DNA Privacy Settings and Law Enforcement Matching

Which DNA testing sites allow police matching and how to choose your settings



When you take a DNA test for genealogy, your results are compared with thousands of other testers so you can find cousins and break down brick walls. Some of those databases also let law enforcement compare crime-scene or unidentified-remains DNA against the same pool of testers. Knowing which companies allow this, and what your settings control, helps you decide where to test, where to upload, and how to talk with relatives you ask to test.


Note that these searches do not hand investigators your raw DNA file. A law enforcement account in a database that allows it sees what any other match sees: a name or alias, contact information, and the amount of DNA you share. It sees that only if you turn up as a match.


Why This Became an Issue for Genealogists


In 2018 investigators in California identified a suspect in the Golden State Killer case by uploading crime-scene DNA to GEDmatch, a site where testers from different companies compare results. They then built family trees from his distant cousins, using the same methods genealogists use for adoptees and unknown parents. Since then, testing companies have written policies about police access, and a few states have passed laws regulating these searches. The rules have changed several times and vary by company, so it is worth checking each site's current policy yourself.


How the Major DNA Databases Differ

  • AncestryDNA: Ancestry does not allow law enforcement to search its database for matches and requires valid legal process, such as a court order or warrant, before it will consider any request for customer data.
  • 23andMe: The company says it does not voluntarily share data with law enforcement and will release it only when legally required.
  • MyHeritage DNA: Its terms prohibit using its DNA services for law enforcement purposes unless a court order is obtained.
  • FamilyTreeDNA: Law enforcement matching is allowed for certain case types, but only against kits that are opted in to Investigative Genetic Genealogy Matching (IGGM). Each kit has its own setting.
  • GEDmatch: Each kit has one of 4 settings. Public Opt-in kits are compared with law enforcement kits in violent crime cases. Public Opt-out kits are not, but they are still compared with kits uploaded to identify unidentified human remains. Personal Research kits can see matches but do not appear in other people's match lists, and Private kits are not used for matching at all.


Keep in mind that a company's policy lasts only as long as that company does. Databases are sometimes sold to new owners, as GEDmatch was in 2019 and 23andMe was after its bankruptcy in 2025, and a new owner may change the terms.


What Your Settings Can and Cannot Do


Your settings govern only your own kit, and only at that one company. Changing a setting at GEDmatch does nothing at FamilyTreeDNA. Deleting a kit does not take back what a match already saw, and it does not remove your relatives' kits from the database.


This is the part many testers do not realize. If your cousin opts in to law enforcement matching, your family may be within reach of an investigation even if you never tested. A 2018 study published in Science estimated that a majority of Americans of European descent could be matched to a third cousin or closer through a large consumer database. The same cousin matching that helps you find an ancestor's parents is what makes a distant relative's kit useful to an investigator.


Settings have also sometimes failed. A 2020 security breach at GEDmatch briefly reset users' permissions so that opted-out kits were visible to law enforcement accounts, and the site later disclosed that some investigators had worked around users' settings.


Situations Where These Choices Matter

  • You are deciding which company to test with and want to know which databases allow police matching.
  • You want to upload your raw data to another site to find more matches.
  • You manage DNA kits for parents, aunts, uncles, or other relatives, including relatives who have died.
  • You are asking an elderly relative to test to help solve a family mystery.
  • You are researching an adoption or unexpected parentage and want to keep contact with matches private.


Limitations to Keep in Mind

  • Company policies, ownership, and laws change, and an article like this cannot promise what any site allows today.
  • Opting out of law enforcement matching does not stop a court from ordering a company to produce data.
  • Choosing a strict privacy setting may also hide you from cousins who could help your research. GEDmatch's Private setting, for example, means no matching at all.
  • You cannot control what relatives decide for their own kits.


Tips for Protecting Your Privacy as a DNA Tester

  • Read each company's privacy policy and terms before testing or uploading: look for sections on law enforcement requests and on what happens if the company is sold.
  • Check your settings at every site where you have ever uploaded, not just the one you remember: old uploads to smaller sites are easy to forget.
  • Get informed consent from relatives: explain law enforcement matching before you test or upload a kit for someone else, and let them make the choice.
  • Use an alias or initials if you prefer: most sites allow a display name, though matches who want to contact you will still need some way to reach you.
  • Consider what your linked family tree reveals: on Ancestry and MyHeritage you can make your individual tree private, and living people are usually hidden from public view.
  • Review your settings periodically: options and defaults have sometimes changed without much notice.




Need help finding more records? We have genealogy research services available. You can also try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1.3 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.



Related Topics