When You Find an Ancestor Listed Twice in the Census
Why some people appear twice in the same census year and how to sort out the entries
Each person was supposed to be counted only once in a U.S. census, at the place where he or she usually lived. In practice, an ancestor sometimes turns up twice in the same census year, in 2 different households or even 2 different counties. Sometimes both entries are genuine census records, not an indexing mistake, and comparing them can tell you more than either one alone.
Note that finding a second entry with the same name does not prove it is the same person. Before treating 2 entries as a duplicate, check that the ages, birthplaces, and family members match.
Why a Person Could Be Counted Twice
Census takers were told to record people at their usual place of abode, but the meaning of that was not always clear. A young man working as a farm hand or a boarder in town might be listed by his employer or landlord and also listed at home by his parents. Students, sailors, travelers, and people visiting relatives could be counted in 2 places. A family that moved during the weeks the census was being taken might be counted at the old home and again at the new one.
Duplicates also happened where enumerators' territories met. A family living near a district boundary sometimes shows up in the returns for both districts.
The 1870 Second Enumeration
The 1870 census was widely criticized for missing people, and a few places were counted a second time using the same official census day. The best known are New York City, Philadelphia, and Indianapolis, along with a few other smaller places. Both enumerations survive, so an ancestor in one of these places may properly appear twice in 1870. The second enumerations for New York City and Philadelphia also include street addresses, which the first count did not, making them worth finding even if you have already located the family in the first.
County Copies of the Census
From 1850 through 1880, more than one copy of the census schedules was made, and in some places a copy was kept locally. A few of these county copies survive. Because a clerk copied them by hand, a county copy can differ slightly from the federal copy, with a misspelled name or a different age. If you search a collection made from a county copy, you may find what looks like a second entry for your ancestor.
When the Duplicate Is Only in the Index
Some repeated entries are not 2 census visits at all. A page may have been filmed twice, or indexed twice by different volunteers, producing 2 index entries for the same page. The difference is simple to spot when you look at the images: a filming duplicate shows the identical page twice, while a true double count shows 2 different pages, often with a different date, handwriting, and set of neighbors.
Say you find John Smith, age 19, born in Ohio, living with his parents in one county in 1880, and a John Smith, age 19, born in Ohio, working as a farm laborer in the household of a neighboring farmer. If the birthplaces of his parents match on both entries, he was very likely counted at home and at work.
Tips for Sorting Out Duplicate Census Entries
- Compare the dates of enumeration: each page usually shows the date the census taker visited, and a gap of weeks may mean the family moved between visits.
- Compare the details: ages, birthplaces, occupations, and the names of other household members can confirm whether 2 entries are the same person or 2 different people.
- Look at the neighbors: looking at others that appear near a family on the list can help you to locate potential family members and neighbors, and different neighbors suggest 2 real places.
- Check the informant marks in 1940: the 1940 census marked the person who gave the information with a circled X and marked household members who were temporarily away with "Ab," which can explain why someone appears in 2 households.
- Check other records from the same year: a city directory, tax list, or church record can show where the family was really living.
- Keep both entries: cite both in your notes and treat any difference between them as a clue, since one entry may give a detail the other lacks.
Where to Find the Census Records
- Search our census records directory by state and county to find federal and state census sources, including some county copies.
- When you find 2 entries, open the image for each one rather than relying on the index. The same census is sometimes indexed separately on different sites, so a name that is misread in one index may be correct in another.
Need help finding more records? We have genealogy research services available. You can also try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1.3 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.
Related Topics
- Learning Genealogy Articles more than 140 helpful articles to help you to do genealogy more effectively