USA > Ohio > The biographical annals of Ohio, 1902-1903. A handbook of the government and institutions of the state of Ohio. Vol. 1 > Part 51
Note: The text from this book was generated using artificial intelligence so there may be some errors. The full pages can be found on Archive.org (link on the Part 1 page).
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16 | Part 17 | Part 18 | Part 19 | Part 20 | Part 21 | Part 22 | Part 23 | Part 24 | Part 25 | Part 26 | Part 27 | Part 28 | Part 29 | Part 30 | Part 31 | Part 32 | Part 33 | Part 34 | Part 35 | Part 36 | Part 37 | Part 38 | Part 39 | Part 40 | Part 41 | Part 42 | Part 43 | Part 44 | Part 45 | Part 46 | Part 47 | Part 48 | Part 49 | Part 50 | Part 51 | Part 52 | Part 53 | Part 54 | Part 55 | Part 56 | Part 57 | Part 58 | Part 59 | Part 60 | Part 61 | Part 62 | Part 63 | Part 64 | Part 65 | Part 66 | Part 67
(629)
JAMES L. PRICE.
James L. Price is a native of Carroll County where he was born near the village of New Hagerstown. He is the son of Benjamin and Nancy Price, who lived to a ripe old age. !
His early years were spent on the farm. After the advantages of the common schools he acquired a thorough academic education, and while preparing for the study of the law, taught one term of common school in Harrison county, near Adena, and a second term at New Hagerstown, after which his law studies were pursued in the office of Eckley & Shober at Carrollton, O. Mr. Price was admitted to the bar at Cadiz and opened an office in Carrollton, where he practiced his profession until the spring of 1865. He was elected and served one term as prosecuting attorney and at its close moved to Van Wert, a thriving county seat in the then new northwestern section of Ohio, where he formed a partnership with Judge J. D. Clark, which relation continued for about two years.
In 1868 he was elected prosecuting attorney of Van Wert county, and served three terms in succession. In the rising northwest, which was then in its transient stage, he acquired a large practice, extending into the surrounding counties. Seeing the rapid growth of Lima, its fine railroad facilities, and its promise of a great business future, Mr. Price removed to that city in the year 1883, where he has since resided.
In 1894 the Republicans of the Third Judicial circuit ventured to nominate a candidate for judge of the circuit court, and while it was then and always since strongly Democrat- ic, they succeeded in electing Judge Price by over 3900 plurality.
The six years' service on the circuit bench was a large contributing factor in his nomination for judge of the supreme court. He was elected on the Republican State Ticket in November 1901 and took his seat in the court February 9, 1902, succeeding Thad. A. Minshall, Esq., whose term expired on that day.
(630)
WILLIAM B. CREW.
Born at Chesterfield, Morgan Co., Ohio, April 1st, 1852; educated in public schools and at Westtown College, Penna. (a college under the management of the Society of Friends) ; admitted to the bar by Supreme Court of Ohio 1873; graduated from the Ohio State and Union Law College, Cleveland, Ohio, in 1874 ; elected Pros. Attorney of Morgan Co., 1876 ; Elected member of Ohio Legislature, 1889 ; Elected Judge of Court of Common Pleas for the 1st Subdiv. of the 8th judicial district of Ohio, 1891; re-elected, 1896 and again re-elected 1901; nominated for Judge of Supreme Court of Ohio by Rep. State Con- vention held at Cleveland in May, 1902; app'td by Gov. Nash July 19, 1902, to fill vacancy on Supreme Court bench caused by death of Judge Marshall J. Williams. He was elected both for the long and short terms, in November, 1902, and will complete his present term of service in February, 1909.
(631)
THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF OHIO.
MEMBERSHIP SEPTEMBER, 1902.
JACOB F. BURKET, Chief Justice.
JUDGES.
WILLIAM T. SPEAR, WILLIAM Z. DAVIS, JOHN A. SHAUCK, JAMES L. PRICE, WILLIAM B. CREW.
T HE Supreme Court of the State of, Ohio as at present consti- tuted consists of six judges who are elected for six years, the term of one judge expiring each year. This court is divided into two divisions of three judges each, the first division consisting of the Chief Justice and the third and fifth judge in the order of the expiration of their terms, and the second division consists of the remaining three.
·When the judges comprising either division divide as to the de- cision in a cause before it, the cause shall be reserved for decision by the full court; and when different causes involving the same question are before the respective divisions at the same time, such causes shall also be reserved for decision by the full court. If the whole court be divided evenly as to the decision in any cause, the judgment of the lower court shall be entered as affirmed, and such decision shall be held to be the law as to all such questions in other causes until overruled by a majority of all the judges. And when the members of the court, in any matter of original jurisdiction, divide evenly on any question or questions therein, the determination of the members with whom the chief justice votes shall be held to be the judgment of the court.
The Supreme Court and Supreme Court Law Library occupy one and a half floors of space in the new state Judiciary Building.
WEEKLY COURT CALENDAR.
For the mutual convenience of the court and of parties in suit before it, the following rule in practice is observed:
Mondays-Reserved for consultation.
Tuesdays-Reserved for decisions of the Court.
Wednesdays-Reserved for the hearing of oral arguments.
Thursdays-Reserved for hearing motions.
Fridays-Reserved for the hearing of oral arguments.
Saturdays-Reserved for consultation.
(632)
.
JUDGES OF THE TERRITORIAL COURTS OF THE NORTHWEST TERRITORY. (1787-1802.)
T T HE first judicial system to be inaugurated in that part of the United States which is now known as the State of Ohio was that put in operation by the "Ordinance of 1787" by which the "territory northwest of the River Ohio" was set apart as a separate gov- ernmental unit, and a form of local government provided for it by the Congress. By a reference to Section 4 of the ordinance, which is printed in Part One of this volume, it will be seen that it was provided that there should be "appointed a court, to consist of three judges, any two of whom to form a court, who shall have a common law jurisdiction, and reside in the district, and have therein a freehold estate, in five hundred acres of land, while in the exercise of their offices; and their commission shall continue in force during good behavior." These judges, with the governor, were to select from the civil and criminal laws of the original states such laws as they deemed suitable for the territory, and were given the power to promulgate such laws, and to enforce them, until they should be amended or repealed by a general as- sembly to be later organized according to the provisions of the ordi- nance under which they were appointed.
In accordance with this provision of the Ordinance, Congress did, on the 16th day of October, 1787, elect as judges for the Northwest Territory : Samuel Holden Parsons, John Armstrong, and James Mit- chell Varnum.
In the place of Mr. Armstrong, who declined the appointment, Congress appointed on the 19th day of February, 1788, Mr. John Cleves Symmes.
The first Territorial Judges (in 1787-8) were therefore, Samuel Holden Parsons, James Mitchell Varnum, John Cleves Symmes.
The salaries of the judges were fixed by Congress in an act bearing the date of October 8, 1787, at $800 per annum.
President George Washington, in a message to the Senate of the United States, bearing the date of New York, August 18, 1789, nom- inates to be judges of the Northwest Territory "in accordance with the law re-establishing the government of the Northwest Territory," Samuel Holden Parsons, John Cleves Symmes, and William Barton.
Mr. Barton, who was appointed vice Judge Varnum, who had died the preceding February, himself declined the appointment, and on the 8th of September the Senate completed the reorganization of the court by confirming the nomination of George Turner, an associate
(633)
634
THE BIOGRAPHICAL ANNALS OF OHIO.
Judges of the Northwest Territory.
justice. The court thus constituted in 1789, and acting under the Constitution of the United States, consisted of the Honorable Judges Samuel Holden Parsons, John Cleves Symmes, George Turner.
Judge Parsons, then Chief Justice, was drowned in November, 1789, while returning from a treaty with the Indians of the West- ern Reserve, and the President nominated as his successor on the bench, Rufus Putnam, of Marietta, whose nomination was promptly confirmed.
The court as thus organized with Judges John Cleves Symmes, George Turner, Rufus Putnam, served from 1790 to 1796, when Judge Putnam was appointed to the office of Surveyor General by President Washington, who, in the same message to the Senate, nominated Jo- seph. Gilman to the Judgeship thus made vacant. The nominations were confirmed.
In 1798 Judge Turner resigned and was succeeded by Return Jonathan Meigs, Jr., whose appointment was confirmed February 12, 1798. The court as thus constituted, consisting of Judges John Cleves Symmes, Joseph Gilman and Return J. Meigs, Jr., continued to serve until the admission of the state into the Union in 1803, and there- fore, until the organization of the Supreme Court of Ohio. This Court (of the Northwest Territory) held its session alternately at Detroit, Vincennes, Cincinnati and Marietta.
NOTE. 1 .- It is worthy of notice in this connection that the Territorial Gov- ernment was set up by Congress in October, 1787, but that the first settlement in Ohio occurred on the site of the city of Marietta in the following April (1788). In the absence of the Governor, and Judges, who were to form the law-giving power, and until their arrival, Col. Return J. Meigs, Sr., drafted a code of regu- lations on common foolscap, which he tacked to the blazed trunk of a large oak, where it was read and endorsed by all the settlers. History does not record a single infraction of those rules. The Governor, with a majority of the court, arrived at Marietta two months later, and set up the official government of the Territory.
NOTE 2 .- Upon the admission of the state into the Union in 1803, and the dissolution of the Territorial Court, Congress by an act passed in February, 1803, provided that a District Court for the District of Ohio, to consist of one judge, should be established at Chillicothe.
NOTE 3 .- By an act of May, 1800, the original Northwest Territory had been di- vided into eastern and western divisions, and an additional court created for the Indiana or western division, at Saint Vincennes, the court for the eastern division remaining at Chillicothe.
JUDGES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF OHIO UNDER THE FIRST CONSTITUTION (1802-1851.)
U NDER the Constitution of 1802 the number of Supreme Court Judges was the same as under the Territorial form of govern- ment, three, with the power vested in the general assembly to authorize the selection of an additional judge at its discretion.
The tenure of office was fixed at seven years, or such part there- of as the judge was well behaved. The salaries of the judges were fixed at not to exceed one thousand dollars per annum.
Under these provisions of the constitution and the laws, the Gen- eral Assembly elected on April 2, 1803, as the First Supreme Court of the State of Ohio, Samuel Huntington (then the Senator from Trum- bull County), Return Jonathan Meigs, Jr. (then a member of the Territorial Court), and William Spriggs (of Jefferson County).
With this establishment of a Supreme Court in Ohio, a search of official records discloses the following to have been the personnel of that court which has reflected a lasting honor on the judiciary whose representatives they were, and on the state to whom they paid affection- ate fealty.
1803-Samuel Huntington, Return Jonathan Meigs, Jr., William Spriggs.
1804-Samuel Huntington, Return Jonathan Meigs, Jr., William Spriggs.
Judge Meigs resigned December, 1804, to accept commission in the U. S. Army as Colonel and Commander of the Department of the Missouri.
1805-Samuel Huntington, Daniel Symmes (vice Meigs), William Spriggs.
1806-Samuel Huntington, Daniel Symmes, William Spriggs (to April).
Judge Sprigg resigned in April and was succeeded by Senator George Tod, of Trumbull County, who was appointed to the vacancy by Governor Tiffin-and was afterward elected to the seat by the General Assembly, January 1, 1807.
In 1807 the Supreme Court consisted of Judges Samuel Hunting- ton, Daniel Symmes and George Tod.
In 1808 Judge Symmes resigned (January 9) and was succeeded by William Spriggs (February 13). Return Jonathan Meigs, Jr., having been declared ineligible to the office of Governor of Ohio, to which he had been elected the previous October, was elected an ad-
(635)
636
THE BIOGRAPHICAL. ANNALS OF OHIO
The Judges of the Supreme Court under the First Constitution.
ditional Judge of the Supreme Court on the 13th of February by the joint session of the General Assembly which also elected his colleague, Mr. Sprigg, to succeed Judge Symmes, who had resigned to accept the presidential appointment of Registrar of Land at Cincinnati. Owing to these changes the court, after February 13, was composed of Judges Samuel Huntington, William Sprigg, George Tod, R. J. Meigs, Jr.
The membership of the court remained as above until in Decem- ber, when Judge Huntington resigned to become Governor of Ohio. He was inaugurated December 12. The House of Representatives had preferred charges early in the same month (December) against Judges Huntington and Tod, of the Supreme Court, and Judge Calvin Pease, presiding judge of the Common Pleas Court of the 3d District, for having, by certain decisions, set aside the act extending the jurisdic- tion of justices of the peace. Governor Huntington was not tried on these charges, but his associates were brought before the Senate, sit- ting as a High Court of Impeachment, and were acquitted.
In 1809, Judge Huntington having become Governor, and Judge Meigs having resigned to become United States Senator from Ohio, the Governor, in the message announcing these vacancies on the bench (January 31) recommends the abolishment of the fourth judgeship for the reason that it creates two courts of two judges each, which sitting at different parts of the state in riding the circuit, tend to disagree- ment in decisions, and consequent confusion. Despite this recommen- dation of the Governor, the Legislature elected (February 17) Thomas Scott (Chief Clerk of the Senate) to succeed Judge Huntington, and Thomas Morris (a member of the House of Representatives) to suc- ceed Judge Meigs as an additional Judge. This created a court of four members, including Judges William Sprigg, George Tod, Thomas Scott and Thomas Morris.
Judge Morris failing to qualify as judge, the General Assembly abolished the additional judgeship the following session (1810).
In 1810, the first period of seven years having expired under the state constitution of 1802, the General Assembly, on February 10, - met in joint session of the two houses and elected a new Supreme Court which served without interruption until 1815. This court con- sisted of Thomas Scott (to succeed himself) ; William W. Irwin, of Fairfield County ; and Ethan Allen Brown, of Hamilton County.
In 1816 the General Assembly was called upon to elect succes- sors to Judges Scott and Irwin who had resigned, and accordingly met in joint session on the 17th day of February, and elected to the Su- preme Court, Messrs. Jessup N. Couch, of Ross County; John Mc-
1
THE BIOGRAPHICAL ANNALS OF OHIO.
637
The Judges of the Supreme Court under the First Constitution.
Lean of Warren County; and an additional judge in Calvin Pease, of Trumbull County.
The Supreme Court was thus increased to four members: Ethan Allen Brown, Jessup N. Couch, John McLean, and Calvin Pease.
In 1817 the re-election of Judge Brown to succeed himself con- tinued the membership of the court as constituted the previous year, and this membership was unbroken until the resignation of Judge Brown in December 1818, to become Governor of Ohio. On the 30th day of January, 1819, the General Assembly elected Peter Hitchcock, of Geauga County, to the vacancy thus created.
From 1819 to 1821 the judges of the Supreme Court were : Jessup N. Couch, John McLean, Calvin Pease and Peter Hitchcock.
In 1821, the death of Judge Couch led to the election of Jacob Burnett, of Hamilton County, one of the conspicuous figures in the Territorial Council and in the early history of Ohio, as his successor. The court thus constituted, being again changed in 1822 by the resig- nation of Judge McLean, Charles R. Sherman, of Fairfield County, was elected to succeed him on the 11th day of January, 1823, at which election the General Assembly also re-elected Judges Pease and Bur- nett.
From 1822 to 1829 the Judges of the Supreme Court were: Cal- vin Pease, Peter Hitchcock, Jacob Burnett and Charles R. Sherman.
In 1828 Judge Burnett resigned (December 11) and as his suc- cessor the General Assembly elected (February 6, 1829) Joshua Col- lett, of Warren County. The judges for 1829 being Calvin Pease, Peter Hitchcock, Charles R. Sherman, and Joshua Collett.
In 1830 the General Assembly elected the following judges of the Supreme Court : January 30, Elijah Hayward, vice Judge Pease, term expired ; February 1, John Milton Goodenow, vice Judge Sherman, deceased; the court thus consisting of Judges Peter Hitchcock, Joshua Collett, Elijah Hayward and John Milton Goodenow.
During the summer of 1830 the court was divided into two sec- tions, sitting in separate localities in the state (under an act of the previous winter), but the illness of Judges Goodenow and Hayward, who finally resigned before the close of the year, deprived the Miami River counties and those of central Ohio of the usual court. An at- tempt to hold a special session in Columbus, in October, resulted in the coming together of but two of the judges, who, deciding that they were not a quorum of the court and could neither sit as a court or legally adjourn, agreed to "separate," which they did, and nothing was done with the fifty cases on the docket. (See Governor's Message. ) Henry Brush was appointed by the Governor during the year 1830 to suc-
638
THE BIOGRAPHICAL ANNALS OF OHIO.
The Judges of the Supreme Court under the First Constitution.
ceed Judge Goodenow, resigned; no appointment being made to fill the vacancy occasioned by the resignation (November 6) of Judge Hayward.
In December, 1830, the Supreme Court Judges were: Peter Hitchcock, Joshua Collett, Henry Brush, and one vacancy caused by the resignation of Judge Hayward.
On the 18th of December the General Assembly elected a suc- cessor to Judge Hayward in the person of Ebenezer Lane, of Huron County, and on the 29th of the month elected John C. Wright, of Jef- ferson County, to succeed Judge Brush, who was not a candidate be- fore the General Assembly. Judge Lane took his seat at once; Judge Wright, on the adjournment of the legislature.
In 1831 and 1832 the membership of the Supreme Court re- mained : Peter Hitchcock, Joshua Collett, Ebenezer Lane, and John C. Wright.
Judge Hitchcock's term expiring on the 5th of February, 1833, there was a spirited contest in the General Assembly over the election of his successor. The election being ordered for the 16th of Decem- ber (1832), on that day the assembly met in joint session, but after casting seven ballots, on all of which Reuben Wood, of Cuyahoga Coun- ty, led, with Judge Hitchcock second and Benjamin Tappan third, the session dissolved without an election and the Senate returned to its chamber. The assembly was called together by another resolution on the next day (17th), and after twelve more ballots, Reuben Wood was declared to have been elected by a majority of one vote.
Several days later the correctness of the court was challenged by a joint resolution and an investigation of the count was ordered, but the title of Judge Wood to his seat was not disturbed by this agitation.
The court for 1833-1835, was composed of Judges Joshua Collett, Ebenezer Lane, John C. Wright and Reuben Wood.
On February 2, 1835, the Governor reported the resignation of Judge Wright, and on the 28th day of that month, the General As- sembly elected, on the fourth ballot, Ex-Judge Hitchcock, at that time Senator from Geauga County and Speaker of the Senate, to succeed him. In this contest, Senator Anthony, of Clarke County, was Judge Hitchcock's principal competitor for the Judgeship and was (March 6) elected to succeed him as Speaker of the Senate. Judge Hitch- cock resigned as Speaker on that day.
From March, 1835, to February 10, 1836, the court consisted of Judges Lane, Wright, Wood and Hitchcock.
Frederick Grimke, of Ross County, was elected on January 30, 1836, to succeed Judge Collett, whose term expired on the 10th of
639
THE BIOGRAPHICAL ANNALS OF OHIO.
The Judges of the Supreme Court under the First Constitution.
February. By the re-election of Judge Lane for the period of seven years from the 18th day of December, 1837, and of Judge Wood, in 1839, the court as constituted in 1836 continued without interruption until 1842, viz .: Ebenezer Lane, Reuben Wood, Peter Hitchcock, and Frederick Grimke.
Matthew Birchard, of Trumbull County, was elected by the Gen- eral Assembly on January 15, 1842, to succeed Judge Hitchcock, whose . term expired in February of that year, and Nathaniel C. Reed, of Hamilton County, was elected on the 5th of March, to succeed Judge Grimke, resigned. The court thus constituted, from March, 1842, to December, 1844, was composed of Judges Ebenezer Lane, Reuben Wood, Matthew Birchard, and Nathaniel C. Reed.
In December, 1844, the term of Judge Lane expired. He was promptly re-elected by the General Assembly on the 5th of the month, but remained on the bench only during the session of the court in Bank, when he resigned. His successor was elected on the 27th of the same month (December), in the person of Ex-Judge Peter Hitch- cock. The action of the General Assembly in re-electing Judge Lane to succeed himself in 1836 and 1844 was, with the exception of the re-election of Judge Wood, in 1839, contrary to the usual refusal of the assembly to grant consecutive terms to the members of the Supreme Court.
The members of the Supreme Court in the years 1845 and 1846 were Judges Reuben Wood, Matthew Birchard, Nathaniel C. Reed, and Peter Hitchcock.
On the 15th day of January, 1847, the General Assembly elected Edward Avery, of Wayne County, to succeed Judge Wood (term ex- piring), although the Judge was a candidate for re-election. From February, 1847, to February, 1849, the membership of the court was: Judges Matthew Birchard, Nathaniel C. Reed, Peter Hitchcock, and Edward Avery.
On the 22d day of February, 1849, the General Assembly elected as members of the Supreme Court: Rufus P. Spalding, of Summit County, for seven years from March 5, to succeed Judge Reed, re- signed; and William B. Caldwell, of Hamilton County, for seven years from March 7, to succeed Judge Birchard, term expired.
The court for 1849-1850, consisted of Judges Hitchcock, Avery, Spalding, and Caldwell.
The last change in the court prior to the enforcement of the pres- ent constitution of Ohio was occasioned by the resignation of Judge Avery, and the election of his successor in the person of Rufus P. Ran- ney, of Trumbull County, on the 17th of March, 1851. The court
610
THE BIOGRAPHICAL ANNALS OF OHIO.
The Judges of the Supreme Court under the First Constitution.
served as thus constituted until "the second Monday in February, 1852," when the official term of the new officers elected under the con- stitution began. The membership of the court from February, 1851, to February, 1852, was Judges Hitchcock, Spalding, Caldwell, and Ranney.
JUDGES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO UNDER THE CONSTITUTION OF 1851.
T HE constitution of 1851 contains the following provision for the continuance of the authority of the Supreme Court:
SEC. 11. Schedule. Suits pending in the Supreme Court in bank shall be transferred to the Supreme Court provided for in this Constitution, and be pro- ceeded in according to law.
Under this constitution the personnel of the Supreme Court of Ohio has been, consecutively, as given, for the years named hereunder.
1852. On the 9th day of February, 1852, the then Supreme Court, which had been elected by the General Assembly under the old constitution, and consisting of Judges Peter Hitchcock, Rufus P. Spald- ing, William B. Caldwell, and Rufus P. Ranney, passed out of exist- ence, and a new court, elected by the people of Ohio at the previous election in October, came on the bench in the persons of Judges Wil- liam B. Caldwell, of Hamilton County (re-elected) ; Rufus P. Ran- ney, of Trumbull County (re-elected) ; Thomas W. Bartley, of Rich- land County ; John A. Corwin, of Champaign County; and Allen G. Thurman, of Ross County.
On the organization of the court, the judges drew lots for the length of their terms, the lot resulting: For one year, Judge Caldwell ; for two years, Judge Bartley ; for three years, Judge Corwin; for four years, Judge Thurman ; and for five years (the length of the regular term under the new constitution), Judge Ranney. Judge Caldwell was re-elected in 1852, and Judge Bartley was re-elected in 1853, so the court remained as installed in February, 1852, until December, 1854, with the following membership: Judges Caldwell, Ranney, Bart- ley, Corwin, and Thurman.
1854-1855. Judge Corwin resigned in December, 1854, and was succeeded by Robert B. Warden, of Franklin County, who was ap- pointed to the vacancy and served until February 9, 1855, when he was succeeded by Joseph R. Swan, of Franklin County, who was elect- ed to the seat.
Need help finding more records? Try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.