Andover Church Records
Andover Presbyterian Church, Register, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, and Deaths, 1838-1947 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Andover Presbyterian Church, Register, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, and Deaths, 1892-1964 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Andover Township, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1863-1867 FamilySearch Library
Byram Church Records Clove Church Records Deckertown Church Records Frankford Church Records Franklin in Sussex County Church Records Fredon Church Records Green Church Records Hardiston Church Records Hardyston Church Records
Hardyston Memorial : A History of the Township and the North Presbyterian Church, Hardyston, Sussex County, New Jersey Ancestry
Hardyston memorial : a history of the township and the North Presbyterian Church, Hardyston, Sussex County, New Jersey FamilySearch Library
Hardyston memorial : a history of the township and the North Presbyterian Church, Hardyston, Sussex County, New Jersey LDS Genealogy
Hardyston memorial : a history of the township and the North Presbyterian Church, Hardyston, Sussex County, New Jersey Internet Archive
Lafayette Church Records Montague Church Records
Church records for the Congregation of Mennisink, now town of Montague, Sussex County, New Jersey, and for the Reformed Dutch Church of Magagkamok, now Port Jervis, town of Deerpark, Orange County, New York, 1737-1816 FamilySearch Library
Listing of those buried at the Montague Reformed Church Cemetery WorldCat
Minisink Valley Reformed Dutch Church records WorldCat
Montague Township, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1848-1867 FamilySearch Library
Old Dutch records of the Machackemech and Menissinck churches : Port Jervis, N.Y. and Montague, N.J. WorldCat
Two and one quarter centuries on Old Mine Road : the history of Minisink Reformed Church, 1737-1962, Montague, New Jersey FamilySearch Library
Newton Church Records
A History of Christ Church, New Jersey Ancestry
A history of the Yellow Frame Presbyterian Church, Fredon Township, Sussex County, New Jersey FamilySearch Library
Centennial, Presbytery of Newton Ancestry
Fifth annual homecoming of the Yellow Frame Presbyterian Church : in memory of Robert Brown Foresman, June 13, 1937 FamilySearch Library
The One Hundred Fiftieth Anniversary of the First Presbyterian Church, Newton, NJ Ancestry
The One hundred fiftieth anniversary of the First Presbyterian Church, Newton, N.J. : 1786-1936 FamilySearch Library
The first century of Newton Methodism, 1831-1931 FamilySearch Library
Sandyston Church Records Sparta Church Records
Proceedings of the Centennial Anniversary of the Presbyterian Church at Sparta, N.J., November 23, 1886 Ancestry
Proceedings of the centennial anniversary of the Presbyterian Church at Sparta, N.J., November 23, 1886 : together with a history of the village FamilySearch Library
Sparta Township, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1848-1867 FamilySearch Library
Sparta, Sussex Co., NJ, Presbyterian Church Membership, 1805-1887 Jane Devlin
Stillwater Church Records Filter By Year: Go Remove Filter
Baptismal records of the First Presbyterian Church of Stillwater, Sussex County, New Jersey : 200th anniversary, 1769-1969 FamilySearch Library
Baptisms in Hartwick Church, New Jersey, 1780-1819 FamilySearch Library
First Presbyterian Church, Register, 1780-1819 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
First Presbyterian Church, Register, Births, Marriages, and Deaths, 1792-1886 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
First Presbyterian Church, Session and Register, 1792-1825 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
First Presbyterian Church, Session and Register, 1838-1908 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
First Presbyterian Church, Session and Register, 1886-1954 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Marriages in Stillwater Presbyterian Church, Stillwater, Sussex County, New Jersey FamilySearch Library
Stillwater Township, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1849-1867 FamilySearch Library
Sussex Church Records Filter By Year: Go Remove Filter
175th anniversary, First Baptist Church of Sussex, 1756-1931 : Sussex, New Jersey, a brief history FamilySearch Library
Beemerville Presbyterian Church, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, Deaths, 1834-1936 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Church records, 1835-1948 (Wantage First Church (Sussex, New Jersey : Presbyterian)) FamilySearch Library
Church records, 1839-1893 (Third Presbyterian Church of Wantage (Deckertown, New Jersey)) FamilySearch Library
First Presbyterian Church, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, Deaths, 1893-1933 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
History of the First Baptist Church of Wantage, Sussex, N.J. WorldCat
History of the First Baptist Church of Wantage, Sussex, New Jersey Ancestry
History of the First Presbyterian Church, Sussex, New Jersey, 1839-1979 FamilySearch Library
History of the First Presbyterian Church, Sussex, New Jersey, 1839-1979 Ancestry
Sussex, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1850-1851 FamilySearch Library
Third Presbyterian Church, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, Deaths, 1866-1880 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Third Presbyterian Church, Births, Marriages, Deaths, 1880-1893 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Wantage First Presbyterian Church, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, 1835-1885 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Wantage First Presbyterian Church, Baptisms, Births, Marriages, Deaths, 1876-1902 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Wantage Presbyterian Church, Session and Register, 1835-1915 (in US Presbyterian Church Records collection) Ancestry
Vernon Church Records Walpack Church Records Filter By Year: Go Remove Filter
Churchbook of the Congregation of Walpeck [i.e. Walpack], N.J., 1741-1830 FamilySearch Library
Congregational list of those who ... have been admitted as members of the Nether Dutch Reformed Church in the congregation of Walpeck (sic) FamilySearch Library
Dutch Reformed Church, Walpack, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1741-1830 FamilySearch Library
Minisink Valley Reformed Dutch Church records, WorldCat
Records Minisink-Machackemeck church record ... : Minisink church record ... : Machackemeck church record ... Walpeck [sic] church record ... WorldCat
Records, baptisms and marriages, 1741-1810 (Old Dutch Reformed Church (Walpack Township, New Jersey)) FamilySearch Library
Reformed (Dutch) Church of Walpack Ancestry
Reformed (Dutch) Church of Walpack, historical discourse : preached at the dedication of the Reformed Church at Bushkill, Penn., January 13th, 1874 FamilySearch Library
Walpack Township, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1850-1867 FamilySearch Library
Wantage Church Records Filter By Year: Go Remove Filter
Clove Valley Dutch Reformed Church, Wantage, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1785-1818 FamilySearch Library
Computer printout of Wantage, Clove Valley Dutch Reformed Church, Sussex, Newj FamilySearch Library
History of the First Baptist Church of Wantage, Sussex, New Jersey FamilySearch Library
Outline of the history of the First Baptist Church of Wantage, Sussex County, N.J. FamilySearch Library
Records of the Clove Dutch Reformed Church of Clove Valley New York Genealogical and Biographical Society at FindMyPast
Records of the First Baptist Church of Deckertown, Sussex, New Jersey : Orange Baptist Church, Orange County, New York, Mt. Salem Baptist Church, New Jersey FamilySearch Library
The Presbyterian Church records, Newtown (now Elmhurst), L. I., N. Y. : The Reformed Dutch Church Records and the Presbyterian Church records at Smithfield, Pa. Clove Dutch Reformed Church records, of Clove Valley, Wantage, N. J FamilySearch Library
Wantage Township, Sussex, New Jersey computer printout; births or christenings, 1848-1867 FamilySearch Library
In 1926 the federal government took a Census of Religious Bodies. The 27 churches listed here reported from Sussex County. For more information, see our article on Using the 1926 Census of Religious Bodies .
Filter by town, denomination or pastor:
Andover
First M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference, Paterson District. Pastor: L. G. Gunn
Baleville
Baleville Christian Church – Christian Church (General Convention of the Christian Church), New Jersey. Pastor: E. E. Huffman
Branchville
Branchville-Frankford Plains – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference, Paterson District. Pastor: Joseph M. Blessing
Glenwood
Glenwood Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, North New Jersey Baptist Association. Pastor: W. H. Shawger
Hainesville
Hainesville M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: L. Merritt LaGrone
Hamburg
Hamburg Baptist Church – Northern Baptist Convention, North New Jersey Asso. Pastor: Martin Brynildsen
Lafayette
Lafayette M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference, Paterson District. Pastor: Roy E. Graves
Layton
Layton M.E. – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: C. Merritt LaGrone
Monroe
Monroe Christian Church – Christian Church (General Convention of the Christian Church), New Jersey
Montague
Minisink – Reformed Church in America, Classis of Wawayanda. Pastor: W. E. Phifer
Newton
First – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: John G. Little
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention. Pastor: John Mierop
Gospel Hall – Plymouth Brethren II
Ogdensburg
Ogdensburg Methodist Episcopal Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference, Jersey City District. Pastor: Fred B. Wilcox
Sparta
Sparta First Methodist Episcopal Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference, Jersey City District. Pastor: Fred B. Wilcox
Stanhope
Stanhope M.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: George Oreson
Stillwater
Stillwater – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference. Pastor: Henry S. James
Stockholm
Stockholm Methodist Episcopal Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: Arthur H. Wallace
Sussex
First Baptist – Northern Baptist Convention, North New Jersey Baptist Association. Pastor: Harry Schoener
Sussex Methodist Episcopal Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference, Jersey City District. Pastor: Nevie Cutlip
Swartswood
Swartswood – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference. Pastor: Henry S. James
Vernon
Vernon Moethodist Church Vernon + Glenwood – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: Geo. R. Warren
Walpack
Walpack Centre – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: C. M. LaGrone
Wantage
Wantage Methodist Episcopal Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark Conference, Jersey City District
Town not stated
Colesville Meth.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: William G. Bowering
Libertyville Meth.E. Church – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark
Tranquility – Methodist Episcopal Church, Newark. Pastor: T. W. Dolman
Not sure what to do next in your genealogy research? We have 