USA > Pennsylvania > Erie County > The history of Erie County, Pennsylvania, from its first settlement > Part 23
Note: The text from this book was generated using artificial intelligence so there may be some errors. The full pages can be found on Archive.org (link on the Part 1 page).
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16 | Part 17 | Part 18 | Part 19 | Part 20 | Part 21 | Part 22 | Part 23 | Part 24 | Part 25 | Part 26 | Part 27 | Part 28 | Part 29 | Part 30 | Part 31 | Part 32 | Part 33 | Part 34 | Part 35 | Part 36 | Part 37 | Part 38 | Part 39 | Part 40
It was required of the State Geologist, from the first, to furnish specimens of all mineral products to the Secretary of the Commonwealth, and also of the minerals of each county to its respective commissioners (those for the counties seemed to be waved). In 1842 the Legislature required the preparation of three cabinets of all geological and mineral specimens for the use of the State, to be severally deposited at Harrisburg, Philadelphia, and Pittsburg. We have been informed that Mr. Rogers also made a promise of a similar one for Erie, to Mr. J. D. Dunlap ; but that it was not added to the list, lest some might consider it favoritism. Such a cabinet might
257
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
awaken in our county an interest in geology, which would manifest itself in the more general pursuit of that engaging science, as well as in the more profitable management of farms, and the opening up of its resources and mineral wealth.
According to Prof. Rogers, the northwest corner of the State, embracing Erie County, a large part of Crawford, and the north half of Warren, which he makes his seventh dis- trict, a mean breadth of forty miles, is much the simplest of all the natural divisions of the geological surface of Pennsyl- vania, as to its variety of strata and their structural features. It includes but two paleozoic formations, namely, the vergent flags1 and vergent shales. 2 These strata (the most ancient or lowest great division of the fossiliferous strata) retain very nearly the horizontal position in which they were originally deposited, sustaining but a trivial inclination toward the southeast, which extends to the coal strata and gives them their trough-like configuration. The surface descends rather rapidly from the watershed to the lake by a succession of ob- scure, alternately gentle and steepish slopes. The declivation of the ground may be inferred from the difference in the ele- vation of its two margins : that of the watershed, in which it begins, being nearly twelve hundred feet, and that of the lake, in which it ends, being only five hundred and sixty-five feet above the level of the sea. This tract is cut transversely by numerous sharp ravines and long tortuous valleys (evi- dently carved by a tremendous rush of waters), carrying its streams to the lake ; and the borders of some of these afford many small, pleasing bits of scenery. But the characteristic, and altogether the most impressive pictures, are those of the lake itself. The first view which the traveler gets of this broad inland sea, as he passes the watershed, especially when the surface of the lake, crisped into gentle waves by a light western breeze, reflects the deep blue of the upper sky, never fails to charm and surprise him.
1 Vergent flags .- A rather fine-grained gray sandstone in thin layers, parted by their alternating bands of shale. It abounds in marine vegeta- tion.
2 Vergent shales .- A thick mass of gray, blue, and olive-colored shales and gray-brown sandstone. The sandstone predominates in the upper part, where the shales contain many fossils.
258 1
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
This inclined plane extends from Cattaraugus County, New York, to Sandusky Bay, being a slope consisting rather of a succession of low terraces, themselves a little inclined. These terraces are made hy the outcropping of the strata, and are parallel with the lake shore. The average inclination of the surface is about thirty-three feet to a mile ; from eight or ten miles from the lake the downward sweep of the surface is much more rapid.
This Lake Erie slope is hounded on the southeast border hy an abrupt, low, broken wall or escarpment, which constitutes the verge of the bituminous coal region. Between the Clarion and Tionesta, and also extending across the river southwest toward Mercer and Beaver, it rises gradually toward the northwest.
The rise of the Allegheny River, from Pittshurg to Franklin, does not exceed 755 feet, and the rise of French Creek, from its mouth to Meadville, is about 130 feet. The high dividing ridge which separates the waters of the Allegheny tributaries from Lake Erie crosses the New York State line near Colt's Station, where it is about 1,000 feet above the surface of the lake. It then passes in a straight line to Strong's on the turn- pike, ten miles from Erie, where it is from 850 to 875 feet above the lake level. From Strong's south westward it hecomes less distinctly marked and much depressed, and is altogether lost previous to reaching Conneaut Creek. The summit of the Erie Extension Canal is at Conneaut Lake, and is little more than 500 feet ahove Lake Erie.
From this dividing ridge there are four tolerahly well- marked terraces to, and parallel with, the lake. These terraces are higher and better defined near the New York State line, and become much depressed on reaching Elk Creek and Fair- view townships, with the exception of the lower one, which extends into the State of Ohio. The streams which empty into the lake frequently run within one of these terraces for a con- siderable distance before they find an opening through which they can pass to a lower level-thus, Walnut, Elk, and Con- neaut Crecks head very far to the east of their respective final outlets.
Between Cattaraugus Creek and Sandusky Bay the whole
-
259
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
lake coast displays only the upper or sandstone member of the flag formation, called in the New York Geological Survey the portage sandstones. This group of strata crossing Erie County in a southwest direction, almost precisely parallel with the bend of the lake coast, constitutes a belt ten or twelve miles in width, its upper limit pursuing the general watershed of the district. All the rocks between this line and the margin of the coal field are referable to the vergent shales.
The vergent flag or sandstone formation, in the type which the group wears upon Lake Erie, would not be recognized in its lithological composition by those who are only familiar with it in the Appalachian valleys. In the eastern and cen- tral tracts of . New York the whole formation is far more arenaceous, and the proportion of the sandstone layers to the shales, or more purely argillaceous beds, is much greater, the upper or terminal subdivision of the mass especially contain- ing, with a large amount of thin bedded or flagy sandstone, a considerable body of more massive strata, But advancing west the clayey element predominates, and in the belt of country bordering on Lake Erie but comparatively little true sandstone remains in the mass. The most arenaceous portion of the formation is even here near the top, and where well ex- posed, as it is in several places about eight miles south of the lake, where it is occasionally quarried, it may be recognized by its marine vegetation, and especially by a vertical stem- like form or species of scolithus.
The vergent shales also on Lake Erie are more argillaceous, and the two formations approximate so nearly in composition, and even in their organic remains, that a separation is not practicable.
The whole vergent mass between the lake and the coal rock is 1,900 feet thick, about 800 or 900 feet representing the thick- ness of the lower formation, and 1,000 or 1,100 the overlying vergent shales. The quarries near the road between Water- ford and Erie, at an elevation of 800 feet above the lake, in- dicate nearly the highest portion of the inferior group, It would appear from the researches of Prof. James Hall, that the total thickness of the vergent flag formation or portage group of New York, amounts, in the longitude of Chautauqua
260
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
Creek, to nearly 1,400 feet ; we are therefore to infer that in the region of Lake Erie some 500 or 600 feet of the formation are covered by its waters.
Ripple marks, so abundant in the vergent flags, are numer- ous in Erie and Crawford Counties. Concretions of various shapes abound in the more calcareous varieties of the finer- grained clay shales, particularly those of the lower or flag group. The commonest forms are spheroids, generally much flattened, and often curiously lobed by the addition of fresh materials on one or more sides. When very calcareous, these are seamed with little veins of carbonate of lime, filling cracks in more central portions-they are, in other words, true septaria.
Among the concretionary structures is one 1 which, from its singularity, and the doubts entertained by many in relation to its mode of origin, deserves a more special mention. It is the so-called " Cone-in-Cone " structure of the English geologist. In England it is met with occasionally in the finer shales and clay ironstones of the coal measures ; but in one vast series of formations it is nowhere seen but in this particular horizon, near the vergent flag formation. It usually occurs in flat cakes of hardened calcareous shale imbedded in soft, mealy shale, the conical structure occupying a thickness of one or two inches on one surface of the cake. Its position in the strata is near the lake shore, and perhaps the best localities for it in Erie County are at the mouth of Sixteen Mile Creek, and at the Cascade near Erie ; but it is to be seen in a correspond- ing situation bordering on the lake at a great number of spots throughout the entire length of the formation, from Chautau- qua Creek in New York, to Cleveland in Ohio, and Prof. Hall speaks of it as abundant on the Genesee River.
A minute inspection of the strata, as disclosed on the lake shore and in the ravines, shows the first two hundred feet to consist of blue and olive-colored soft, calcareous clay-shales, brown bituminous shale and slate, and their alternating layers of fine-grained gray calcareo-argillaceous sandstone. All
1 This structure was first observed by Dr. Samuel L. Mitchell, a distin- guished geologist of New York, in 1827, and regarded by him with very great interest. His specimens were labeled "Argillaceous Schist of a peculiar conchoidal fracture."
261
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
these materials are in their beds, and in constant alternation, their dimensions being from one fourth of an inch to twelve inches. The carbonaceous shales and slates are the thinnest. Some of the finer-grained shales extend with little change of thickness over very considerable areas, while other beds change their dimensions rapidly. The shales, but more especially the sandstones, are slightly calcareous.
The level line of the shore enables us to detect, in the dip of the strata, a slight lateral or northeast and southwest undula- tion-but this feature is only local and inconspicuous. At the mouth of Elk Creek, and elsewhere, the strata exhibit even a very gentle dip toward the northwest ; and when examined, this feature is connected with a low anticlinal arching of the rocks, the axis of elevation being near the bridge, half a mile above the outlet of the stream, not far from Girard. If it were practicable thus to refer all the inclinations of the strata to a succession of horizons absolutely level, we should discover a vast succession of very low but broad and obscure anticlinals, conforming in their northeast and southwest trend to the flex- ures of the Appalachian chain, and indicating the last expir- ing swells in the crust transmitted with abating intensity across the broad bituminous coal region, from the enormous billows which lifted the Appalachian chain.
Organic remains are rare in the strata near the side of the lake, but one slender layer, about three inches in thickness, occurring on the shore near the borough of Northeast, con- tains the little Avicula speciosa and Ungulina suborbicularia, the most abundant fossils of the formation. In other places the faces of the slabs of slate, especially when in contact with bituminous shale, are sometimes covered with fragments of plants, chiefly a delicate species of fucoid.
Eight or ten miles back from the lake the terrace outcrops consist of thinly-laminated olive and brownish shales, alter- nating with flagy layers of sandstone. These latter become gradually more abundant as we ascend in the series. The thickest arenaceous beds measure in some places twelve or fifteen inches, and where a number of them occur together, with only thin partings of shale, the mass is quarried as a building material.
262
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
A stratum of this kind appears about midway between Erie and Waterford, and has been quarried in an excavation known as Vincent's, about one mile west of the turnpike, the materials from it being used in the locks of the Erie extension of the Pennsylvania Canal. Near Elk Crcek, at Elisha Smith's, east of Girard, and at Cranes' near Cranes' Mills, are the most extensive quarries of similar masses. It is seldom possible to trace a particular stratum of the sandstone for any considerable distance, for the beds soon thin off or deteriorate for economical uses, becoming too argillaceous. At an ele- vation of about 810 feet above the level of the lake there ap- pear, in the vicinity of Waterford, two or three thin layers of calcareous sandstone, abounding in marine organic remains, chiefly bivalve shells. These strata, easily recognized by the profusion of their imbedded fossils, are to be seen at White- man's, and also at Wilcox's, near the village, as likewise along the streams at the head waters of Le Boeuf and Elk Creeks- one locality being near the house of Martin Strong. The species are characteristic of the vergent newer shales, the Che- mung group of New York.
Upon these fossiliferous beds rest several bands of sandstone, the layers being from six to twelve inches thick. These have been quarried for building-stone, but. approaching Waterford they deteriorate. East of the village occurs a stratum of yellow sandstone, coarser than the beds of the for- mation generally, and differing from them in aspect. It has been quarried on the borders of French Creek, where a good building material was obtained. At Smith's quarry the bed was about four feet thick. Upon it rest, first, thin bands of pebbly rock, the pebbles having the size of large shot ; sec- ondly, shale ; thirdly, two layers of hard silicious sandstone, sixteen inches thick, and above them slate and flaggy sand- stone. A similar section may be seen on the opposite side of the stream at A. Middleton's.
In the Moravian quarry (near Waterford) the sandstone bed is not so thick. At Carrol's quarry it is from four to six feet in thickness, some thin layers of pebbly rock or coarse grit, and other sandstone resting over it, separated by only a few inches of shale. All these beds are embraced within a thick-
263
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
ness of ten or twelve feet. A little petroleum is found in all of these quarries. We have already seen that many of the clay shales are highly bituminous.
The greater part of the surface of the northwest district is thinly strewed with Northern drift, and the valleys of all the principal streams are deeply filled with it, presenting some very instructive features in the forms of many bold terraces into which the waters have brought it.
Character of the Soil .- The cadent and vergent rocks, of which this northwest district consists, furnish by disintegra- tion a soil in which clay is the predominating ingredient. It may be denominated a cold, clayey loam, better suited for grazing than for growing wheat. That derived from the in- ferior, more argillaceous strata nearer the lake, is in many belts a stiff clay, while that into which the sandy matter of the upper parts of the formation enters as an element is looser, and approximates to the character of a loam. A greater or less mixture of the materials of the Northern drift or trans- ported gravel, with the proper soil of the region, modifies the quality of the latter, and gives to many localities agricultural peculiarities which the subsequent rocks themselves could never impart. In nearly all the larger valleys the depth of the drift is such as to confer on them a soil abounding in gravel. Though this very heterogeneous covering contains pebbles and sand derived from the limestones which outcrop to the north and east of Lake Erie, mingled with the less fer- tile materials of the crystalline and silicious rocks yet farther north, and with the fragments of the underlying shales, a soil exists usually well adapted to the culture of wheat and the finer kinds of grain,
The soil derived from the cadent and vergent rocks alone is too generally deficient in calcareous matter to possess a high degree of fertility, and, unfortunately for the domestic agri- cultural resources of the district, not a single bed or forma- tion of good limestone either within it or cheaply contiguous to it, contributes to the land the element which it chiefly needs. As, however, much good agricultural lime is procurable from the immediate coast of the lake toward its west end, there cannot be a doubt that ultimately commerce, in her inexhaus-
264
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
tible power to benefit, will be enlisted to convey the requisite quantity of this almost indispensable fertilizer not only to the coast of Erie County, but by the canals, to all the contiguous regions toward the southeast.
Calcareous Marl .- In the Pymatuning and Conneaut swamps there are shallow but rather extensive deposits of a soft calcareous tufa and shell-marl, the possible value of which to the agriculture of the surrounding districts is not enough appreciated. This is in Crawford County. Thus far we have cited the State geologist.
In Erie County, at Beaverdam, west of Union, thirty years ago, marl was burned for lime ; and at Walnut Creek, quite recently, lime of the best quality was manufactured. At the Sink-hole, in Waterford, we have reason to suppose the quan- tity of shell-marl inexhaustible. 1 Many cords of hard blue limestone were quarried in excavating the canal in Erie. The very superior quality of the wheat produced in the vicinity of the lake confirms Prof. Roger's statement, that lime exists in the sand and pebbles. It is sometimes too, observed in bricks, in their disruption when the lime slackens.
For several years the blast furnace of Vincent, Himrod & Co. was stocked principally with Erie County bog ore. 2 It was brought from Laird's farm, Nicholson's, Elk Creek, etc., in the western part of the county. Near Cranesville there is a bed which is burned and used as a mineral paint. The ore yielded fron fifteen to twenty, and sometimes even sixty per cent of iron-some was found to be one-fifth limestone. At the time the furnace discontinued operations, the supply of ore was supposed to be exhausted.
Coal in small quantities has been found, and also sulphate of alumina compounded with the sulphate of iron, from which
1 Prof. Austin, of the Waterford Academy, put the marl to the test, and found it to be composed principally of lime; and adds, "the time will come when it will be extensively used as a fertilizer, and it can be burned so as to form lime-but the lime will not be as good as if Obtained from some other source."
2 As a proof of the quality of the metal, we find in the Erie Gazette, 1813: " An inspection of 1200 32-pound shot was made by the navy agent, at the Presqu'ile Foundery, from Erie County ore, and a contract was finished with government for 300 8-inch shot and 7,000 32-pounders, part of which were shipped for Buffalo and Sackett's Harbor."
Many years ago considerable quantities were shipped at Massassaqué for a small furnace in Conneaut, Ohio.
265
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
the alum of commerce is derived. Salt springs have been dis- covered in various places, but probably not of sufficient strength to justify the erection of works for the manufacture of salt.
Petroleum .- Boring for oil has been prosecuted in different parts, as yet not with any marked success. The well of C. McSparren, in the southeastern part of the town, reached the depth of 200 feet, mostly through rock. An abundance of gas was found, but the work has ceased for the present. In Sum- mit township, Mr. C. Fronce bored a well on a branch of Le Bœuf Creek to the depth of 200 feet without finding oil in pay- ing quantities. Afterward, near Strong's Mill, at a depth of 157 feet, a vein which it was thought would yield ten barrels per day was found. P. G. Stranahan drilled 200 feet in Union ; and on Sturgeon's farm, at Fairplains, 100 feet through a stratum of coal four feet in thickness. Near the Springfield Depot, on the Cleveland and Erie Road, boring has been com- menced. Nearly a dozen companies are now prosecuting the business in Conneaut township, on the banks of Marsh Run. Oil was found in that region twenty years ago, and collected for medicinal purposes, and in quarrying stone the workmen found it in small pools among the rocks. An old salt well which had been opened forty years ago, in Wellsburg, having become filled with rubbish, was cleaned, and jets of oil were thrown at three different times. This is on the east branch of Conneaut Creek. A company with a cash capital of $1,000 was formed in February, 1861, at Waterford, to drill in that neighborhood, and in Erie one hundred Germans formed an association with a capital of $10,000, and immediately com- menced operations on Ninth Street.
The Germans carried on this work and drilled four hundred feet. On February 26, 1862, they struck a vein of gas which threw the water twenty feet into the air. About 9:30 the proprietor, Mr. Athof, and eight others visited the well to examine, carrying a lighted lantern. When they were within a few feet of the derrick, the gas took fire, and the whole party were more or less injured and one survived but a few hours.
Several mineral springs have been discovered-a burning
266
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
sulphur spring on the farm of Mr. Knox, south of the town, at one time claimed attention and excited much curiosity. Another burning spring is found on the Ohlwiler farm, on Six Mile Creek. A mineral spring on the ground formerly owned by P. P. Glazier, on Eighth Street, was, in 1840, im- proved and fitted up with baths for the benefit of invalids.
A specimen of the water was sent for analysis to Prof. Booth, of Philadelphia. His experiments on one gallon of 60,000 grains resulted as follows :-
Chloride of potassium 20.56
Carbonate of lime. 19.12
sodium 110.16
16
magnesia 0.96
magnesium. 45.36
iron
1.44
..
calcium. 8.88
iron 2.88
11.68
Total insoluble
22.00
Total soluble matter.
199.52
Silica 0.48
Sulphate of lime.
Prof. Booth explains insoluble matter to mean " the residue, which will not redissolve in pure water after evaporation to dryness. The carbonates in the insoluble portion are held in solution in the spring water by a small quantity of carbonic acid which escapes during the evaporation."
He adds : "It appears from the analysis that the spring water is of excellent quality and bears comparison with many European springs which have attained some celebrity." The waters have been successfully tried by invalids ; but the prem- ises are now out of repair, and the water not to be obtained in its purity and strength.
The unforseen and repeated sinking of the Philadelphia and Erie track, at Le Boeuf swamp, near Waterford, attracted much attention during the construction of that road, and elicited the following statement in substance from Mr. R. Andrews, one of the engineers. When the location was made, the surface, excepting in a few places, appeared firm and hard. Le Bœuf swamp, in which the sinking occurred, is between two large mounds designated as the north and south mounds, as they lie in that course with the railroad. The level is about four feet higher than Le Bœuf Creek. The surface soil is mostly made up of vegetable mould, varying from three to seven feet in thickness, for the distance of 38,000 feet. The line of the railroad is perfectly straight through
267
HISTORY OF ERIE COUNTY.
this swamp, and the height of the bank above it averages five feet.
The grading of the railroad was begun in 1856, at both ends, and after making 100 feet of the bank near the south mound it first showed symptoms of settling, and went from bad to worse as the bank receded from the mound. At the north end better progress was made, and there were no indications that any settling would take place. When the work on the road was stopped, in 1857, 1,000 feet were made on the north end, and 175 on the south.
In 1858 the work was resumed, but little progress was made until January, 1859, when the efficient and energetic con- tractors, Russel, Barnet & Co., took charge. Soundings were made under the direction of the engineer through the swamp, the length of which, by previous advancement, was reduced to 2,600 feet. At the south mound no bottom could be found for a distance of 300 feet-an iron rod having been made thirty- five feet in length for the purpose. The soundings for the re- maining 1,300 feet averaged from 1 to 25 feet, striking a good gravel bottom. The penetration of the rod in most places through the crust was somewhat hard ; but when through, it passed readily to the gravel.
Need help finding more records? Try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.