USA > Massachusetts > Suffolk County > Boston > St. Botolph's town; an account of old Boston in colonial days > Part 1
Note: The text from this book was generated using artificial intelligence so there may be some errors. The full pages can be found on Archive.org.
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16 | Part 17 | Part 18
Old Boston in Colonial Days ST. BOTOLPH'S TOWN,
Mary Caroline Crawford
M. L
Gc 974.402 B65c 1135645
Old Boston in Lincolnshire
n
ALLEN COUNTY PUBLIC LIBRARY 3 1833 01105 8929
0 ;
B. Mc Manus
GENEALOGY COLLECTION
OLD BOSTON IN COLONIAL DAYS OR, ST. BOTOLPH'S TOWN FROM THE TIME OF BLACKSTONE, THE FIRST SETTLER, TO THE OUTBREAK OF THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION
Works of Mary Caroline Crawford
The Romance of
Old New England Rooftrees $2.50
The College Girl of America
2.50
Among Old New England Inns
2.50
Old Boston in Colonial Days
4.00
THE PAGE COMPANY 53 Beacon Street, Boston, Mass.
Elsie J. Shewood. July 1930.
Lieutenant-Governor Hutchinson in the Audience Chamber of the Province House From a painting by Frank T. Merrill
Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2015
https://archive.org/details/stbotolphstownac00craw_0
Old Boston in Colonial
Days ;
or, St. Botolph's Town
From the Time of Blackstone, the First Settler, to the Outbreak of the American Revolution
BY MARY CAROLINE CRAWFORD
Author of "Among Old New England Inns," "The Romance of Old New England Rooftrees." etc.
Illustrated
C
BOSTON THE PAGE COMPANY MDCCCCXXII
Copyright, 1908 BY THE PAGE COMPANY All rights reserved
Made in U. S. A.
PRINTED BY C. H. SIMONDS COMPANY BOSTON, MASS., U. S. A.
1135645
FOREWORD
IN my student days colonial history never interested me. I did not then understand why but I am now perfectly certain that it was be- cause persons and events were discussed, in most of the books set before me, only as their careers touched New England and hence in so fragmentary a way as to make them appear mere puppets with tiresome dates attached. The treatment usually accorded Sir Harry Vane offers an excellent example of what I mean. He flashed before us, in the history books, as a brilliant, handsome youth who espoused the cause of Mrs. Hutchinson, - and then disappeared for ever from view. Because his wonderful career in England was deemed to have nothing to do with the subsequent his- tory of Massachusetts we were deprived of the great privilege it would have been to make his inspiring life-story a part of our mental equip- ment! If this volume errs in the other extreme
Y
1- 2.00
vi
Foreword
by talking over-much of Vane and of La Tour after their connection with Boston has ceased the fault may be attributed to a reaction from my own defective education.
The truth is that it is biography rather than history which really allures me; history seems to me worse than useless unless it illus- trates the times of which it writes as those times affected the lives of its men and women. A book like this has no justification, to my mind, save as it makes us understand just a little better the part New England, in the per- son of its chief town, has played in the mighty drama of nations made up of thinking, feeling men and women.
Up to the time of the Revolution, of course, Boston was the biggest place in all the colonies as well as the chief settlement of Massachu- setts. This numerical preëminence needs to be borne in mind if we would understand many acts on both sides of the ocean. To understand the America of to-day, too, we must needs know the Boston of the fathers. So only can we be sure that the excrescences of modern govern- ment are no essential part of that Christian state of which Winthrop dreamed and for which Vane was glad to die.
The books consulted in the preparation of
vii
Foreword
this work have been many and, for the most part, are named in the text. But sweeping credit is here due to the invaluable " Memorial History of Boston " and to the " Boston An- tiquities " of Samuel Drake. I have to thank also Mr. Irwin C. Cromack of the engineering department, City of Boston, for kindly aid given and the editor of the Canadian Magazine for permission to incorporate in the chapter " How Winthrop Treated With the La Tours " my article on the " Fight Between La Tour and D'Aulnay " contributed to his magazine last year. M. C. C.
"S "T. BOTOLPH'S Town ! Far over leagues of land
And leagues of sea looks forth its noble tower, And far around the chiming bells are heard : So may that sacred name forever stand A landmark and a symbol of the power That lies concentred in a single word."
- LONGFELLOW.
66
T HE distinctive characteristic of the settlement of the English colonists in America is the in- troduction of the civilization of Europe into a wilderness without bringing with it the political insti- tutions of Europe. The arts, sciences, and literature of England came over with the settlers. . . . But the monarchy did not come, nor the aristocracy, nor the church as an estate of the realm. Political institu- tions were to be framed anew such as should be adapted to the state of things." - DANIEL WEBSTER.
T HE spirit of that age was sure to manifest itself in narrow cramping measures and in ugly acts of persecution ; but it is, none the less, to the fortunate alliance of that fervid religious enthu- siasm with the love of self-government that our modern freedom owes its existence." - JOHN FISKE.
T
66 HOU, too, sail on O ship of State ! Sail on, O Union, strong and great ! Humanity with all its fears, With all the hopes of future years Is hanging breathless on thy fate !" - LONGFELLOW.
CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
FOREWORD ·
V
I. As IT WAS IN THE BEGINNING .
1
II. JOHN WINTHROP AND MARGARET, HIS WIFE ·
17 III. ST. BOTOLPH'S TOWN IN OLD ENGLAND AND NEW . 34
IV. THE COMING OF A SHINING LIGHT 48 ·
V. SIR HARRY VANE - PROPHET AND MARTYR .
63
VI. How WINTHROP TREATED WITH THE LA TOURS VII. FREEDOM TO WORSHIP GOD .
89
VIII. BOSTON AS JOHN DUNTON SAW IT
138
IX. THE DYNASTY OF THE MATHERS
165
X. THE COLLEGE AT CAMBRIDGE . 205
XI. THE BOSTON OF FRANKLIN'S BOYHOOD 233
XII. A PURITAN PEPYS
·
.
255
XIII. IN THE REIGN OF THE ROYAL GOVERNORS 283
XIV. A GENUINE COLONIAL ROMANCE
311
XV. THE DAWN OF ACTIVE RESISTANCE
333
INDEX
361
108
List of Mustrations
B.M.M.
PAGE
LIEUTENANT-GOVERNOR HUTCHINSON IN THE AUDIENCE
CHAMBER OF THE PROVINCE HOUSE Frontispiece CAPTAIN JOHN SMITH 4
OLD' HOUSE IN MEDFORD, BUILT BY GOVERNOR CRADOCK 12
GOVERNOR JOHN WINTHROP
.
18
ST. BOTOLPH'S CHURCH, BOSTON, ENGLAND
40
JOHN COTTON'S VICARAGE
43
REV. JOHN COTTON .
56
COTTON CHAPEL, ST. BOTOLPH'S, BOSTON, ENGLAND 60
SIR HARRY VANE, FROM AN OLD MINIATURE
66
JOHN ENDICOTT
72
OLIVER CROMWELL
80
SIR HARRY VANE'S HOUSE, STILL STANDING IN HAMPSTEAD, LONDON · 86
FORT LA TOUR (OR ST. JEAN), ST. JOHN, NEW BRUNSWICK,
FROM A DRAWING BY LOUIS A. HOLMAN 102
ROGER WILLIAMS
118
THE WELLS - ADAMS HOUSE, ON SALEM STREET, WHERE THE BAPTISTS HELD SECRET MEETINGS . 121
SIR RICHARD SALTONSTALL 134
GOVERNOR SIMON BRADSTREET 147
INCREASE MATHER
·
166
HOUSE OF COTTON MATHER, WHICH STOOD AT WHAT IS NOW
298 HANOVER STREET 172
xii
List of Illustrations
PAGE
SIR EDMUND ANDROS
178
THE PRATT HOUSE, CHELSEA . 186
SIR WILLIAM PHIPS
COTTON MATHER
197
193
WILLIAM STOUGHTON
200
COVER AND TITLE-PAGE OF JOHN HARVARD'S BOOK . 206
MASSACHUSETTS HALL, HARVARD UNIVERSITY, BUILT
DURING THE PRESIDENCY OF JOHN LEVERETT · 225
GOVERNOR JOSEPH DUDLEY
· 230
MAP OF BOSTON IN 1722
Facing 232
BENJAMIN FRANKLIN
234
THE OLD FEATHER STORE 236
FRANKLIN'S BIRTHPLACE
238
SAMUEL SEWALL
255
THE DEANE WINTHROP HOUSE, WINTHROP 263
GOVERNOR BELLINGHAM'S HOUSE, CHELSEA 265
GREEN DRAGON TAVERN .
273
THE PROVINCE HOUSE
286
THE ORIGINAL KING'S CHAPEL AND THE KING'S CHAPEL OF TO-DAY 298
GOVERNOR WILLIAM BURNET .
303
THE MATHER TOMB IN THE COPP'S HILL BURYING GROUND 310
GOVERNOR WILLIAM SHIRLEY .
312
SIR HARRY FRANKLAND
316
GOVERNOR SHIRLEY'S HOUSE, ROXBURY 319
THE CLARKE HOUSE, PURCHASED BY SIR HARRY FRANK-
LAND 325
GOVERNOR POWNALL 334
SIR FRANCIS BERNARD
336
JAMES OTIS .
339
THE OLD STATE HOUSE
350
PETER FANEUIL'S HOUSE 356
SAMUEL ADAMS .
358
.
OLD BOSTON IN COLONIAL DAYS: OR, ST. BOTOLPH'S TOWN
I
AS IT WAS IN THE BEGINNING
To Sir Ferdinando Gorges, the intimate friend of Sir Walter Raleigh and a man of much more than common interest in the history of Elizabethan England, is due the credit of the first enduring settlement in the environs of Boston. John Smith had skirted the coast of New England and looked with some care into Boston Harbour before Gorges came; Miles Standish had pushed up from Plymouth to trade with the Indians of this section; and Thomas Weston, soldier of fortune, had es- tablished a temporary trading-post in what is now Weymouth. But it remained for Gorges and his son Robert to plant firmly upon our shores the standard of England and to reiter- ate that that was the country to which, by
1
2
St. Botolph's Town
virtue of the Cabots, those shores rightly be- longed.
The Cabots, to be sure, had come a century and a quarter before and, since their time, ex- plorers of several other nations had ventured to the new world - one of them even going so far as to carve his name upon the continent. But an English king had fitted out the " car- vels " of John and Sebastian Cabot; and Eng- lish kings were not in the habit of forgetting incidents of that sort. The letter in which Sebastian Cabot relates the story of those Bris- tol vessels is very quaint and interesting. " When my father," he writes, " departed from Venice many years since to dwell in Eng- land, to follow the trade of merchandizes, he took me with him to the city of London, while I was very yong, yet having, nevertheless, some knowledge of letters, of humanity and of the Sphere. And when my father died in that time when news was brought that Don Chris- tofer Colonus Genuse [Columbus] had discov- ered the coasts of India whereof was great talke in all the court of King Henry the Seventh, who then raigned, inso much that all men with great admiration affirmed it to be a thing more divine than humane, to sail by the West into the East where spices growe, by
3
As It Was in the Beginning
a way that was never known before; by this fame and report there increased in my heart a great flame of desire to attempt some notable thing. And, understanding by reason of the Sphere, that if I should saile by way of the Northwest winde, I should by a shorter track come into India, I thereupon caused the king to be advertised of my devise, who immediately commanded two Carvels to bee furnished with all things appertaining to the voiage, which was, as farre as I remember, in the yeere 1496, in the beginning of Sommer.
" I began therefore to saile toward the Northwest, not thinking to find any other land than that of Cathay, and from thence to turn toward India, but after certaine dayes I found that the land ranne towards the North, which was to me a great displeasure. Nevertheless, sailing along the coast to see if I could find any gulfe that turned, I found the land still con- tinuing to the 56 deg. under our pole. And seeing that there the coast turned toward the East, despairing to find the passage, I turned back again, and sailed down by the coast of that land towards the Equinoctiall (ever with intent to find the said passage to India) and came to that part of this firme land which is now called Florida, where my victuals failing, I
4
St. Botolph's Town
departed from thence and returned into Eng- land, where I found great tumults among the people, and preparation for warrs in Scotland : by reason whereof there was no more consid- eration had to this voyage." But barren of immediate results as this voyage undoubtedly was it is of immense importance to us as the first link in the chain which, for so long, bound America to England.
The next link was, of course, forged by Cap- tain John Smith to whom New England as well as Virginia owes more than it can ever repay. About one year before the settlement of Boston by the company which came with Winthrop Smith recapitulated the affairs of New Eng- land in the following lucid manner: " When I went first to the North part of Virginia, [in 1614] where the Westerly colony [of 1607] had been planted, which had dissolved itself within a yeare, there was not one Christian in all the land. The country was then reputed a most rockie barren, desolate desart; but the good return I brought from thence, with the maps and relations I made of the country, which I made so manifest, some of them did beleeve me, and they were well embraced, both by the Londoners and the Westerlings, for whom I
--
GLAND
THE
I/ ADMIRALL OF NEW ENGL
PORTRAICTUER OF CAPTAYNF
NE JOHN SMITH !
CAPTAIN JOHN SMITH
--
5
As It Was in the Beginning
had promised to undertake it, thinking to have joyned them all together. Betwixt them there long was much contention. The Londoners, in- deed, went bravely forward but in three or four yeares, I and my friends consumed many hundred pounds among the Plimothians, who only fed me but with delayes promises and excuses, but no performance of any kind to any purpose. In the interim many particular ships went thither, and finding my relations true, and that I had not taken that I brought home from the French men, as had beene re- ported; yet further for my paines to discredit me and my calling it New England, they ob- scured it and shadowed it with the title of Cannada, till, at my humble suit, king Charles confirmed it, with my map and booke, by the title of New England. The gaine thence re- turning did make the fame thereof so increase, that thirty forty or fifty saile, went yearely only to trade and fish; but nothing would be done for a plantation till about some hundred of your Brownists of England, Amsterdam and Leyden, went to New Plimouth, whose humour- ous ignorances caused them for more than a yeare, to endure a wonderful deale of misery with an infinite patience; but those in time do-
6
St. Botolph's Town
ing well diverse others have in small handfulls undertaken to goe there, to be severall Lords and Kings of themselves. .
The Gorges project, certainly, aimed at noth- ing short of a principality and was begun in all pomp and circumstance. To Greenwich on June 29, 1623, came the Dukes of Buckingham and Richmond, four earls and many lords and gentlemen to draw lots for possessions in the new country. This imposing group was called the Council for New England and had been established under a charter granted in 1620 to the elder Gorges and thirty-nine other patentees. Gorges had had the good luck to acquaint Raleigh with the conspiracy of the Earl of Essex against Queen Elizabeth and James I had valid reason, therefore, to appoint him governor of Plymouth in Devonshire. It was while pursuing his duties in Plymouth that his interest in New England was excited, by the mere accident, as he relates, of some Indians happening to be brought before him. At much pains he learned from them something of the nature of their country and his imagination was soon fired with the vision of golden har- vests waiting in the western continent to be reaped by such as he. Naturally sanguine and full of enthusiasm he succeeded in interesting
....
7
As It Was in the Beginning
in his project Sir John Popham, Lord Chief Justice of the King's Bench, through whose acquaintance with noblemen and connection at Court the coveted patent for making settle- ments in America was ere long secured.
Then the success of the Greenwich assembly -- King James himself drew for Buckingham! -- seems to have decided both Sir Ferdinando and his son to go at once to their glittering new world; and, a few weeks later, the latter sailed forth, armed with a commission as lieutenant of the Council with power to exercise jurisdic- tion, civil, criminal and ecclesiastical, over the whole of the New England coast. The plan was for him to settle not too far from Ply- mouth, absorb as soon as might be the little group of men and women who were really lay- ing there the foundations of a nation and be- gin in masterful fashion the administration of the vast province which was undeniably his - on paper.
At Weymouth Thomas .Weston had left a rude block-house and this Robert Gorges and his comrades immediately appropriated. In their company were several mechanics and tillers of the soil who proceeded to make them- selves useful in the new land; but of most in- terest to us because of their after-history, were
8
St. Botolph's Town
three gentlemen colonists, Samuel Maverick, a young man of means and education who es- tablished at what is now Chelsea the first per- manent house in the Bay colony, Rev. William Morrell, the Church of England representative in the brave undertaking and William Black- stone, graduate of Cambridge University and destined to renown as the first white settler of what we to-day know as Boston.
It was in September, 1623, that Robert Gorges landed in Weymouth. In the spring of 1624 he returned to England taking with him several of his comrades. Governor Bradford, whom he tried in vain to bully into obeisance observes mildly that Gorges did not find " the state of things heare to answer his Qualitie and condition." So he stayed less than a year. Some of those who had come with him were for trying the thing longer, however. Even the Rev. Mr. Morrell put in a second bitter winter before giving up the attempt. Though he speaks feelingly of the hard lot of men who are " landed upon an unknown shore, peradven- ture weake in number and naturall powers, for want of boats and carriages," and being for this reason compelled with a whole empty con- tinent before them "to stay where they are first landed, having no means to remove them-
9
As It Was in the Beginning
selves or their goods, be the place never so fruitlesse or inconvenient for planting, build- ing houses, boats or stages, or the harbors never so unfit for fishing, fowling or mooring their boats,"-yet Morrell was none the less very favourably impressed, as Smith and all the others had been, with the natural charms of New England. As the fruit of his sojourn we have a Latin poem in which the country is described in a genial and somewhat imaginative way.
The year that Morrell returned to England (1625) was in all probability that in which William Blackstone took up his abode across the bay, in Shawmut, opposite the mouth of the Charles. And it was in that same year, too, that Captain Wollaston and his party es- tablished themselves at the place since known as Mount Wollaston, in the town of Quincy.
Among Wollaston's companions was one Thomas Morton " of Clifford's Inn, Gent.," a lawyer by profession and an outlaw by practice. In the rather dull pages of early New England history Morton's escapades supply " colour," however, for which we cannot be too grateful to him. The staid Plymouth people soon came to speak of him as the " Lord of Misrule " and there is no evidence whatever that he failed
-
10
St. Botolph's Town
to deserve the title. When Wollaston departed to Virginia on business he proceeded to become captain in his stead and, naming the settlement Mare Mount, - Merry Mount, - he invited all the settlers to have a good time. They did so, according to Morton's own account -in the mad glad bad way ever dear to roystering Eng- lishmen. Not only did he and his followers drink deep of the festal bowl but they made the Indians with whom they traded welcome to drink deep also. To the men savages were given arms and ammunition while to the women was extended the privilege of becoming the mates of the conquering English. The May Day of 1627 was celebrated in revelry run riot. Morton has left us a minute description of the pole used on this occasion " a goodly pine tree of 80 foote long . with a peare of bucks horns nayled one, somewhat neare unto the top of it," while Governor Bradford says they " set up a May-pole, drinking and dan- cing aboute it many days togither, inviting the Indean women for their consorts, dancing and frisking togither (like so many fairies, or furies rather) and worse practices."
Bradford not unnaturally failed to appre- ciate the " colour." Moreover, the settlers could not, of course, have the natives furnished
11
As It Was in the Beginning
with firearms. So Morton was, after some difficulty, made a prisoner and shipped off to England. But he came back again the next year and for a considerable time was a veri- table thorn in the flesh to Endicott and his com- panions at Salem.
The Salem settlement was in the nature of a rescuing party. For while Sir Ferdinando and his friends had been exhausting themselves upon the pomps and ceremonies of colonization John White, a Dorchester clergyman, had es- tablished a little group of " prudent and hon- est men " in a kind of missionary settlement near what is now Gloucester. Of these men Roger Conant with three others had stayed on in the face of much discouragement after their companions returned to England, finally re- moving to Naumkeag (Salem), - where Endi- cott found them when he landed early in the fall of 1628.
The rights of Endicott's men to territory in New England were obtained by purchase from Sir Ferdinando's Council of Plymouth. The name adopted by them was that of " the Massa- chusetts Company." Very wisely, however, as matters turned out, Endicott and his friends insisted that a charter be obtained from the Crown confirmatory of the grant from the
12
St. Botolph's Town
Council of Plymouth. And though they sailed before the charter passed the seals, when it did so, March 4, 1629, the rights of the colonists were defined as they never before had been, - and Charles I had placed in the hands of mere subjects powers which many a king who came after him would have given much to revoke.
Though Endicott was the " Governor of London's Plantation in the Massachusetts Bay of New England " Matthew Cradock was the governor, -i. e. the executive business head, - in the old country; and Cradock it was who, in July, 1629, submitted to his fellow-members in England certain propositions, conceived by himself, which, reinforced as they were by the charter, were destined to work a veritable revolution in the colonization of New England. Up to this time there seems to have been no thought whatever of transferring to the new land the actual government of the Company but Cradock made the startling proposal that just this should be done to the end that persons of worth and quality might deem it worth while to embark with their families for the planta- tion. There is still standing in Medford, near Boston, a house bearing the name of this gov- ernor and built for his use though he never came to occupy it. Between the suggestion
OLD HOUSE IN MEDFORD, BUILT BY GOVERNOR CRADOCK
13
As It Was in the Beginning
of Cradock's plan at Deputy Goffe's house in London, in August, 1629, and its adoption a month later every member of the Company gave deep thought to the change involved. And, gradually, they came to see in it a way of escape from persecution and oppression. Reforms in England, whether of Church or State, seemed impossible. Strafford was at the head of the army and Laud in control of the Church. Illegal taxes were being levied on all hands and it looked as if Charles were re- solved to rule the kingdom in his own stiff- necked way, disdaining the cooperation of any Parliament. Little hope indeed did the Old World offer to the liberty-loving, religious men who made up the bulk of the Puritan party!
The document by which these men finally emancipated themselves has come down to us as the Cambridge Agreement, so called because it was signed beneath the shadows and prob- ably within the very walls of that venerable university whose traditions it was destined to transplant into a new world. It bore the date, August 26, 1629; and was in the following words : -
" Upon due consideration of the state of the Plantation now in hand for New England, wherein we whose names are hereunto sub-
14
St. Botolph's Town
scribed, have engaged ourselves, and having weighed the work in regard of the consequence, God's glory and the Church's good; as also in regard of the difficulties and discouragements which in all probabilities must be forecast upon the prosecution of this business; considering withal that this whole adventure grows upon the joint confidence we have in each other's fidelity and resolution herein, so as no man of us would have adventured it without the assurance of the rest; now for the better en- couragement of ourselves and others who shall join with us in this action, and to the end that every man may without scruple dispose of his estate and affairs as may best fit his prepara- tion for this voyage; it is fully and faithfully agreed among us, and every one of us doth hereby freely and sincerely promise and bind himself, in the word of a Christian and in the presence of God, who is the searcher of all hearts, that we will so really endeavor the prosecution of this work, as by God's assist- ance we will be ready in our persons, and with such of our several families as are to go with us, and such provision as we are able conve- niently to furnish ourselves withal, to embark for the said Plantation by the first of March next, at such port or ports of this land as shall
15
As It Was in the Beginning
be agreed upon by the Company, to the end to pass the Seas (under God's protection) to in- habit and continue in New England: Provided always, that before the last of September next, the whole Government, together with the Patent for the said Plantation, be first, by an order of Court, legally transferred and estab- lished to remain with us and others which shall inhabit upon the said Plantation; and provided also, that if any shall be hindered by such just or inevitable let or other cause, to be allowed by three parts of four of these whose names are hereunto subscribed, then such persons for such times and during such lets, to be dis- charged of this bond. And we do further promise, every one for himself, that shall fail to be ready by his own default by the day ap- pointed, to pay for every day's default the sum of £3 to the use of the rest of the company who shall be ready by the same day and time.
Need help finding more records? Try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.