USA > New York > Ontario County > History of Ontario county, New York : with illustrations and family sketches of some of the prominent men and families > Part 18
Note: The text from this book was generated using artificial intelligence so there may be some errors. The full pages can be found on Archive.org (link on the Part 1 page).
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16 | Part 17 | Part 18 | Part 19 | Part 20 | Part 21 | Part 22 | Part 23 | Part 24 | Part 25 | Part 26 | Part 27 | Part 28 | Part 29 | Part 30 | Part 31 | Part 32 | Part 33 | Part 34 | Part 35 | Part 36 | Part 37 | Part 38 | Part 39 | Part 40 | Part 41 | Part 42 | Part 43 | Part 44 | Part 45 | Part 46 | Part 47 | Part 48 | Part 49 | Part 50 | Part 51 | Part 52 | Part 53 | Part 54 | Part 55 | Part 56 | Part 57 | Part 58 | Part 59 | Part 60 | Part 61 | Part 62 | Part 63 | Part 64 | Part 65 | Part 66 | Part 67 | Part 68 | Part 69 | Part 70 | Part 71 | Part 72 | Part 73 | Part 74 | Part 75 | Part 76 | Part 77 | Part 78 | Part 79 | Part 80 | Part 81 | Part 82 | Part 83 | Part 84 | Part 85 | Part 86 | Part 87 | Part 88 | Part 89 | Part 90 | Part 91 | Part 92 | Part 93 | Part 94 | Part 95 | Part 96 | Part 97 | Part 98 | Part 99 | Part 100
According to Hon. Lewis H. Morgan, LL.D., who is the acknowl- edged standard authority on Seneca names, the name in the several Iroquois dialects is as follows : Seneca, Ga-nun· da-gwa; Cayuga, Ga-na da gwa; Onondaga, Ca-na-da- qua; Tuscarora, Ca-ta- na- ra-qua; Oneida, Ga-na da-lo-qua ; Mohawk, Ga-na-ta- la qua; the signification being " A Place Selected for a Settlement," or, in other words, "the chosen spot or city," a fact itself of much significance in view of later events, for the Indian location or " spot chosen for a new settlement " was also selected by the Phelps and Gorham proprietary as their " chosen spot or city," after they had been compelled to leave the vicinity of old Kanadesaga; and a little later the same "chosen spot" was designated as the shire town of the county, and was therefore destined to become a somewhat important point in Western New York in the affairs of civilized white settlement as it had been formerly prominent in connection with the Indian occupation of the region. However, as the subject of Indian supremacy and dominion is fully discussed in the early chapters of this volume, it need not be further pursued here, but rather may we give attention to the development and improvement of the town during its occupation by the whites.
As is fully narrated in one of the earlier chapters of this work, in the year 1788 the region of country now including this whole county was sold by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts to Oliver Phelps and Nathaniel Gorham, they representing an association of eastern capital- ists. As soon as they had secured the Indian title they at once caused the entire tract to be surveyed into townships, and each numbered by range and town. For the purpose of better carrying out their designs, the proprietors made a location for a village at the ancient Indian site called Kanadesaga, also Geneva, but on running the eastern line of the Massachusetts lands it was discovered that the village was east of the so-called pre-emption line and therefore not within the purchase proper. We may here state incidentally that Geneva was on the west side of the line, but owing either to error or fraud the line was so run
200
HISTORY OF ONTARIO COUNTY.
as to bring that village eastward of it and on lands claimed by other proprietors.
Whether error or fraud located Geneva east of the pre- emption line matters little at this time, but the circumstance was indeed fortunate for the after history of Canandaigua. The proprietary were compelled to change their seat of operations from Geneva, consequently in 1789 Mr. Phelps caused township number Io, in the third range, to be resurveyed and allotted for more than usual townships and agricultural purposes. Moreover, the town was especially reserved to the proprie- tors for their own use, also as a county town, for it seems that the worthy proprietor even at that early day had in contemplation the erection of a new county out of the territory of old Montgomery.
Oliver Phelps made generous provision for the future of the pro- spective village, and indeed carried out the New England custom of donating lands for. county buildings, park and schools, and likewise laid out the main thoroughfare of the village of ample width, having a consideration for the personal comfort of the people as well as for private gain.
Col. William Walker acted as agent for the proprietors, and to him has been given the honor of erecting the first house in the town-a log structure built during the year 1788, and standing on the east side of the main street, south of the square ; the contract for the erection of this building will be found in the chapter of the town of Phelps. Two other dwellings were built during the same year, one for James D. Fish, and the other for Joseph Smith, but none of these was perma- nently occupied by its owner until the following spring. Smith soon turned his dwelling into an inn, thus becoming the pioneer landlord of the vicinity.
Joseph Smith was a prominent character at an early day at Canan- daigua. He had been a captive among the Indians, and when set free he chose to remain among them. He was an open-hearted, generous man, and possessed many good qualities. As an Indian interpreter his services were often in requisition. He was in business in this region as early as October and November, 1788, as the following bills receipted by him, and yet in existence, will show: November 22, bill against William Walker, for " Mogassens," rum, salt, etc., £21 Is. Bill against
201
TOWN OF CANANDAIGUA.
William Walker, for sundries furnished by Smith & Vrooman, to differ- ent persons, £8 04s. 7d. As no place is mentioned in the above bills, it is uncertain whether they were furnished at Canandaigua or Geneva, but from the following receipt for goods stored by Walker on his de- parture from the place for the winter, it would seem that Canandaigua must at the time have been his residence, although on account of the familiarity and friendship of the Indians, the goods would doubtless remain undisturbed even if he was not permanently here during the winter:
KANANDAIGUE, Nov'r 19, 1788.
Bill of articles belonging to the Hon'ble Mess'rs Phelps & Comp'y, William Walker, Esq'r, Agent.
I Chest containing
I Broad ax, 9 Narrow Do., I Bush Hook, 2 Fros and one hoe, I Drawing knife, I twist augur, I p'r Carpenters Chitzels, I Hand Saw, I nail hammer, 2 Iron Wedges, I Small Broken Chain, I Bake Pan, I Spider, I Skillet, I Earthen Plate, I Pewter Do., I Tin Qt mug, I case knife & 2 forks, ¿ H. old Pewter, about 3 qts Salt, I Small Brass Kettle, Ring of Iron, I Crane Hook, 31 Candles, I Iron Hinge, one Sitting Pole Iron, I Door Hook and some small pieces of Iron.
I Batteau, 3 Oars, I Paddle, 3 Setting Poles and Boat House, 5 Empty Barrels, and one Large Iron pot and one Grindstone.
Re'd the above Chest containing said Articles together with Said Batteau, Oars, &c and Empty Barels, into my care, all of which are to be safely kept and to be delivered to William Walker, Esq'r or to his order, when called for. Extraordinaries Excepted.
JOSEPH SMITH
JAMES PERRY for Joseph Smitlı
Endorsed, Joseph Smith's Rec't for Articles left at Canandaiqua.
The memorandum book kept by Colonel Wm. Walker contains the names of a number of people who were early on the ground in the new country and employed by him in October, 1788. The following are ex tracted therefrom : Colonel Hugh Maxwell, surveyor, and Samuel Whe don, Brown and two others, assistants. Frederick Saxton, surveyor ; Wm. Markham, Capt. Cleveland, Phinehas Blodget and Ranson Smith, assistants. Mr. Curtis, surveyor, Joseph Salisbury, Robert White, Ad-
26
202
HISTORY OF ONTARIO COUNTY.
ner Hickox, John Fanning, assistants. William Ewing, surveyor, Henry Reading, Andrew Evers, Benoni Taylor. Four men on the road on the falls on the outlet of Canadaque, Cornelius Decker, John Jones, E. Phelps, John Culver. Also the following: David Bailey, chain bearer, James Parmeter, Enos Boughton, Sewell and Othniel Gilbert, James Dugan, Rees Stevens.
The first permanent settlement in the town was made in 1789, when Fish and Smith occupied their respective houses, and about the same time there also came to the locality General Israel Chapin, Nathaniel Gorham, jr., Frederick Saxton, Benjamin Gardner, Daniel Gates, Dan- iel Brainerd, Martin Dudley. These pioneers were soon followed by others, and in the same year William Walker opened his land office in the village. First events followed one another in rapid succession, and from preserved records we learn that pioneer Samuel Gardner opened the first store, while Major Willis taught the first school, beginning in 1792. The first birth was that of Oliver Phelps Rice, and the first death was that of Caleb Walker, both events taking place in 1790.
Although it is well known that the settlement of this town began in 1788 and 1789, it is quite difficult to determine just when pioneership ceased, and equally difficult to ascertain the names of persons and fam- ilies who are entitled to mention in that connection. However, we may state that early settlements in the town began in the village and rapidly extended therefrom in almost every direction until the lands were well occupied and put under cultivation. There was no separation of the village from the township until 1815, and for the purposes of the record the entire territory may be treated as a body so far as pioneer- ship is concerned.
The greatest difficulty which confronted the pioneers who sought homes in this region was that attending the journey from the east, and although the opening of a public highway engaged the early at- tention and efforts of those interested in the lands, and the State as well, it was not until the year 1790 that the old " State Road " from Utica to Canandaigua was opened ; and even in the completion of this thorough- fare many of the emigrants took part, stopping on their journey for this purpose, and thus hastening the work to a successful end. This road, how- ever, was but little better than an Indian path, sufficiently opened to allow
203
TOWN OF CANANDAIGUA.
a sled to pass and the most impassable streams bridged, and it was not till 1797 when, on the 28th of March, the Legislature passed an " act for opening and improving certain great roads in this State," which pro- vided for raising money by lotteries for such purpose. Under the provisions of this act and through the energetic exertions of Charles Williamson, who made and secured large additions in contributions of money, and with the additional assistance of the inhabitants who subscribed four thousand days' work, the state commissioner was enabled to com- plete the GREAT GENESEE ROAD of near one hundred miles, opening it sixty-four feet wide and paving with logs and gravel the moist places through which it was carried. Hence the road from Utica to the Gen- esee, from being in the month of June, 1797, a little better than an In- dian path, was so far improved by the latter part of September that a stage route was established on it.
The construction of the " turnpike " in 1803-4 opened a valuable thoroughfare to travel leading from the eastern country into the then comparatively wild Genesee region, and from the time of its completion, settlement and development increased with great rapidity. An ad- ditional reason for this sudden influx of pioneers lies in the fact that in 1789, before the opening of the road, a new county had been created out of the territory of old Montgomery, and Canandaigua had then been designated as its seat of justice.
The settlers of this region were fortunate in having a good mill in their vicinity, which aided them materially in obtaining lumber for their buildings. During the winter of 1789-90 Judge Augustus Porter, a pion- eer of the region, agreed with General John Fellows, one of the pro- prietors of East Bloomfield, to join together in the erection of a saw- mill on Mud Creek, five miles west of Canandaigua, which was in due time accomplished.
However, among the many important, and we may say fortunate, early events which contributed to the building up and development of this town, that which led them all was the erection of Ontario county and the designation of Canandaigua as the county seat. The erecting act was passed on the 27th of January, 1789, and by it provision was made for the creation of towns under the name of districts, of which there were to be not less than two. At that time the county included
204
HISTORY OF ONTARIO COUNTY.
all the western part of the State, but the total number of inhabitants within its boundaries did not exceed one thousand. Therefore, in the organization of the territory into provisional districts a large area of land was included within each, and, as a matter of fact, the entire county contained only six of these districts, one of which was Canandaigua.
Following close upon the creation and organization of the county came the erection of the county buildings, for which the generous pro- prietors donated a suitable plot of land, situated on a commanding ele. vation, and in the most desirable portion of the village tract. That Canandaigua was to be a county seat was of itself sufficient in impor- tance to swell the local population and enhance materially the value of lands not only in the village but in the town beyond the settled hamlet. Professional men, merchants, speculators and the ever attendant con- tingent of persons who are ready almost for anything, soon came to the town, and the result was that Canandaigua soon took a position at the head of the districts and afterward towns of the county. Of the lawyers who made this their place of residence and business we have no positive record, but the first medical men of the town were Moses Atwater and his brother, Jeremiah Atwater, Samuel Dungan and William A. Will- iams, all of whom were here before 1800, while Dr. Moses Atwater is credited with having settled in the town in 1791.
Town Organization .- The district of Canandaigua was organized January 27, 1789, but there is no record of proceedings by which we can accurately determine either the extent of the district or its first officers. However, the district did not long retain that distinctive character, for in 1791 it took the name of "town," and included within its boundaries townships 9 and 10 of the third range, containing pre- sumably seventy- two square miles of land, but in 1824, surrendered to Gorham that part of township No. 9 which lay east of Canandaigua Lake. Therefore, as at present constituted, the town is twelve miles in length, six miles wide on the north boundary and less than three miles on the south line.
The first town meeting (of which there is any record) was held on the first Tuesday in April, 1791, and was " opened and superintended " by Israel Chapin, esquire. The records appear in the bold and per- fectly plain handwriting of pioneer James D. Fish, and from the title
205
TOWN OF CANANDAIGUA.
line on the initial page it appears that the town was known to the early settlers as Canandarguay, for it must naturally be presumed that as Mr. Fish was so good a penman he must also have been at least a fair " speller," and that his rendition of the name must have been that rec- ognized by the inhabitants at that time.
At the first town meeting just referred to, the following town officers were elected : supervisor, Israel Chapin ; town clerk, James D. Fish ; assessors, John Call, Enos Boughton, Seth Reed, Nathan Cumstock, James Austin, Arnold Potter and Nathaniel Norton ; collectors, Phineas Bates and John Codding; overseers of the poor, Israel Chapin and Nathaniel Gorham ; commissioners of highways, Othniel Taylor, Joseph Smith, Benjamin Wells; constables, Nathaniel Sanburn, Jared Bough- ton and Phineas Pierce ; overseers of highways, James Latta, Joshua Whitney, John Swift, Daniel Gates, Jabez French, Gameliel Wilder, Abner Barlow, Isaac Hathaway, Hezekiah Boughton, Eber Norton, William Gooding and John D. Robinson.
The foregoing list of first town officers will bring to the notice of the reader the names of perhaps a majority of the pioneers at that time, as the number of eligible freeholders was so small that nearly every one having an interest or ambition in that direction was freely supplied with office. In this connection it may be interesting to refer to the succes- sion of supervisors of Canandaigua from the organization of the town to the present time as follows :
Supervisors .- Israel Chapin, 1791-95 ; Abner Barlow, 1796-99; Augustus Porter, 1800-1; Nathaniel Gorham, 1802-3 ; (no record of 1804 and 1805); Timothy Burt, 1806-7; Hugh Jameson, 1808 ; Eben- ezer F. Norton, 1809; Hugh Jameson, 1810-II; Nathaniel Gorham, 1812; Reuben Hart, 1813; Phineas P. Bates, 1814; Eliphalet Taylor, 1815-16; John A. Stevens, 1817; Nathaniel Gorham, 1818; Lott Rew, 1819; Harvey Sanders, 1820; Phineas P. Bates, 1821; Francis Granger, 1822-25; Oliver Phelps, 1826-31; Phineas P. Bates, 1832 ; Oliver Phelps, 1833 ; Phineas P. Bates, 1834-36; Russell B. Johnson, 1837 ; Charles Shepard, 1838-42; William W. Gorham, 1843-47 ; Jabez H. Metcalf, 1848; Gideon Granger, 1849-51 ; Henry W. Taylor, 1852; Zebina Lucas, 1853-54; Ebenezer Hale, 1855; Evander Sly, 1856 ; Charles Shepard, 1857 ; Charles Coy, 1858-61 ; Jacob J. Matteson,
·
206
HISTORY OF ONTARIO COUNTY.
1862; George Cook, 1863 ; John Callister, 1864; J. Harvey Mason, 1865-67; Gustavus R. Fox, 1868; Frank O. Chamberlain, 1869-70; Charles E. Shepard, 1871-73 ; Frank O. Chamberlain, 1874; James S. Hickox, 1875; John B. Robertson, 1876-78; William L. Parkhurst, 1879-81 ; Thomas H. Cost, 1882 ; Rollin L. Beecher, 1883-84 ; Marion P. Worthy, 1885 ; Matthew L. Parkhurst, 1886; Joel M. Howey, 1887 ; George B. Sackett, 1888; Frederick W. Bryan, 1889: Charles C. Sack- ett, 1890-92 ; Frank O. Sisson, 1893.
The attention of the first town officers was early drawn to the matter of surveying and opening highways; in fact this duty was about the first of importance which required the efforts of the proprietors. From the lake running northward a distance of about two miles a splendid thoroughfare of travel was surveyed, but it was some time afterward that the road was fully completed. This is now known as Main street, and was originally laid out six rods in width, but Mr. Phelps had in view such grand possibilities for his chosen town that he increased the width to eight rods. Cross street was laid out and ever afterward main- tained as a six rod road.
Returning, however, from this digression to the subject of early set- tlement in the town of Canandaigua, we may say generally that great difficulty is encountered in learning the names of pioneers, while the exact or even approximate date of their settlement in the town cannot be learned. In a later department of this volume the reader will find sketches of many of the pioneer families in the towns, properly arranged and classified, and furnishing a reasonably complete biographical record of those named ; wherefore in the present connection it cannot be consid- ered necessary to furnish more than a brief allusion to the heads of pio- neer families, with a mention of the general locality of their settlement.
Over in the east part of the town, near the foot of the lake, at an early day dwelt pioneers Samuel Rogers, Artemas Lincoln and Charles Grimes, the latter the owner of a fulling and cloth mill, an almost indis- pensable necessity in a new locality. John Van Orman afterward oper- ated the mill and also acquired some fame as a landlord. Liberty Day was an early settler on the turnpike, and made brick in a small way. but his industry was greatly appreciated by the people of the locality. Elihu Tupper was a pioneer in the same region, and also became pro-
207
TOWN OF CANANDAIGUA.
prietor of an inn, and as well was the owner of a three- horse team, hence a man of some note in the vicinity. He also carried a stock of goods and was a tradesman of the town. Lyman and Arnold Hays also were pioneers in the vicinity of which we write, and while both were farmers the former conducted a fulling mill. Judah Colt, the first sheriff of the county, at one time lived in this neighborhood, on what was called the Shepard farm.
In that part of the town north of the locality of which we have just written were a number of families of whom several can be recalled by name. Zachariah Tiffany was one of these pioneers and the head of a large family who followed in the parental footsteps. In this vicinity also dwelt the Cassarts and Shulers, the Faurots and Sanders, the latter settling here as early as 1795. and being a physician was regarded as a man of importance in the town. In this neighborhood there also dwelt pioneers De Bow and Latting.
West of the general locality just mentioned at a very early day were made settlements by Caleb Gage, Thomas Pike, Joseph Canfield, Stephen Bishop, John Gage, Levi Brockelbank, Chandler Burger, James Reeves (a wheelwright), Eliphalet Taylor (a prominent man in town affairs), Oliver Glover, Charles Cassart, William Curtis, and possibly others whose names are not now recalled, but all of whom by their efforts helped to develop the resources of the town, and laid the foundation for prosperity to be enjoyed by a later generation of occupants.
In the northern part of the town, in the locality which has for many years been known as Paddleford, there settled at an early day a number of families of much prominence, and among whom can be remembered the names of Price, Hudson, Walker, Tilton and Marble. The pioneer of this region is said to have been the first named settler, Price Pad- dleford as a village did not attain any prominence prior to the building of the railroad. Lying to the west of Paddleford is situate District Number 20, so called, which is a part of the territory included by the settlement above mentioned. Some of the old family names are still preserved in the locality but the pioneers themselves are all gone. This section of the town was formerly known as the " Bacon Tract."
The locality of the town lying southeast of the village of Canandaigua was settled very soon after the survey of the region was completed.
208
HISTORY OF ONTARIO COUNTY.
The lands here appeared to have been especially desirable, and settlers and speculators were active to possess them. Lemuel Castle was one of the first to make an improvement in this vicinity, coming here in 1789. Castle is said to have built the first frame barn for Mr. Phelps in 1792. Following Castle came other pioneers, among whom were John Sutherland, Seth Holcomb (a settler of 1792, and also a hotel keeper), Ebenezer Williams, wheelwright and wagon-maker; Captain George Hickox, a soldier of the War of 1812, but a pioneer of 1793. Joseph Van Orman, Daniel Case, Giles Mitchell and Hugh Jameson were like- wise early settlers in the same region, and are remembered as men of prominence and worth in the community.
The country around Centerfield was also desirable as an early (and even present) place of abode, and was settled early. Colonel Thaddeus Remington and Abner Barlow located here in 1790, while later on came other pioneers, among them David Hawley, Noah Heacock, Jesse Mil- ler, Isaac Morse, better known as " Papa " Morse, and popular at all country sports because of his ability as a fiddler. Enos and Henry Hawley, Stephen Ward, Charles and Oliver Johnson, Harvey Steele and Oliver Rose were also early residents of this locality.
A short distance south of Centerfield early settlements were made by Rev. Zadoc Hunn, who was a preacher of some note among the pio- neers, and who settled here in 1795 and died in 1801. Seba Case came here in 1794, and was followed by Elijah Tillotson and George Good- ing, both of whom were also pioneers. East of the pioneers just named was a locality also occupied at an early day, there appearing the prom- inent names of Spencer, Taylor, Moore, Root, Castle, Bunnell, Butler, and Mack, nearly all of whom are to be recorded as settling in the town prior to 1800, and the names of whom are generally represented in the locality at the present day.
Along the west side of the lake the early settlers had no thought of erecting summer cottages such as now dot its shore, as their attention was directed to other enterprises, such as getting suitable buildings for family and stock, and earning a livelihood from the lands. Pioneers Israel Reed and Miles Hecox, Seth Lewis, Levi Rowley, Epaphratus Nott, Christian Seaman, and the Eatons had but little time during the early years of this century to devote themselves to pleasure seeking on
209
TOWN OF CANANDAIGUA.
the lake, but with them, as with all pioneers of an undeveloped country, they were content to live frugally and in the enjoyment of such pleas- ures as a life of constant toil might afford.
THE ACADEMY TRACT.
In the extreme southeast part of the town is situated what was orig- inally known as the Academy tract, containing three thousand acres of land which was deeded and donated by Oliver Phelps for the benefit of the Canandaigua Academy, from which its name was derived. The. tract was surveyed into lots, each one hundred and fifty acres, and these were in turn divided so that each occupant should have seventy-five acres. According to the original purpose, these lands were to be rented, but they were gradually disposed of by sale and are now occu- pied almost entirely by owners. This generous donation was made by the proprietor in 1804. but it was not until 1810 that settlement on the tract in fact began, and then the lots were taken quite slowly, as the lands were supposed to be unproductive. The pioneer settler on this tract was named Santliff, but within the succeeding three years the lands were occupied by at least fourteen families, as follows : James Cur- rier, John Penoyer, Jonathan Croker, William Warren, Solomon Riggs, William Holmes, Elias Bascom, Robert McGill, the Widow Holmes, the pioneer Santliff and other heads of families named Olds, Gordon, Bul- lard and Dickerson.
Need help finding more records? Try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.