USA > Ohio > Erie County > History of Erie County Ohio, with illustrations and biographical sketches of some of its prominent men and pioneers > Part 1
Note: The text from this book was generated using artificial intelligence so there may be some errors. The full pages can be found on Archive.org.
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16 | Part 17 | Part 18 | Part 19 | Part 20 | Part 21 | Part 22 | Part 23 | Part 24 | Part 25 | Part 26 | Part 27 | Part 28 | Part 29 | Part 30 | Part 31 | Part 32 | Part 33 | Part 34 | Part 35 | Part 36 | Part 37 | Part 38 | Part 39 | Part 40 | Part 41 | Part 42 | Part 43 | Part 44 | Part 45 | Part 46 | Part 47 | Part 48 | Part 49 | Part 50 | Part 51 | Part 52 | Part 53 | Part 54 | Part 55 | Part 56 | Part 57 | Part 58 | Part 59 | Part 60 | Part 61 | Part 62 | Part 63 | Part 64 | Part 65 | Part 66 | Part 67 | Part 68 | Part 69 | Part 70 | Part 71 | Part 72 | Part 73 | Part 74
TO
15
GENEALOGY COLLECTION
m
3 1833 00826 6048
Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2016
https://archive.org/details/historyoferiecou00aldr
HISTORY
OF
ERIE
COUNTY
OHIO
WITH ILLUSTRATIONS AND BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCHES OF SOME OF ITS PROMINENT MEN AND PIONEERS.
EDITED BY
LEWIS CASS ALDRICH
SYRACUSE, N. Y. D. MASON & CO., PUBLISHERS
1889
1560915
INTRODUCTION.
H ISTORY is a statement of fact, clearly and concisely written, and without comment, inferences or opinions. One of the most satisfactory situations in which the writer of local history can find himself is that that enables him to realize that his work is original. But in Erie county this delightful reflection is denied him, for there is but little of its history that has not, in some form or other, appeared in print; still, it is confidently believed that this volume con- tains records, the events of which are proper to be treated upon as a part of the county's history, that have been passed unnoticed by former writers; and while the major part, perhaps, of the work is a compilation of records previously discussed, the subjects have been herein arranged and classified so as to make them more intelligent to the reader, and therefore more valuable.
It would be indeed remarkable to find, after an examination, that this vol- ume contained not an error of fact or date. "To err is human," and the editor realizes fully the force of the statement made by Samuel Johnson, when he says: " He that has a great work to do will do something wrong."
In the preparation of the History of Erie County and its several townships, the compiler has to acknowledge with gratitude the valuable assistance of a number of residents of the city of Sandusky and other towns. But before making any individual mention, the editor desires to extend to the press of the city sincere thanks for uniform courtesy and willing assistance rendered upon every occasion upon which the same was sought.
To Charles N. Freeman, of Sandusky, is due the credit of a valuable and interesting contribution of material facts-the results of his explorations among the Indian and other mounds with which the county was at an early day known to abound; to Charles H. Cramer, esq., an attorney of the city, is also due thanks for the contribution of the Geological chapter; to Professor A. A. Bar- tow for the chapter on education, and other valuable assistance; to Dr. E. Von
٠١٠
8
INTRODUCTION.
Schulenburg for his able chapter on The German Element of Erie county ; to W. D. Gurley for the history of Perkins township; to Mrs. Margaret B. Peeke for the church history of the city and other important chapters ; to Dr. I. B. Massey for substantial assistance in preparing the Medical chapter ; to J. F. Green for the Agricultural article ; to Counsellor S. C. Wheeler for valuable material relating to the Masonic organizations of the city of Sandusky and elsewhere ; and further, to the people of the county at large, who by their generous contributions to the subscription list have made the publication of this volume not only possible but successful, are also extended the thanks not only of the editor but of the publishers as well.
CONTENTS.
CHAPTER I.
The Subject - Beginning of Erie County's History . Page 13
CHAPTER II.
Traces of a Pre-Historic Race - An Unknown People - The Mound Builders - Theories Concerning Them - Character of Their Mounds - Discoveries in Erie County of Evi- dences of Their Former Presence There 14
CHAPTER III.
The Indian Occupation - The Eries - Their Destruction by the Five Nations - The Iro- quois Confederacy - Lake Erie - Its Name and Derivation - The Huron or Wyandot Indians - Their Subjugation by the Five Nations -Other Tribes of this Region - In- cidents Concerning Them - Their Final Removal. 19
CHAPTER IV.
The French Dominion - La Salle - His Voyage Up Lake Erie - The Griffin - French Operations in this Region - The French and English Wars - Extinction of French Power in America - Pontiac's League - The Conspiracy - The War - Peace Again Restored 23
CHAPTER V.
Events Preceding the Revolution - Twelve Years of Peace - Growing English Power - Early Commerce of the Lake - The Second Sailing Vessel - The Beaver - The Mora- vian Missionaries and Indians - Their Settlement in Erie County - The Revolution .. 28
CHAPTER VI.
Extinguishment of Indian Titles to Land - Treaty at Fort McIntosh - Fort Laurens - Fort Finney - Battle at Fallen Timbers - Wayne's Victory - Treaty at Fort Indus- try - Text of the Treaty - The Indian Title to Lands of Erie County Vested in the United States- Later Events - The War of 1812-15.
31
IO
CONTENTS.
CHAPTER VII.
The Soil and Civil Jurisdiction of Ohio - The Connecticut Lands - The Western Reserve - Connecticut Sufferers' or Fire Lands - Detailed Record of their Organization - Laws- Acts and Explanations - Surveys - Dissolution of the Fireland's Company - Records Transferred to Huron County 38
CHAPTER VIII.
Organization of Counties on the Reserve - Botetourt - Trumbull - Geauga - Cuyahoga - Huron - Proceedings to Erect Huron County - The County Seat at Milan Changed to, Norwalk - Officers - Erie County Erected - Acts Regarding It -County Civil List 50
CHAPTER IX.
A General Topographical and Geographical View of Erie County - Its Situation and Boundaries - Civil Divisions 59
CHAPTER X.
Locating the County Seat - Sites Offered - Incidents - Sandusky Chosen - The First Court-House - Change of County Seat Threatened - Permanent House of Justice Provided - The Tardy Proprietors - Some Notable Cases Tried - The First and Only Murderer Executed in Erie County - The Old Jail - Present County Buildings 63
CHAPTER XI.
Geology of Erie County 72
CHAPTER XII.
Agriculture of Erie County . . 83
CHAPTER XIII.
Military History of Erie County
93
CHAPTER XIV.
The Press of Erie County 178
CHAPTER XV.
Bench and Bar 187
II
CONTENTS.
CHAPTER XVI.
The Medical Profession . 211
CHAPTER XVII.
The German Element of Erie County
228
CHAPTER XVIII.
Railways of the County
263
CHAPTER XIX.
Some Events of Erie County's Political History
272
CHAPTER XX.
History of the City of Sandusky - The Seat of Justice of Erie County . .. 280
CHAPTER XXI.
History of Berlin Township
438
CHAPTER XXII.
History of Florence Township ... 450
CHAPTER XXIII.
History of Groton Township
454
CHAPTER XXIV.
History of Huron Township
459
CHAPTER XXV ..
History of Kelley's Island ....... 473
CHAPTER XXVI.
History of Margarettal Township 481
I2
CONTENTS.
CHAPTER XXVII.
History of Milan Township and Village . 492
CHAPTER XXVIII.
History of Oxford Township 509
CHAPTER XXIX.
History of Vermillion Township 514
CHAPTER XXX.
History of Perkins Township. 521
CHAPTER XXXI.
Brief Biographical Sketches
541
ILLUSTRATIONS.
Stoll, Adam J., portrait facing 406
Sadler, Ebeneze B., portrait facing 534 Simpson, William A., portrait facing 280
BIOGRAPHICAL.
McKelvey, John 529 Sadler, Ebenezer B 534
Simpson, William A 532 Stoll, Adam J 531
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
CHAPTER I.
THE SUBJECT .- BEGINNING OF ERIE COUNTY'S HISTORY.
T HE history of any county properly begins with its organization, and a nar- rative of the events occurring within its borders prior to that organization must necessarily be associated with the older counties of which it had previously formed a part. Erie county was not organized with its present name until the year 1838. The larger and the more interesting part of its history had at that time already taken place. It is necessary, therefore, to point out that the sub- ject of this work is the territory comprised within the present bounds of Erie county, together with the inhabitants of that territory, no matter whether the events recorded occurred before or after the beginning of the independent ex- istence of the county. Again, as has already been intimated, it will be neces- sary to frequently refer to matters outside this territory in order to elucidate the history of the county and show a succession of events. Such extraneous references, however, will be confined chiefly to a few of the earlier chapters.
There is scarcely a subject pertaining to the history of Erie county, or to this region, that has not in some manner been written, and it is hardly to be expected that at this late day any new and important historical material can be unearthed and brought forward from the long hidden recesses of the past. It will be necessary in view of the many publications that have been made, to discuss the subjects that have therein appeared and in much the same manner as they appear to be related ; but in quoting from other works and other writ- ers full credit will be given and preference exercised for those who have been in some manner identified with the past of this immediate locality.
Further, when "Erie county" is spoken of previous to the organization and naming thereof, it will be understood that the words are used chiefly to avoid circumlocution and mean the territory included within its present boundaries. So, too, for convenience the territory now comprised in a township will occa-
3
14
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
sionally be mentioned by its present name, before any such township was act- ually in existence.
It is the aim and hope of the writer, by a proper arrangement and classifi- cation of the subjects treated in the several chapters, to present to the people of Erie county a work that shall be to them of much value for ready reference and to the succeeding generations a work of inestimable value as an instructor regarding the past of the county and region.
CHAPTER II.
Traces of a Pre-Historic Race .- An Unknown People .- The Mound Builders .- Theories Concerning Them .-- Character of Their Mounds .- Discoveries in Erie County of Evidences of Their Former Presence There.
[T seems to be a fact, and a fact founded upon theory, surmise, inference and probability, that the whole region of country now embraced within the lim- its of the State of Ohio, was the home of a large race of people possessing traits and a degree of intelligence far beyond those possessed by the average Amer- ican Indian of the seventeenth, eighteenth or nineteenth centuries, of all of whom we have positive knowledge. Of this peculiar people there exists no written history, nor have we any traditionary knowledge of them or other ev- idence than the works and relics that they left behind them like "footprints in the sands of time." This people, the historians of the last two centuries have been pleased to term as Mound Builders. The time of their occupation of the -country has never been determined.
The earliest traditionary Indian history carries the reader back to the oc- ·cupation of this whole lake and river country by two nations of people who were said to have come from the country west of the Mississippi River, those settling in the country bordering upon the lakes being known as the Mengwe, while the others occupied the territory upon the larger rivers of New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio and the country south and who were known as the Lenni Lenapes or " original people." These two peoples had a tradition extending back to the early part of the thirteenth century, but from them there came no knowledge of an earlier nation than their own. The name Mound Builders seems to have been accepted as the only one to properly designate the pecul- iar race who certainly did, in some by-gone age, occupy the territory of Ohio.
The case presents two features : That which is known and that which is not known concerning them, and the latter is largely in preponderance. "Eu- ropeans, Egyptians and Asiatics might have voyaged across the Atlantic by
15
PRE-HISTORIC EVIDENCES.
way of the Western Islands, Iceland and Greenland, or as the Welsh expedi- tion of Madoc did in 1170 A. D., or as Christopher Columbus did in 1492, or as might have been done by an earlier, bolder navigator by way of the mid-ocean island Atlantis, of which we read (though always doubtingly) in Plato, and which the right of authority pronounces fabulous." But " we do not know where they came from, when and how they disappeared, whether they were extinguished by war, pestilence, or famine, or ultimately degenerated into bar- barians, or whether they slowly moved to the southwest and finally came with- in the domain of history as Aztecs, or some more ancient people, once of pre- historic times in Mexico or Central America."
We leave then the speculations of theorists for the more practical knowl- edge of the Mound Builders, as shown by their works which have been exam- ined and explored. in this State. These consisted of mounds, effigies and in- closures, and from the first, which, predominating, gave the name of "Mound Builders " to this people.
Those who have given this subject the most study and examination have classified the mounds into sepulchral, sacrificial, temple (or truncated) mounds, also mounds of observation and memorial or monumental mounds. Effigies are also called animal mounds ; sometimes, too, they are named emblematic or symbolic mounds.
" Inclosures are of several kinds, one class being known as military or de- fensive works, another as parallel embankments or covered ways, and the third as sacred inclosures."
But it is not well to pursue this theoretical subject further for the purposes of this chapter. None of these higher grades of mounds have been discovered in this locality, although they have been known elsewhere in Ohio. Still there have been found in Erie county evidences of the presence here of this lost and unknown people. Many of what has been believed to be the remains of mounds in various localities hereabouts have been explored and implements of warfare and for domestic use among the Mound Builders have been taken from them.
A few interested persons, residents of Sandusky and elsewhere in the county, have given these matters some attention. Therefore, by request, we present to the readers of this work the results of examinations made by Charles N. Freeman, of the city of Sandusky, written and contributed expressly for this chapter :
Contrary to the generally accepted opinion, Erie county bears abundant evidence of occupancy by a race of people ante-dating the present race of Indians, or their generally accepted ancestors. Although there are no large mounds, or those of peculiar shape, such as are found in the central and south- ern parts of the State, yet a close examination of the knolls along the banks of the rivers and creeks tributary to Sandusky Bay and Lake Erie reveals the fact that mounds did exist here in large numbers. The action of time, and
16
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
more especially cultivation, the greatest foe to the preservation of such re- mains, have in many instances almost obliterated all trace of them, but the fact that they are still traceable is stronger proof of their existence. On the high- est points and some distance back from the creek banks, in fields of light, sandy soil and clay sub-soil, are found circular deposits of extremely black earth, varying in depth from one to three feet, in which are found skeletons of a " race "-not Indians. The skull is well developed, being full in the fore- head, broad, with good height above the ears, and in all respects different from the Indians. The skeletons of adults are above the average size and some of them gigantic. The writer, together with Dr. Charles Stroud and Mr. T. L. Williams, have dug up a number in different localities, and always, with one exception, with the same results. The graves were dug through the soil of varying depth to the clay sub-soil, on which was spread a deposit of ashes and charcoal from four to eight inches thick. The skeletons are found lying side by side, facing the west, the arms closely pinioned to the sides, and sur- rounded by innumerable bones of birds and small animals, black with age, but evidently not burnt.
The exception referred to was an excavation made by the writer on the farm of Henry Geasen, formerly part of the Upp property, situated on the east bank of Pipe Creek. Here, in a mound of about one-half acre in extent, were discovered a large number of skeletons buried face downward in parallel trenches running north and south. Twenty-three were removed and exam- ined, and a large number were left untouched. No relics of importance were found, but there were large quantities of broken tomahawks, pipes and pottery, the latter from the shallowness of burial, evidently destroyed by action of frost. On this mound have been found stone arrow and spear points, relics of the stone age ; also stone pipes, fleshers, tomahawks, curiously shaped totems, and pottery of various and in some instances of quite elaborate design. In the collection of Mr. Williams is an arrow point, found in Oakland Cemetery, at a depth of eight feet. Nearly all the finds are made on the east side of the creeks. On Plum Brook, beginning at a point near where it empties into the marsh, is a line of mounds, or rather their remains, extending in almost a straight line to Bogart's Corners, crossing the creek in one instance, but al- ways on the highest elevations. On one of them is a large ring, fifty feet in diameter, four feet wide, and being of black earth is plainly discernible on the yellow sandy soil. In this ring have been found several fine specimens, highly polished. The arrow and spear points differ in shape and material on the dif- ferent creeks, those found on Plum Brook being leaf-shaped, chert, and deeply notched black flint ; also the Icelandic or double notched arrow points, which are very rare and are found in no other place in this vicinity. On Goose Creek, so called, the arrow points are of chert, crude and imperfect, very few good specimens being found. Even the tomahawks and fleshers are of the
17
PRE-HISTORIC EVIDENCES.
crudest make, and bear evidence of great age. Pipe Creek furnishes the most of the willow-leaf variety, double pointed arrows and drills. The specimens found here are of excellent workmanship. Mill's Creek furnishes a greater variety, but here, even, a special shape, that of the triangular or war arrow, predominates. These facts seem to denote tribal distinctions. On the north bank of Mill's Creek, just south of the Lake Shore track, was a large burial mound, which was partly removed when the fill was made at that place. On this mound grew an immense oak tree, of great age, whose roots had pene- trated to the center and there entwined themselves around the bones laid to rest, drawing sustenance from those whose graves it sheltered. When this tree was removed a number of relics were found, besides the skeletons referred to. To the east of this mound is a level spot of about three acres, evidently the site of a village. The rise from the creek is gradual, and the elevation ·commands a view of the creek to its mouth as well as the surrounding country. Its natural position made it easy of defense, and occupied by any considerable force would seem almost impregnable. It was less than one-half mile from the shore of one of the most beautiful sheets of still water to be found along the lake shore, whose depths swarmed with fish of countless variety, and whose surface was covered with wild fowl-the bay and adjoining marshes being feeding grounds during the migratory seasons-and backed by a track- less forest, filled to repletion with the game that supplied the material for their clothing and a large proportion of their food. Supplies of nuts and acorns were easily obtained, and the marshes were thickets of wild rice, which for them then, as for the tribes of the Northwest now, no doubt formed part of their food supply. No stretch of the imagination is necessary to appreciate the motives and sentiments that influenced those who chose this spot for a dwelling place. The ground bears evidence of having been the scene of a fierce conflict. Scattered about all over this field are broken tomahawks of all shapes and sizes, and the small triangular or war arrows are found in great abundance. The soil is full of specimens of great variety. There is a bed of burned pottery material here, covering about thirty feet square, evidently the seat of the pottery manufacture for this whole section. It is composed of clay and ground white quartz, mixed in proportions of about one to twenty, evi- dently to make it harder. Many stone hammers are found, of granite and greenstone, fashioned to fit the hand perfectly. There are no large fragments of flint found, but an abundance of fine chips, the refuse of the arrow-makers. Almost every stone in the whole field bears evidence of having been used for some purpose. Taken together, these results prove conclusively that this is the site of the prolonged habitation. The land adjoining, at this writing planted in vineyards, yields with every turn of the plow relics of every descrip- tion and grade of workmanship. I have in my collection two beveled-edge arrow points, found here, which for design and symmetry equal any thing that
-----
18
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
can be fashioned from stone. The angles are exactly forty-five degrees, which would cause the arrow to revolve as soon as it left the hand of the archer, insuring more accurate aim and causing an ugly wound.
At a point on Sandusky Bay known as Martin's Cave are several mounds of small pieces of stone. They have been repeatedly investigated, but nothing of importance found in them. There are also several earth mounds in that vicinity which as yet remain untouched.
. Tradition, the ally of the historian, has made mention of a fort in this vicin- ity which has finally been located about one mile south of Venice. Repeated plowing and the washings of many years have effaced all semblance as regards embankments, but by the discoloration of the soil the outline is plainly defined, and within its prescribed limits, at various times, have been found stone pipes, and a number of those curious combination bird and animal shape totems. They have often the body, legs and ears of an animal, and a bill like a duck. Through the feet are drilled small holes, for what purpose is a mystery. Nu- merous other relics have been found differing from any known to be in any of the large collections of the State.
The same general condition of things is found on the banks of the Huron and Vermillion Rivers, and in fact throughout the whole county; but that part of it nearest to and within easy reaching distance of Sandusky City has been the most thoroughly examined, and from it in particular the facts have been noted, and the deductions drawn which appear in this article. To whatever race made and used these tools and weapons must be given the credit for in- genuity, skill and persistent effort. With stone hammers they fashioned their tomahawks and fleshers, and sharpened and polished them on stones of Berea grit, by rubbing them in a circle until the desired effect was obtained. With the bow and flint-drill were made the holes in the totems and pipes, they bear- ing the marks of the sharp edges of the drills to this day. The pipes were first fashioned as regards shape and style, and then drilled. I have two in my col- lection finished, with the exception of boring, which in each is begun at the stem and bowl. They sawed by means of sand and water on the same princi- ple of to-day, until the required depth was reached, and broke the remainder. Time to them was an unknown quantity, but that admitted, the results they ob- tained were wonderful. The material for their fleshers, hammers and toma- hawks were obtained from the beds of the creeks. Mill's Creek, especially, at some points being full of small boulders of the same material as the relics found. The chert came from the limestone beds, and the flint from a distance ; the flat totems from stones picked up on the lake shore, and other tools and weap- ons from stones whose natural adaptation attracted their notice. Beginning with the crudest relics found by comparison it is an easy matter to trace the progress made not by long strides, but little by little, adding detail to detail, until perfection in the material used was obtained. Adaptation to circum- stances is a natural law governing the human race.
n
19
INDIAN OCCUPATION.
There is also an inherent force urging mankind to greater effort, but then even, the diversity of their product, the skill developed, and the patience shown are marvelous, and to the student an endless source of admiration.
A large number of specimens from Erie county have been donated to the Fremont and Firelands Associations, aside from those to the collections of Dr. Stroud, Mr. Williams and my own, which together number more than three thousand, nearly all of which have been collected personally, by careful and persistent search. They embrace spear and arrow points; of the latter nine va- rieties being found, pipes of pottery and stone, carved and plain, tomahawks, fleshers, hammers, mortars and pestles, totems of different design and material, drills, bone awls, wampum, beads of pottery, flint knives, polishing-stones, round hammered stones, used as a bolas, bears claws, with holes drilled through them, evidently parts of amulets and necklaces, worn by the braves as proof of their prowess, and a large number of unique specimens which the writer has never seen classified or described.
Need help finding more records? Try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.