Finding Amish and Mennonite Ancestors

Where Amish, Mennonite, and other Anabaptist families left records and how to search them



If your ancestors were Amish, Mennonite, or members of another Anabaptist group, you may find that the usual church records are thin or missing. These groups baptize adults rather than infants, and each congregation governs itself, so there is no single baptism register or central church archive to search. However, Anabaptist families are some of the best documented in America, because their communities kept family registers, published large genealogies, and preserved records in their own historical societies.


Note that Amish and Mennonite families also appear in the same civil records as everyone else. Census, land, tax, and probate records are often the backbone of the research, with church sources filling in the family details.


Why the Church Records Are Different


The Anabaptist movement began in Switzerland in 1525. Mennonites take their name from Menno Simons, a Dutch leader who joined the movement in the 1530s, and the Amish separated from the Swiss Mennonites in 1693 under Jakob Ammann. Because baptism happened in the teens or adult years, a congregational book, where one was kept, records a person's baptism into membership rather than their birth. Children who died young or who left the faith before baptism may never appear. Many Amish districts kept no written church records at all, so family registers and community genealogies take their place.


First, Work Out Which Group Your Ancestor Belonged To


The records you need depend on which branch and migration your family came from. Keep in mind that families sometimes moved between groups, so an Amish line may turn up later in Mennonite records.

  • Swiss and South German Mennonites and Amish: These families came to Pennsylvania in the 1700s, and many later moved to Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, and Ontario. Another wave of Amish arrived from Europe in the 1800s and settled in the Midwest. Lancaster County, Pennsylvania has the largest collection of records for the colonial families.
  • Russian and Prussian Mennonites: These families came to the Great Plains, especially Kansas, Nebraska, the Dakotas, and the Canadian prairies, beginning in the 1870s. Their ancestry is often well documented back into Prussia and Russia.
  • Hutterites and Brethren: Hutterites live in communal colonies in the northern plains and Canada, and the Church of the Brethren began in Germany in 1708. Each keeps its own records, separate from Mennonite and Amish sources.


Types of Amish and Mennonite Records

  • Congregational record books: Some ministers kept books of baptisms, marriages, deaths, and members. These typically have the name and date of the event. Sometimes a birth date or names of parents may be listed.
  • Family Bible registers: Births, marriages, and deaths were often written in a family Bible or a decorated family register, sometimes in German.
  • Published genealogies: Large compiled genealogies cover many Amish and Mennonite surnames. Hugh F. Gingerich and Rachel W. Kreider's "Amish and Amish Mennonite Genealogies" traces descendants of the early Amish immigrants.
  • Community directories: Many Amish and some conservative Mennonite settlements publish directories listing each household, with birth dates, maiden names, parents, and children.
  • Genealogical card files and databases: The Lancaster Mennonite Historical Society card file gathers vital information on hundreds of thousands of people, mostly from the Lancaster area. The GRanDMA database covers Prussian and Russian Mennonite families.
  • Church newspaper obituaries: Mennonite church periodicals printed obituaries that often name parents, spouse, children, and place of burial.
  • Ship and oath lists: From 1727, Pennsylvania required adult male immigrants arriving at Philadelphia to sign oaths of allegiance. These lists were published in "Pennsylvania German Pioneers." Wives and children are usually not named.


Using These Records: An Example


Say you have a hypothetical ancestor named John Yoder, born about 1830, whom you find in the 1860 census in Holmes County, Ohio, with his wife Mary and 4 children. Yoder is a very common Amish surname, so the census alone cannot tell you which John Yoder he is. You search a published Amish genealogy and find a John Yoder of the right age married to Mary Troyer, with children whose names match the census. The entry names his parents and the Pennsylvania county they came from.


That is a strong lead, but it is a compiled source, so you check it against original records. His father's will in the Pennsylvania county names a son John, and a family Bible register held by a cousin gives John's exact birth date. Sometimes a compiled genealogy combines 2 men with the same name, so matching the wife and children in more than one record is what proves the connection.


Limitations of Amish and Mennonite Records

  • Many congregations, especially Amish districts, kept no written records, and other books stayed in private hands.
  • Baptism records show when a person joined the church, not when they were born.
  • Common surnames such as Yoder, Miller, Stoltzfus, and Hershberger, combined with a small set of first names, make it easy to confuse people.
  • Published genealogies may contain errors and often give no sources.
  • Community directories are often sold within the community and may be hard to find in libraries.
  • Records for the Russian Mennonite families before emigration are often in German or Russian.


Tips for Researching Amish and Mennonite Ancestors

  • Track the wife's family as carefully as the husband's: maiden names are often the key to sorting out men with the same name.
  • Use nicknames and middle initials as clues: communities often added a father's name or a place to tell men apart, and these may show up in records.
  • Look at neighbors in the census: Amish and Mennonite families settled close together, and neighbors are often relatives.
  • Check civil records first: deeds, wills, and orphans' court records name heirs even when no church record survives.
  • Learn a few German words: Bible registers and older church books may use German terms for born, married, and died.


Where to Find Amish and Mennonite Records

  • Search our church records directory by state and county to find where church records are held and which are online.
  • For Lancaster-area families, search Lancaster, Pennsylvania, U.S., Mennonite Vital Records, 1750-2014 on Ancestry.com. This is the Lancaster Mennonite Historical Society card file, and the originals are at Mennonite Life in Lancaster.
  • For Russian and Prussian Mennonite families, the GRanDMA database has genealogies for many of these families. The Mennonite Library and Archives at Bethel College in North Newton, Kansas holds church and family records for these families.
  • The Mennonite Church USA Archives holds denominational records and offers an obituary index.
  • For Amish families, look for published genealogies and community directories at libraries in Amish areas, and contact the historical society nearest the settlement. A few records are not online and are only available from a local historical society or family.




Need help finding more records? We have genealogy research services available. You can also try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1.3 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.



Related Topics