Why Ages Change From One Census to the Next

Reasons an ancestor's age varies between census years and how to work out the right birth year



An ancestor's age in the census can go up 12 years in a decade, go up only 9, or be off by 2 or 3 years from what other records show. This does not usually mean you have the wrong person, and it does not mean anyone lied. Most people of the past had no birth certificate to check, and the age written down depended on who answered, which date the census was counting from, and the common habit of rounding.


Who Answered the Enumerator


For the 1850, 1860, and 1870 censuses, enumerators were told to get information from the head of the family. Starting in 1880, the rules allowed any member of the family who seemed reliable to answer, and if no one was home, a neighbor could be asked. A wife might know her husband's age, but a teenage son or a boarder might guess. Each census year may have had a different informant, which alone can explain many age changes.


The 1940 census is the only one that shows who answered. The enumerator marked a circled X after that person's name. Before 1940, nothing on the page tells you whether an age came from the person or from someone guessing for them.


The Official Census Day


Each census was supposed to record ages as of an official census day, not the day the enumerator visited. These dates were:


  • 1850 through 1900: June 1
  • 1910: April 15
  • 1920: January 1
  • 1930 through 1950: April 1


Because the census day changed, the time between 2 censuses was not always exactly 10 years. From June 1900 to April 1910 was less than 10 years, and from April 1910 to January 1920 was less than 10 years as well. A person with a birthday in February or March could easily appear only 9 years older in the next census. Enumerators also sometimes recorded the age on the day of their visit instead of the official day, which can move an age by a year.


Rounding and Guessing


Many people did not know their exact age. The 1890 census instructions warned that "the general tendency of persons in giving their ages is to use the round numbers, as 20, 25, 30, 35, 40." Look for ages ending in 0 or 5 as a sign that the number may be an estimate. Also note that most census years asked for age at the last birthday, but the 1890 census asked for age at the nearest birthday. Sometimes people also gave a younger age on purpose, such as a woman who was older than her husband or a man trying to appear younger for work.


The 1900 Census Gives Month and Year of Birth


The 1900 census is the only one that asked for both a person's age and the month and year of birth. This makes it especially useful when ages vary. You can check whether the birth year and age agree with each other, and use the birth month to see how the person's birthday fell in relation to other census days. The 1870 and 1880 censuses also gave a month of birth, but only for babies born during the year before the census.


An Example


Say your ancestor John Smith is listed as age 30 in 1880, 48 in 1900 with a birth date of March 1852, 57 in 1910, and 65 in 1920. With a birthday in March, he would have been 48 on 1 June 1900, 58 on 15 April 1910, and 67 on 1 January 1920. The 1910 and 1920 ages are each off by a year or two, and the 1880 age of 30 looks like a rounded number. All 4 entries still fit a man born about 1852, which is what the 1900 census states.


Tips for Working With Census Ages


  • Make a chart of every census year with the age given, the census day, and the birth year it suggests.
  • Expect a range: a difference of 1 or 2 years is ordinary, and most ages fall within about 5 years of the true birth year.
  • Give more weight to the 1900 census birth month and year, and to records the person had a reason to answer carefully, such as a draft registration or naturalization petition.
  • Be cautious with death certificates: the age is often given by a relative who did not know the birth year.
  • Confirm the family, not just the age: matching spouse, children, and birthplaces are better evidence that you have the right person.


Where to Find Census Records





Need help finding more records? We have genealogy research services available. You can also try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1.3 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.



Related Topics