Evaluating AncestryDNA ThruLines Suggestions
How ThruLines uses family trees, not DNA, to suggest ancestors and how to check them
ThruLines is the AncestryDNA feature that suggests how you are related to the people on your DNA match list. Despite how it looks, it does not trace a genetic path through your matches. It compares your family tree, and the trees of your matches, against your match list and then suggests a paper connection between you and each match. The DNA tells ThruLines which people to compare; the trees tell it what relationship to show. If the trees are wrong, ThruLines repeats the error.
Note that this does not make ThruLines useless. It is a good source of hints, as long as you treat each suggestion as a lead to research and not as proof.
How ThruLines Builds Its Suggestions
Ancestry introduced ThruLines in 2019, replacing an older feature called DNA Circles. To use it, your DNA results must be linked to a tree that is public or private but searchable, and your matches' trees must be set the same way to be included. Ancestry suggests a tree of at least 4 generations with names and dates. ThruLines then looks for the same ancestor in your tree and in your matches' trees, matching people by names, dates, and places.
The ancestors it shows fall into 2 groups:
- Solid outline: This person is already in your own tree. The suggestion is only as accurate as your own research.
- Dotted outline: This is a potential ancestor who is not in your tree but appears in several of your matches' trees. Ancestry is filling a gap in your tree with someone else's research.
Ancestry's own help page says ThruLines suggests possible relationships but does not prove them, and that its accuracy depends on how complete and accurate the trees are.
Where ThruLines Goes Wrong
The biggest problem is copied trees. When one person attaches the wrong father to an ancestor, others often copy that tree without checking. ThruLines may then show the wrong father with dozens of DNA matches supporting him. Those matches may be real cousins who descend from your ancestor, or from another branch of the family, while the wrong father sits in all their trees because they copied the same mistake. The number of matches makes the suggestion look strong, but it only shows how many trees repeat it.
Other common problems include:
- Same-name confusion: 2 men with the same name in the same county are sometimes merged into one person in many trees.
- Small differences: A misspelled name or wrong birth year in a tree can keep ThruLines from recognizing the right person.
- Thin trees: Matches with no linked tree, a private unsearchable tree, or a tree that does not reach back to the shared ancestor do not appear in ThruLines, so many real cousins are missing.
An Example
Say your ancestor Mary Smith was born about 1845 in Ohio and you do not know her parents. ThruLines shows a potential father, William Smith, with 20 DNA matches. Before accepting him, open the trees of several of those matches. If every tree gives William with no sources, or with a single family tree as the source, they may all trace back to the same guess. Then look at how the matches descend from William. If they all come through Mary's possible siblings, the DNA supports a connection to that sibling group, but the name of the father still needs records. A probate file naming Mary as William's daughter, or a census showing her in his household, would be the kind of evidence to look for.
Tips for Using ThruLines
- Check your own tree first: a wrong person in your tree will produce wrong suggestions, and fixing your tree is the main way to change what ThruLines shows.
- Treat a potential ancestor as a research question: it tells you where other people think your line goes, not where it actually goes.
- Look at the matches' trees and sources: a suggestion backed by records such as wills, deeds, or church registers is worth more than one backed only by other trees.
- Compare shared matches: if several matches under the same ancestor also match each other, the connection is more likely to be real.
- Look at the amount of shared DNA: check whether the centimorgans fit the relationship ThruLines suggests.
- Do not copy names and dates straight into your tree: add them only after you find records that support them.
Where to Use It
ThruLines is available only to people who have tested with AncestryDNA.
Need help finding more records? We have genealogy research services available. You can also try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1.3 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.
Related Topics
- Learning Genealogy Articles more than 140 helpful articles to help you to do genealogy more effectively