Cape May County NJ Church Records
USA (1,403,636) > New Jersey (19,322) > Cape May County (387) > Cape May County Church Records (45)
USA (1,403,636) > New Jersey (19,322) > New Jersey Church Records (3,244) > Cape May County Church Records (45)
NOTE: Additional records that apply to Cape May County are also on the New Jersey Church Records page.
Cape May County Church Records
A history of the First Presbyterian Church, Cape May, New Jersey, 1851- 1951 FamilySearch Library
Cape May meeting : minutes. WorldCat
Early church records of Atlantic & Cape May counties, New Jersey WorldCat
First Cape May Baptist Church Marriages; 1700s-1800s US Gen Web Archives
Marriage Records From Cape May and Egg Harbor Friends' Meeting Records, 1726-1837 New Horizons Genealogical Services
Marriage records from the First Baptist Church, Cape May court house, New Jersey : Goshen Methodist Church, Goshen, New Jersey, and Cape May county bible records, 1742-1950 FamilySearch Library
New Jersey Births and Christenings Index, 1660-1931 Ancestry
New Jersey, United Methodist Church Records, 1800-1970 Ancestry
South Jersey church records : baptisms, marriages, deaths, 1830-1900 WorldCat
South Jersey church records : baptisms, marriages, deaths, 1857-1930 WorldCat
Churches in Cape May County in 1926
In 1926 the federal government took a Census of Religious Bodies. The 70 churches listed here reported from Cape May County. For more information, see our article on Using the 1926 Census of Religious Bodies.
Bellaplain
Bellaplain M. E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Paul J. Myers
Burleigh
Burleigh M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Garner T. Hand
Cape May
Allen A.M.E. Church – African Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey Conference. Pastor: A. G. Casper
Beermont Union A.M.E. Church – Union American Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey Conference. Pastor: J. H. Cannon
Cape Island Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, West New Jersey Association - Northern Baptist Convention. Pastor: William Hunter
First Methodist Episcopal Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Edward W. Graham
Franklin St. M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Delaware. Pastor: W. H. Johnson
Macedonia – Baptist, West New Jersey Baptist Association. Pastor: James A. Jones
Second Baptist Church of Cape May Court House – Negro Baptists, Bethany Baptist Association, N.J. Pastor: Thomas H. Herring
St. Mary Star of the Sea – Roman Catholic Church, Trenton. Pastor: E. P. Kennedy
Cape May C.H
Unnamed congregation – Seventh-day Adventist, N.J. Conf. Pastor: Schmidt
Cape May Court House
Asbury M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: James A. R. Corliss
Cape May Court House, Methodist – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: William Ewen
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, West New Jersey Baptist Association. Pastor: Charles N. Hamer
Cape May Point
Friendship Mission – African Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: W. H. Anderson
Dennisville
First Methodist E. of Dennisville – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: E. F. W. Eastlow
Shiloh – Negro Baptists, Ebenezer Bay Asso. of So. Jersey. Pastor: Grant Harris
Dias Creek
Dias Creek M. E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Chas. T. Hand
Eldora
Eldora M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Paul J. Myers
Erma
Tabernacle, Erma Charge – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey Conference, Bridgeton District. Pastor: L. V. Brown
Goshen
Goshen M. E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Chas. T. Hand
Immanuel Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, West Jersey. Pastor: William Henry Cox
Mission of St. Elizabeth Catholic Church – Roman Catholic Church, Trenton, N.J.
Green Creek
Bethel – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: P. S. Sampson
Marmora
Beesleys Point M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey, Bridgeton District. Pastor: Walter L. Yerkes
Middle Township
John Wesley – Methodist Episcopal Church, Delaware. Pastor: R. A. F. Graham
North Wildwood
First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, West New Jersey Association. Pastor: Herbert J. Punchard
North Wildwood – Methodist Episcopal Church, Bridgeton District, N.J. Conference. Pastor: W. H. Libe
Ocean City
First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, Camden Association. Pastor: Chas. W. Shelley
First Methodist – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Norman Vincent Sargent
Macedonia – Methodist Episcopal Church, Delaware. Pastor: J. Lee Sawyer
St. Augustine's – Roman Catholic Church, Diocese of Trenton, N.J. Pastor: Thomas F. Blake
St. James A.M.E. Church – African Methodist Episcopal Church. Pastor: F. J. Wolford
St. John's Ev. Lutheran Church – United Lutheran Church in America, Phila. Eng. Conf. of the Ministerium of Penna. Pastor: Clinton F. Hildebrand Jr.
The First Spiritualist – National Spiritualist Association, N.J. State. Pastor: Licentiate Missionary
The Tabernacle Baptist – Negro Baptists, New Jersey Baptist Association & Convention. Pastor: Joseph T. Payne
Palermo
2nd Cape May Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, West Asso. Pastor: Everett M. Stoffels
Peermont
First M.E. Church of Avalon – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Charles E. String
Petersburg
Petersburg M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Walter L. Yerkes
Rio Grand
Rio Grand – Northern Baptist Convention, West Jersey. Pastor: William Henry Cox
Rio Grande
Rio Grand M. E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey, Bridgeton District. Pastor: P. S. Sampson
Rio Grande – Church of the Nazarene, Washington Philadelphia District. Pastor: Byron Maybury
Sea Isle
Messiah at Sea Isle City, Church of Our Savior – United Lutheran Church in America, East Penna Synod. Pastor: B. Nelson Bair
Sea Isle City Methodist Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: H. F. Von Uffel
St. Joseph's Catholic Church – Roman Catholic Church, Trenton, N.J. Pastor: Aloysius Pozzi
Seaville
Seaville M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Walter L. Yerkes
So. Dennis
Memorial Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, West Jersey Association. Pastor: William E. Bisgrove
Trinity Methodist – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: E. F. W. Eastlow
So. Seaville
Calvary Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, W. Jersey Association. Pastor: William E. Bisgrove
So. Seaville M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: E. F. W. Eastlow
Stone Harbor
Bethel Union A.M.E. Church – Union American Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey Conference. Pastor: Wm. H. Decker
Church of Our Savior – United Lutheran Church in America, East Penna Synod. Pastor: L. Upton Bair
St. Paul's – Roman Catholic Church, Trenton, N.J. Pastor: James A. Moroney
Strathmere
Strathmere M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: Harry H. Pratt
Tuckahoe
Methodist Episcopal – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey. Pastor: C. D. Lawrence
Whitesboro
First Baptist – Baptist, Bethany Association, New Jersey State Convention. Pastor: John J. McCue
St. Stephens – African Methodist Episcopal Church, First Episcopal District. Pastor: W. C. Hoover
Wildwood
Unnamed congregation – Plymouth Brethren IV
Angel Rest – Negro Baptists. Pastor: F. E. Ingram
Asbury A.M.E. Church – African Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey Conference. Pastor: S. C. Sturdey
Christian Science Society – Church of Christ, Scientist
Eureka – Negro Baptists
Eureka Baptist Church – Baptist, West Jersey Association
First Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, West Association. Pastor: Irvin W. Fisher
First Methodist Episcopal Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, New Jersey Conference. Pastor: DeWitt C. Cobb
Holy Trinity Lutheran Church – United Lutheran Church in America, Ministerium of Pennsylvania. Pastor: Paul J. Neff
St. Ann's – Roman Catholic Church, Trenton, N.J. Pastor: James A. Moroney
Woodbine
1st Woodbine B. P. Church – Negro Baptists, Bethany. Pastor: Isaac Hulme
Heard's Chapel A. M. E. Mission – African Methodist Episcopal Church. Pastor: Virginia Lattimore
St. Casimir's – Roman Catholic Church, Trenton
Additions or corrections to this page? We welcome your suggestions through our Contact Us page