.'
299
HISTORY OF WHITE COUNTY
"I hardly need say my dreams of a land of milk and honey with grapes of Eschol vanished quicker than it takes to tell you."
During the pastorate of Brother Leach he made an appointment to preach at the Monon schoolhouse on a week night. It was the fall of the year, the evenings were getting long, and at the time of which we speak the air was crisp and cool, when the preacher, accompanied by Brother Will Bott, and, by the way, incidents and anecdotes will be in- complete without Brother Bott's name, together with many others fig- uring in it. The preacher and Will, late in the afternoon, took up their journey for the evening appointment, giving themselves just time to reach the place by the time the people were there. Arriving, they found the people on hand, and had kindled a fire in the box stove that occupied the middle of the floor, and from the opening at the hearth proceeded all the light they had. On the arrival of the preacher and his traveling companion, all conversation ceased, which up to that time had embraced all the range of crops, coon hunts, corn huskings and general neighbor- hood gossip, and everything was quiet, subdued and dark.
"As Brother Leach sat warming himself and musing on the situation, the spirit of song took possession of him, and, though I can't afford to give you much music in this lecture, at the price I get for it, I will give you this as sung by the preacher that night while warming by the stove :
" 'Plunged in a gulf of dark despair, We wretched sinners lay, Without one cheering beam of hope Or spark of glimmering day.'
"While the hymn was being sung some parties slipped out to the nearest neighbors and returned with candles to light up the house."
VILLAGE GOVERNMENT ABANDONED
The incorporation of the Village of Monticello was soon followed by the election of the following officers: Jacob Hanaway, Ferdinand Keifhaber, William S. Haymond, A. V. Reed and John Wilson, trus- tees; John R. Willey, marshal, clerk, treasurer and assessor. The vil- lage form of government, as inaugurated in 1853, only endured for a year, and was then abandoned by mutual consent.
WALKER'S, JENNERS' AND REYNOLDS' ADDITION
Up to this time two additions had been made to the original plat, both of them within three years after the town was laid out. The par- ticulars of these accessions to its area are thus presented by the late Milton M. Sill: "Little opportunity was given to non-resident land speculators to obtain land in the immediate vicinity of the county seat, as it was all taken by the resident settlers very soon after the county seat was located. Messrs. Jacob Walker and William M. Jenners, of Lafayette, and Benjamin Reynolds, of Big Creek township, succeeded,
300
HISTORY OF WHITE COUNTY
however, in purchasing land of George R. Bartley adjoining the original plat of the town on the south and west, and laid out the first addition to the town on the twenty-seventh day of October, 1836. It was named Walker's, Jenners' and Reynolds' addition to Monticello, and still re- tains the name. It consisted of one hundred and thirty-four lots, with streets and alleys, the streets varying in width from Railroad street one hundred feet to Water street thirty feet, and the streets and alleys in the original were extended through their addition of the same width as in the original plat. The venture did not prove to be a financial success, as town lots were not ready sale at the prices asked by the proprietors, and Mr. Reynolds parted with his interest in the addition soon after it was laid out.
BARR'S ADDITION
"The Board of County Commissioners directed the county agent (Mr. Barr) by an order, entered of record, to lay out and plat the remaining land donated for the county seat, and accordingly, on the 27th day of April, 1837, one hundred and five lots were added to the original plat, and called Barr's addition, to designate it from the town first platted. Two additional streets were platted in Mr. Barr's addition, one on the north marking the northern limit of the land donated, and named North street, running east and west parellel with the streets in the original plat and sixty-six feet in width, and one on the river bank, one hundred feet in width, connecting Main Cross street on the south with North street and used by the traveling public to gain access to the ferry landing located about midway between Washington street and Main Cross street ; but after the removal of the ferry landing to the foot of Marion street, the southern part of River street was abandoned, and that portion of it south of Washington street was never afterward used as a public thor- oughfare.
"With the addition of Mr. Barr's and Walker's, Jenners' and Rey- nolds' to the original plat, Monticello assumed the proportions of a town on paper, but was in fact only a respectable village. A few lots in the new addition were sold, mainly those on the east side of Tippecanoe street, between Main Cross and Marion streets, they being much larger than those in the original plat, and more than twice the size of the largest lot in the Walker addition, but the sales were made chiefly to residents who already owned vacant and unimproved lots in the original plat, and if improvement was made on their new purchase it was only a stable or fence enclosing their lot for the purpose of utilizing it for a calf pasture.
"The supply of lots far exceeded the demand, and though the prices asked were ridiculously low, but few were disposed of for several years after the Barr addition was made to the town.
BOOM NOT IN EVIDENCE
"Those who had purchased town lots at the first sale, expecting a boom in prices by reason of the selection of Monticello as the county
Courtesy of C. L. Foster
IN AND ABOUT MONTICELLO :
(A, B) TIPPECANOE RIVER, EAST OF THE PUBLIC LIBRARY ; (c) TIPPECANOE STREET, NORTH FROM PUBLIC LIBRARY ; (D) A PLEASANT RIVER SCENE
302
HISTORY OF WHITE COUNTY
seat were grievously disappointed. No boom was realized. Grass grew in the streets and dog fennel and other noxious weeds covered the vacant lots on the west and south of the original plat, and cattle, horses, sheep and hogs roamed at will through the town. Invidious remarks were made that the town was finished and only needed fencing to make a suitable pasture field for the stock. Some wicked boys and young men, acting on this suggestion, one summer night, whilst their parents were peacefully slumbering in bed and perhaps dreaming of the future profits to be realized from the sale of their vacant lots, actually did build a rail fence across the two principal streets (Main and Main Cross), taking the rails from the neighboring fields adjoining the town. The fence was well constructed and duly staked and double ridered, and completely spanned the two streets on the south and east of the court house square. The perpetrators of this indignity were never discovered, and but little effort was made to find them. The fence was removed in the morning by the owners of the rails, who were the only parties whose equanimity was seriously disturbed by the boys' foolish prank.
"After the organization of the Hydraulic Company and the improve- ment of the water power, the town improved somewhat and lots increased in value, eligible sites for business houses and residences on the principal streets selling for one hundred dollars, and in a few instances more. This was a great advance over former prices, and property owners began to assume a more cheerful demeanor.
THIRD TOWN ADDITION
"The third addition to the town was made by James C. Reynolds on the 16th day of December, 1854. It consisted of fourteen lots on the west side and fronting Illinois street, between Washington and North streets.
"There was no crying demand for additional town lots at that time. There were vacant, unimproved lots fronting on every street of the town to the number of one hundred or more, in the aggregate, awaiting purchasers at prices ranging all the way from ten to one hundred and fifty dollars, so that the supply already far exceeded the demand, but he succeeded in disposing of a few lots between Washington and Marion streets, and frame buildings were built on them by the purchasers.
CIVIL WAR OVERSHADOWS ALL
"The Logansport, Peoria and Burlington Railroad, now a part of the Pennsylvania system known as the Panhandle, after a long delay from its beginning, was completed in 1860, the first train passing through Monticello on the first day of January of that year. With a railroad the hope that the county seat question was finally settled was entertained by the real estate property owners of Monticello, and their hope was realized to a greater or less extent, probably more on account of the War of the Rebellion, beginning early in the year 1861, than the
Need help finding more records? Try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.