USA > New York > Steuben County > History of the settlement of Steuben County, N.Y. including notices of the old pioneer settlers and their adventures, 1853 > Part 13
Note: The text from this book was generated using artificial intelligence so there may be some errors. The full pages can be found on Archive.org (link on the Part 1 page).
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16 | Part 17 | Part 18 | Part 19 | Part 20
The Congregational church was organized in 1804, and at that time consisted of eleven members. The first church: edifice was erected in 1807, and was a framed building standing near the southeast corner of the public square. The worshippers it seems were at first inclined to build it of logs, greatly to the displeasure of Capt. Pratt, who "retorted upon the society the anathema pronounced against those who dwelt in ceil- ed houses while the temple of the Lord laid waste."
193
Rev. John Niles and Rev. James H. Hotchkin were the early ministers of this society.
The West Hill settlement was commenced in 1805, by Stephen Prentiss, Warham Parsons, and Aaron Cook. The settlement of Riker's Hollow was com- menced in 1807, by Michael Keith, who was joined in 1810, by Thomas Riker, John Riker, and William Drake.
" Captain Pratt, who figures so conspicuously in our early history, and who was the founder of our town, and to a great extent the fashioner of its polity, continued to reside among this people till 1820, when he ended his mortal career. His last days were a sort of patriarchal retirement, and to this day his memory is cherished by all who knew him."-(MS. Hist.)
Judge Porter died in 1847. He was for many years one of the most prominent citizens of the town, and was a man of liberal education, of much literary taste, and an efficient and conscientious magistrate. The annal- ist, ofthe town says, "He probably filled more offices of trust among this people than any other man of his day. Our early town records show that all the most responsible offices within our bounds have from time to time been filled by him."
Rev. James H. Hotchkin, a venerable and widely known citizen of Prattsburgh, (author of The History of the Presbyterian Church in Western New York, here- tofore alluded to,) died September 2d, 1851. He was the son of Beriah Hotchkin, a pioneer missionary. He graduated at Williams College, 1800; studied theology with Dr. Porter, of Cattskill, removed to- 18
.
194
Prattsburgh in 1809, and there labored twenty-one years. The Genesee Evangelist says of him " He had a mind of a strong masculine order, well disciplined by various reading, and stored with general knowledge. The doctrinal views of the good old orthordox New England stamp which he imbibed at first, he main- tained strenuously to the last, and left a distinct im- pression of them wherever he had an opportunity to inculcate them. His labors through the half century were 'abundant' and indefatigable. He had the hap- piness of closing his life in the scenes of his greatest usefulness."
WHEELER.
The first permanent settler in this town was Capt. Silas Wheeler, a native of Rhode Island, who emi- grated from Albany County, in the State of New York, in the year 1790 or 1800. Capt. Joel Pratt made a purchase of several thousand acres in this town, in the year previous, and had made a clearing of one hundred and ten acres, and raised a crop of wheat from it, on what is now known as the " Mitchell farm." Capt. Pratt was permitted, by Capt. Williamson, to ex- change this for a tract in the town of Prattsburgh, where he removed in 1804, or about that time.
Capt. Wheeler had been a man of adventure. He was one of Benedict Arnold's men in the perilous march through the forests of Maine, and at the assault of Quebec stood near Montgomery when he fell. He was four times taken prisoner in the revolutionary war -twice on land, and twice when roving the high seas
195
as privateer's man. From his first captivity, he was soon released by exchange. After another capture, he lay in prison more than a year. Being taken a second time on one of the daring privatcers that tor- mented the British coast, he was confined in the Jail of Kinsale, in Ireland, and condemned to be hung as a pirate-or at least was very rudely treated, and threa- tened with hanging by powers that had the authority to make good their threats. He escaped this disagree- able fate by the assistance of a friendly Irishman, and of the distinguished orator and statesman Henry Grat- tan. Mr. Grattan procured for him a passport, pro- tected him from press-gangs and the police, and se- cured for him a passage to Dunkirk, in France.
Capt. Wheeler was induced to settle in Steuben County by Preston, the Surveyor, (mentioned in the sketch of the settlement of Prattsburgh,) who, on his return to Westerlo, spread the most glowing accounts of the fertility and prospects of the Conhocton Country. Capt. Wheeler's settlement was made at the place now occupied by his grand-son, Mr. Grattan H. Wheeler.
Capt. Wheeler's first trip to mill, is worthy of re- cord. There were, at the time when he had occasion to " go to mill," three institutions in the neighbor- hood where grinding was done-at the Friend's Settle- ment, at Bath, and at Naples. The mill-stones of Bath had suspended operations-there being nothing there to grind, as was reported. Capt Wheeler made & cart, of which the wheels were sawn from the end of & log of curly-maple; the box was of corresponding architecture. He started for Naples with two oxen
196
attached to this vehicle. Two young men went before the oxen with axes and chopped a road, and the clumsy chariot came floundering through the bushes behind- bouncing over the logs, and snubbing the stumps, like a ship working through an ice-field. The first day they reached a point a little beyond the present vil- lage of Prattsburgh-a distance of six miles from their starting point-and on the second, moored triumphant- ly at the mill of Naples.
Capt. Wheeler was a man famous for anecdotes throughout all the land. Not one of the multitude of Captains, who flourished in our country in early days, earned his military title more fairly. He died in 1828,. aged 78. Hon. Grattan H. Wheeler, son of Capt. Wheeler, died in 1852. He had been a prominent citizen of the county many years, and had served in the State and National Legislature.
After Capt. Wheeler's settlement, lots were pur- chased, and improvements made by persons residing abroad, some of whom afterwards established them- selves on these farms. Thomas Aulls, Esq., a son of William Aulls, the first settler of Pleasant Valley, and Col. Barney, of the same neighborhood, with Philip Murtle, who lived on the farm now owned by Gen. Otto F. Marshall, were among the earliest settlers after the Wheelers. These, with settlers named Bear, Ferral, and Rifle, were mentioned by our informant as constituting all, or nearly all, of the original stock of settlers. Esq. Gray came in at an early time. The Gulf Road to Bath was opened by Capt. Wheeler ; the Kennedyville Road was opened a year or two after-
197
wards. The first saw-mill in the town stood at the Narrows of the Five Mile Creek, and was built by Capt. Wheeler.
PULTENEY.
The first settlement in the town of Pulteney, was made on Bully Hill, by John Van Camp and D. Thomp- son, in 1797. The following are the names of other early settlers from 1799 to 1807 :- Samuel Miller, G. F. Fitz Simmons, Thomas Hoyt, Abraham Bennet, Ephraim Eggleston, John Kent, Joseph Hall, senior, Samuel Wallis, John Turner, John Ellis, Augustus Tyler, and Ezra Pelton. John Gulick kept the first dry goods store in the town .*
HOWARD.
Abraham Johnston settled in 1806 where Richard Towle now lives, and about the same time, Samuel Ba- ker settled where J. Rice now lives, and Reuben Smith, Abraham Smith and Abel Bullard, settled on the road between Goff's Mills and the old Turnpike, near the old State Road. Jacob, Benjamin and Daniel N. Ben- nett, settled in 1807, or about that time, on what is yet called Bennett's Flatts, Job B. Rathbun, with three of his brothers, in the Rathbun settlement, in 1808 or 1809. William Allen and David Smith, in the Pond settlement in 1810 or '11, and Captain Joel Rice and Esq. Israel Baldwin in 1811 or '12. Ma- jor Thomas Bennet settled on the old turnpike about
* Communicated by Melchior Wagener, Es 18*
-
198
six miles east of Hornellsville, toward 1808. Colonel Henry Kennedy built a saw-mill at Goff's Mills in 1809. William Goff, Esq., came in in 1812.
The town of Howard was set off from the old town. of Canisteo in 1812. The first town meeting was held at the house of Simeon Bacon, on the old turnpike, in the spring of 1813. In the year 1812, there were about thirty families in the town .*
HORNBY AND ORANGE. +
Asia and Uriah Nash, the first settlers of Hornby, settled in 1814, in the north part of the town called Nash settlement. Edward Stubbs, Ezra Shaw, Samuel Adams, and Jesse Underwood, settled in 1815. In the same year, Jesse Platt, John Babbins and Amasa Stanton, settled in the Platt settlement, in the south- western part of the town. James S. Gardner, Ches- ter Knowlton, and Adin Palmer settled in the Palmer settlement in 1816.
Darius Hunt, Chauncey Hunt, James Overhiser and Thomas Hurd, were the first settlers in Orange, on Mcad's Creek, probably in 1812.
CONHOCTON.I
Captain Williamson, about the time of the settle- ment of Bath, sent a man named Bivin, to the Twenty- two mile Tree, (now Blood's Corners,) to keep a tavern.
* Communicated by William Goff, Esq.
+ Communicated by Henry Gardner, Esq.
# Commnicated by Mr. Levi Chamberlain.
199
This point was known in early times as Bivin's Cor- ners. The first settlement made in the town of Con- hocton after this, was made, according to the best of our information, in the Raymond Settlement, by James and Aruna Woodward. In 1806, Joseph Chamber- lain, of Herkimer County, settled on the Davis farm, near Liberty Corners. His household consisted of a cow and a dog. All his property, besides his axe, was
contained in a small pack. For his cow the accommo- dations were rather rude. When the hour of milking arrived, the settler resorted to the strange expedient. of driving the beast " a straddle of a log," and milk- ing into a notch cut with his axe. Into this he crum- - bled his bread, and ate therefrom with a wooden spoon.
In the following year, Levi Chamberlain, Captain Jones Cleland, Joseph Shattuck and Deacon Horace Fowler, settled in this neighborhood. Other early settlers were-Timothy Sherman, James Barnard, Samuel Rhoades, Jesse Atwood, Isaac Morehouse, and Charles Burlingham. "The Brownsons settled at Loon Lake at an early day. Abram Lint settled at Lint Hill, in 1809, or about that time, and afterwards the Hatches, the Ketchers, and others.
Captain Cleland built in 1808 the first mills. Levi Chamberlain built in 1809, the first frame house at Liberty Corners, and Joseph Shattuck kept the first tavern at the same place about the same time.
On account of some legislative. awkwardness, the settlers in the northern part of the town, went for sev- eral years to Bath, to vote at town meetings, while those in the southern part went to Dansville. The
200
two squads of voters used to meet each other on the road when going to the polls.
THE COUNTRY SOUTH OF CANISTEO.
The following are names of settlers who were living in 1810 in the town of Troupsburgh, which then com- prised nearly all the territory in the county south of the Canisteo River, "Beginning on the east side, the settlers were Caleb Smith, Daniel Johnson, Lemuel Benham, Breakhill Patrick, Samuel B. Rice, Nathaniel Mallory, Elijah Johnson, Joseph Smith, Reazin Searle and Bethuel Tubbs. Further west, on the old State Road, were Ebenezer Spencer, Andrew Simpson and a family of Marlatts, Elisha Hance, Philip Cady, Eli- jah Cady, Samuel Cady, Peter Cady, Caleb Colvin, Matthew Grinnolds, William Card, Charles Card ; and west of the old State Road, were Nathan Coffin, Henry Garrison, Edmund Robinson, Jeremiah Nudd. The last three came in 1812, Alanson Perry came in 1810. There was some others here in an early day, as by the census of 1815, there were over 500 inhabitants."* Daniel Johnson was Supervisor till 1812, and Charles Card from 1813 to 1819. Samuel B. Rice was Town Clerk for about twenty years. The first grist-mill was built by Caleb Smith, the second by George Mar- tin in 1812. " There was but little improvement made for several years, and many of the first settlers became discouraged and emigrated to the West, and the town seemed to be at a stand. Those remaining have become
* Communicated by Charles Card, Esq.
201
comfortable in circumstances." The Brotzman's, Andrew Boyd, the Rowleys and John Craig were early settlers of Jasper.
ORANGE. *
" That part of the Town of Orange called Mead's Creek was settled, or began to be settled, a few years previous to 1820. Among the inhabitants who were there previous to or about that time, were Jedediah Miller, Andrew Fort, David Kimball, Esq., and his brother Moses, John Dyer, Sylvester Goodrich, and three settlers named Hewitt. Joshua Chamberlain came there four or five years later and bought the land where the village of Monterey stands, of a man by the name of De Witt.
. " The northeast part of the Town of Orange known by the appellation of Sugar Hill, did not receive its name from any distinguished elevation or large hill, but from the following circumstance. Some of the men and boys from the older settlements used to come to this place to make sugar in the spring of the year, while it
was yet a wilderness. They had traversed the woods in quest of deer, and taken notice of the fine groves of maple in this locality, and as there were no settlers on the land, and nobody in their way, they had an excel- lent chance for making sugar ; and as they had to give the place some name, they called it Sugar Hill. The settlement began about the year 1819 or 1820. Lewis Nichols, William Webb, Thomas Horton, Abraham
* Communicated by Dr. Silas B. Hibbard, of Sugar Hill.
202
Allen, John Allen, Ebenezer Beach, Mr. Eveleth, Sey- mour Lockwood, and two families of Comptons, were among the first settlers. Dr. Hibbard arrived in 1821, and Abraham Lybolt, Esq., came about the same time.
" After the commencement of the settlement the land was very soon taken up by actual settlers. The fertility of the soil, its proximity to the head of Seneca Lake, their anticipated place of market, the easy man- ner of obtaining the land from the Land Office at Bath, their confidence in the validity of the title, and perhaps the novelty of the name, might all have contributed to the speedy settlement of the place."
CAMPBELL.
THE first permanent settlers of that part of the old Town of Bath which is now the Town of Campbell, were Joseph Stevens, Robert Campbell, Solomon Camp- bell, and Archa Campbell. In addition to these, the remaining inhabitants of the Town in the year 1800, and about that time, were, Elias Williams, blacksmith, Samuel Calkins, farmer, Abram Thomas and Isaac Thomas, hunters, James Pearsall, farmer, David Mc- Nutt, Joseph Woolcott, and - - Sailor.
AVOCA.
AVOCA wasknown in the early part of Col. William- son's time as " Buchanan's," or the Eight-Mile-Tree. The name of the first settler, as the title of the settle- ment indicates, was Buchanan. He was established at
* Communicated by Mr. Samuel Cook, of Campbell.
203
that point by the agent and kept "accommodations " for travellers. A correspondent has returned the names of the oldest residents as follows : James Mc- Whorter, Abraham Towner, Gersham Towner, Daniel Tilton, John Donnahee, Spence Moore, Henry Smith, Allen Smith, who have been residents for about thirty years, and John B. Calkins, Joseph Matthewson, Ger- sham Salmon, James Davis, and James Silsbee, who have been residents about twenty-four years.
WAYLAND .*
THE first settlement in the town of Wayland was made by - Zimmerman, in 1806, on the farm now occupied by J. Hess, at the depot. The north part of the town was settled by Captain Bowles (1808), Mr. Hicks (about 1810), Thomas Begole (1814), Mr. Bow- en (1808), and John Hume (1808).
The settlements at Loon Lake in the south part of the town, were made in 1813 by Salmon Brownson. James Brownson, Elisha Brownson, and Isaac Willie,
The settlers of the central part of the town were Walter Patchin (1814), Dr. Warren Patchin (1815), Dennis Hess (1815), Benjamin Perkins, and Samuel Draper.
" No road passed through the town except the an- cient one from Bath to Dansville. It was a hard town to settle, and people were generally poor. They passed through many hardships and privations, but now our town is in a prosperous condition.
* Communicated by Rev. E. Brownson.
204
" One circumstance connected with the early settle- ment of this town may be somewhat interesting. In 1815, there being a scarcity of bread, I went through the towns of Springwater, Livonia, and Sparta, and thence to Dansville, in search of grain for sale, and none was to be had in those towns, nor in Western New York. People had to hull green wheat and rye for food. I found a field of rye on William Perine's farm which was thought nearly fit to cut. I went home and got some neighbors, and with oxen and cart went and cut some of it, threshed it, and took it to the mill and had it mashed, for it was too damp to grind, and thought ourselves the happiest people in the world be- cause we had bread."
.
1
CHAPTER VIII.
THE AIR CASTLE VANISHING-THE CLOSE OF COL. WILLIAMSON'S AGENCY-HIS CHARACTER.
Nearly sixty years have passed away since the Scot- tish Captain started from the West Branch in pursuit of the air-castle which shone so bravely like a bal- loon to him, looking northward from the Cliffs of North- umberland. The changes which have in the mean time been wrought upon this continent, are without a parallel in the world's annals. Prophecy has been put to silence : conjecture has proved a fool ; for the things which have been accomplished exceed so far any thing promised in the visions of political prophets, or in the ravings of dreamers, that the extravagance of our ancient soothsayers is this day accounted modera- tion. No conquest of Goths, or Tartars can be com- pared for rapidity with that which has been achieved by the woodsmen of America in the overthrow of a forest as broad as an ocean. The little weapon which they wielded against the innumerable host that they went forth to conquer, seemed enchanted, like the swords of those champions of old, who are said to have slain their pagan enemies till rivers were choked, and hollows became hillocks. States have been founded,
.
19
206
cities built, savage rivers made highways, prairies where the Genius of Barbarism fed his herds of elk and buffalo, made pastures for mules and bullocks, and the lakes which lay afar off in the solitudes, cross- ed only by flocks of wild fowl and the fleets of Indian admirals, have been gladdened by the keels of steam- ships and the watchful flame of light-houses. The ut- most western wilderness which the settler of "The Genesee" beheld over the Lakes, and which he sur- mised might become the dwelling place of desperate pioneers when he had been a century in his grave, is now but midway between Niagara and the outposts of the Republic, and caravans of restless men, pressing beyond these momentary borders, have crossed the Cor- dilleras and built cities on the coast of the Pacific.
Where now is the gallant Scot and his city ? The Genesee country has not lagged in the advances of the Republic. Its population is counted by hundred thou- sands, and its wealth is told by millions ; but the me- mory of the city builder and his schemes has almost perished. While the Northern counties have been making almost unexampled strides to power and opu- lence, the district which wise men of the last century pointed at as the centre of future Western commerce has dragged its slow length along in poverty and ob- scurity, and only by the sheerest labor has reached its present position of independence. The Great West- ern Highway was diverted from the valley of the Con- hocton. For a quarter of a century the wealth of the North and West has been rolling in one tremendous forrent to the Mohawk and the Hudson, and by the
ยท
207
side of the channel through which it poured, the demon, our ancient enemy aforementioned, has struck swamps and salt-bogs with his staff, and forthwith cities have risen from the mire. The little river which was to have been the drudge of the broad northwest, carrying to the seaboard squadrons of rough arks laden with the grains of Gencsee and far-off Michigan, has been hap- pily delivered from that tedious servitude, and ram- bles idly through its valley, turning a few mill-wheels and watering meadows. The fair valley of Bath, in- stead of groaning under the weight of a wilderness of bricks where brokers and cashiers, and other mercan- tile monsters might go about, gratifying their financial instincts to the full, bears at this day only a quiet village and a few ranges of farms, and is girdled by wooded hillsides as wild as in the days when the great Captain of the Six Nations was wont to rest with his warriors under their shadows.
The memory of the Scot and his city has almost pe- rished. A Senator of the United States, addressing not long since the members of the Legislatures of the State of New York, guests of the city of New York, at the Astor House, spoke of the prediction of a tra- veller in the year 1800, that the village of Bath on the Conhocton river, would in fifty years become the com- mercial metropolis of the State of New York.# The
* A portion of the speech of Hon. WILLIAM H. SEWARD, at the Astor House, on the evening of March 22, 1851, is thus reported in the New York Courier and Enquirer :
" Gentlemen : It seems to me that we can improve this festival occasion by considering how intimate is the relation between the
208
public heard it with surprise. Many men of the past generation remembered the name of Williamson, but of the present generation few, except citizens of West- ern New York, knew of the attempted assassination of the great Atlantic city.
The story of the downfall of the Backwoods Baron - and his city, is a brief one. Ten years Col. Williamson
City and the State,-how essential each is to the other. There is a town in the interior of the State, far away in what was lately known as the secluded, sequestered part of it, Bath by name. Many of the representatives of the Rural Districts know it well: the members from Steuben can speak for it. Of this town I wish to speak. It is a beautiful but quiet one, situated in the delightful valley and on the banks of the Conhocton, a tributary of the Susquehanna. But those who know it well have remarked, that it has a broad and 1magnificent plan, imperfectly filled out. There are houses on cor- ners, designating streets and avenues, without inhabitants. In short, it was laid out for a great city, but has long since renounced all am- bitious pretensions. You do not know how this has happened. Well if on your return to Albany, you will call on my excellent friend (Mr. Street,) the State Librarian, he will give you a small duodeci- mo volume, published in the year 1800, containing an account of a journey performd by an English gentleman in the short space of six weeks, from the city of New York all the way to Niagara Falls. That traveller visited Bath, then in the day-spring of its growth, and he recorded of it that it was destined to be the greatest commer- cial metropolis of the State of New York .- The Hudson was only a short arm of the sea. It did not penetrate the interior far enough to take a hold of the trade of the country. Bath was to receive all of it that could be diverted from the channel of the St. Lawrence and the market of Quebec, and send it down through the Conhocton and the Susquehanna to Chesapeake Bay. Had that calculation been realized, Bath might have been a city like Albany, and New York would have been a city over which the President could have had but little ambition to preside."-(Cheers.)
209
lived on the Conhocton, and exhausted all chemistry in his experiments upon the possibility of turning a- castle of rainbows into stone. His expenditures had been enormous, and the British proprietors began to grumble audibly. The towers of glass, which they once imagined they saw glimmering in the wilderness, were scrutinized with profound suspicion. But whatever doubt there might be about the reality of those struc- tures, as to one thing there could be no doubt at all. The greedy wilderness was swallowing the fortune of the Pulteneys with as little gratitude as an anaconda. Hundreds of thousands of pounds had been thrown to that monster, and like the grave it was yet hungry. To satisfy such a remorseless appetite one needed a silver mine, or a credit with the goblins.
Col. Williamson, however, was not discouraged. Time enough has not been given, he argued. Even a magician would not undertake to perform such a chem- ical exploit in ten years. The brilliant balloon which overhangs the wilderness is not yet securely anchored, it is true, and sways to and fro as if it might possibly rise into the air and sail away. Give but a few years more and every thing will be accomplished.
But the faith and patience of the proprietors had become utterly exhausted. They had had enough of balloons and ballooning, and were deaf to argument. Like one awaking from enchantment, the Baronet saw the towers of ivory to be but squat pens of logs, and the spires of glass, but long dead trunks of hemlocks, bristling with spikes and blackened with fire. It was determined to change the system which had regulated 19* -
Need help finding more records? Try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.