Census Informants in Genealogy Research
Who answered the census taker's questions and how that affects the accuracy of your ancestor's entry
The person who gave the census taker information about your ancestor's household is called the informant. It was often not your ancestor. Depending on the census year, the informant could be a spouse, an older child, a boarder, or even a neighbor. Knowing who likely answered helps explain many of the errors you find on a census page, such as a misspelled surname, a wrong age, or a vague birthplace.
Who Was Allowed to Answer
For the 1850, 1860, and 1870 censuses, the instructions told the assistant marshals to collect information "by actual inquiry at every dwelling house, or by personal inquiry of the head of every family, and not otherwise." In practice, the head of the family was not always home, and another family member sometimes answered anyway.
Starting with the 1880 census, the rules were loosened. The enumerator could take answers from the head of the family or from the member "deemed most credible and worthy of trust." If no one competent to answer could be found at the home, the enumerator was told to get the information from "the family or families, or person or persons, living nearest to such place of abode." In other words, a neighbor could answer for an entire household. The 1890 and 1900 instructions repeated much the same rule.
The 1940 census is the one year that tells you who answered. The enumerator marked an X with a circle around it after the name of the person who gave the information. If someone outside the household answered, the enumerator was told to write that person's name in the left margin, such as "Information from John Brown, neighbor."
Why This Matters for Accuracy
The enumerator wrote down what he was told. He did not check answers against birth records or earlier censuses, and he often worked under time pressure. In 1880, for example, cities of 10,000 or more people had to be counted in the first 2 weeks of June. A man's answers about his own age and occupation are firsthand information. His answers about his wife's birthplace, his mother-in-law's age, or a boarder's name are secondhand, and a neighbor's answers about the family next door may be little more than a guess.
Say your ancestor John Smith was a farmer, and the family was in the fields when the enumerator came by. A neighbor might give the right names and a rough count of the children, but guess at their ages and give "Germany" as the birthplace. The 1880 instructions told enumerators to write the specific German state, such as Prussia, Baden, or Bavaria, instead of "Germany." A neighbor was much less likely to know that detail than the family itself.
Clues That Someone Else Answered
- Ages that are off by several years compared to other censuses, especially for everyone in the household at once
- Birthplaces given only as a country, or as "unknown"
- Surnames spelled very differently from other records, as if written by ear
- Given names recorded as a nickname or an English version, such as "Fred" for Friedrich
- Relationships that seem wrong, such as a grandchild listed as a son or a widowed sister listed as a boarder
- A family missing members you know were living there, or including someone who had already moved away
Tips for Weighing a Census Entry
- Look at the original image, not just the index. In 1940, find the circled X and check the left margin for a note naming an outside informant. Keep in mind that enumerators sometimes skipped these marks, so a missing note does not prove a family member answered.
- Give more weight to details about the informant. If you know who answered, their own age and birthplace are more likely to be right than the same details for others in the home.
- Compare every census year your ancestor appears in. A different informant in each year can explain why ages and birthplaces change from one census to the next.
- Look at the neighbors on the same page. Looking at others that appear near a family on the list can help you to locate potential family members and neighbors, including the people who may have answered for them.
- Confirm any important detail with another record, such as a church register, death certificate, passenger list, or naturalization record, before adding it to your family tree.
Where to Find Census Records
U.S. federal census records from 1790 through 1950 are available online. Our census records directory lists federal and state census sources for each state.
Need help finding more records? We have genealogy research services available. You can also try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1.3 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.
Related Topics
- Learning Genealogy Articles more than 140 helpful articles to help you to do genealogy more effectively