DNA Testing Your Oldest Living Relatives

Why the oldest generation's DNA matters for genealogy research and how to get them tested



Autosomal DNA, the type used by the major testing companies to find cousin matches, is cut roughly in half with every generation. You share about 50 percent of it with each parent, about 25 percent with each grandparent, and about 12.5 percent with each great-grandparent. Your oldest living relatives carry more of your ancestors' DNA than you do, and once they are gone, any DNA that was not passed down or captured by a test is lost.


Note that a DNA test does not replace records. It works best alongside a well-researched family tree, and testing the oldest generation simply gives you more DNA to work with.


Why the Oldest Generation Carries More


A grandparent carries about 25 percent of each of their own grandparents' DNA. By the time that DNA reaches you, only about 6.25 percent of each of those ancestors remains, and some segments the grandparent carried never reached you at all. Testing the grandparent puts that larger share into the match databases, where it can connect you to more distant cousins on that line. Sometimes a lost segment survives by chance in a cousin, but there is no way to know that in advance.


Situations Where Testing Older Relatives Can Be Helpful


  • You want to sort your matches into your mother's side and your father's side.
  • You are trying to identify an unknown great-grandparent and need matches that only an older relative has.
  • Your own matches on one line are too distant to use, and you need stronger matches one generation closer.
  • You want to test a direct paternal or maternal line that only a particular relative can still represent.
  • You need to confirm a relationship, such as whether 2 elderly relatives are full or half siblings.


What Each Kind of Test Preserves


  • Autosomal DNA: inherited from all family lines and halved every generation. It is most useful for relationships within about 5 or 6 generations.
  • Y-DNA: passed from father to son with very little change, so it follows a direct paternal line. Only males carry it, so a surname line becomes untestable once there are no living men left on it.
  • Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA): passed from a mother to all her children, but only daughters pass it on. A direct maternal line can be lost when no one is left who inherited it through an unbroken line of women.


Testing Siblings to Rebuild a Parent's DNA


Full siblings each inherit a different random half of their parents' DNA, so testing a brother or sister adds coverage rather than repeating what you already have. On average, 1 child carries about 50 percent of a parent's DNA, 2 children together carry about 75 percent, 3 children about 87 percent, and 4 children about 94 percent. Say John Smith has died, but 3 of his children are living. Testing all 3 captures far more of John's DNA than testing just 1, and matches that appear for any of the 3 may belong on John's side of the family.


Once several relatives are tested, compare how much DNA they share with each match. A tool such as the Shared cM Project tool on DNA Painter shows which relationships fit a given amount of shared DNA, though it works from probabilities, not certainties.


Tips for Testing an Older Relative


  • Have the conversation first: a DNA test can reveal something unexpected, such as a parent who is not biologically related or a half sibling no one knew about. An older relative should understand that possibility and agree to the test before taking it.
  • Choose the sample type carefully: most companies use a saliva sample, which can be hard to produce for someone with a dry mouth from age or medication. Family Tree DNA uses a cheek swab, which is often easier for an elderly person.
  • Follow the collection directions: avoid eating or drinking for the period the kit instructions specify, and help the relative read the small print if needed.
  • Decide who will manage the results: with the relative's permission, a family member can manage the account, answer messages from matches, and keep the results available after the relative dies.
  • Consider a company that stores samples: Family Tree DNA keeps samples in storage so that further tests, such as Y-DNA or mtDNA, can be ordered later without asking for a new sample.
  • Ask again if needed: sometimes the hardest part is simply asking a parent or grandparent to take the time, so treat reluctance as normal and ask again later.


Where to Test


Each company has its own database, and your relative will only match people who tested with that company or uploaded results to it. AncestryDNA has the largest database and links matches to family trees, though you need an Ancestry subscription to see the full trees of most matches. MyHeritage DNA has many testers outside the United States. Family Tree DNA has a smaller autosomal database but offers Y-DNA and mtDNA tests. Sometimes the best plan is to test with one company and then upload the results to others that accept uploads, which adds matches without another sample.




Need help finding more records? We have genealogy research services available. You can also try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1.3 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.



Related Topics