Finding Castle Garden Immigration Records
What survives from New York's immigrant landing depot of 1855 to 1890 and how to search it
Castle Garden was the immigrant landing depot at the southern tip of Manhattan, run by New York State from 1855 to 1890, before Ellis Island opened. According to the National Park Service, more than 8 million people passed through it, about 75 percent of all immigrants to the United States in those years. If your German, Irish, English, Scandinavian, or Italian ancestor arrived at New York in that window, there is a good chance he or she came through Castle Garden.
Note that the records you will search today are not Castle Garden's own paperwork. Knowing what survives, and what does not, will save you a lot of frustration.
What Survives and What Was Lost
Castle Garden kept its own registers of arrivals. When the federal government took over immigration in 1890, those state records were moved to the federal immigration station, and they were destroyed when the original Ellis Island buildings burned in 1897.
However, a separate set of records survived. Since 1819, federal law had required the captain of every ship arriving from a foreign port to file a passenger list with the local customs collector. The U.S. Customs Service kept these lists apart from the immigration station, so they were not lost in the fire. These customs passenger lists cover the same arrivals, and they are what every "Castle Garden" database actually indexes. The National Archives microfilmed them as series M237, Passenger Lists of Vessels Arriving at New York, 1820-1897.
Possible Information Found in the Passenger Lists
- passenger's name
- age and sex
- occupation
- nationality or country of citizenship
- last residence, in later lists
- intended destination
- name of the ship
- port of departure
- date of arrival
- notes on deaths during the voyage
The earliest lists were not standardized, and many give only a country rather than a town. In 1883 the federal government began requiring more detailed manifests with a column for the immigrant's specific last residence. If your ancestor arrived after that, the list is more likely to name a town or district you can follow up in records from the old country.
Limitations of the Castle Garden Era Lists
- The lists cover only the Port of New York. An ancestor who landed at Boston, Philadelphia, Baltimore, or New Orleans is in that port's own records.
- Not every list survived, so some arrivals cannot be found at all.
- There is no microfilmed name index for New York arrivals from 1846 to 1897. The only federal index covers 1820 to 1846, so for most of the Castle Garden years you must rely on modern online indexes.
- Clerks often guessed at unfamiliar names, and indexers later misread the handwriting, so spellings in the index may be far from what the family used.
- The lists generally do not name parents or relatives in the U.S. Those columns were not added until after the Castle Garden years.
Tips for Searching Castle Garden Arrivals
- Find the arrival year first: the 1900 and 1910 census asked for the year of immigration, and naturalization papers often give the year, port, and sometimes the ship.
- Search by first name, age, and year: when the surname has been badly misspelled, leaving it out or using a wildcard can turn up the right person.
- Look at the whole page: families and neighbors from the same village often traveled together, and looking at others that appear near your ancestor on the list can help you to locate potential family members.
- Always view the image: the index may leave out the residence or destination columns, or may have misread the age or nationality.
- Check more than one index: each website indexed the lists separately, so a name missed on one site may be found on another.
Say your ancestor John Smith told the 1900 census he immigrated in 1868. You could search the New York lists for a John Smith of about the right age arriving that year, then compare the occupation and nationality with what you know. If a wife and children with matching names appear on the next lines, you can be fairly confident you have the right family.
Where to Find Castle Garden Passenger Lists
- Search our New York immigration records directory to find passenger list and naturalization sources for the state.
- FamilySearch has the free collection New York, Passenger Lists, 1820-1920, with images of the M237 lists. For earlier arrivals, it also has New York, New York, Index to Passenger Lists, 1820-1846.
- Ancestry.com has New York, U.S., Arriving Passenger and Crew Lists (including Castle Garden and Ellis Island), 1820-1957.
- MyHeritage has its own index in Ellis Island and Other New York Passenger Lists, 1820-1957.
- The original microfilm, M237, is held by the National Archives and is worth checking directly when every online index comes up empty, since you can browse the lists by arrival date.
Need help finding more records? We have genealogy research services available. You can also try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1.3 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.
Related Topics
- Learning Genealogy Articles more than 140 helpful articles to help you to do genealogy more effectively