USA > Pennsylvania > Luzerne County > Wilkes-Barre > A history of Wilkes-Barre, Luzerne County, Pennsylvania : from its first beginnings to the present time, including chapters of newly-discovered early Wyoming Valley history, together with many biographical sketches and much genealogical material. Volume II > Part 37
Note: The text from this book was generated using artificial intelligence so there may be some errors. The full pages can be found on Archive.org (link on the Part 1 page).
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11 | Part 12 | Part 13 | Part 14 | Part 15 | Part 16 | Part 17 | Part 18 | Part 19 | Part 20 | Part 21 | Part 22 | Part 23 | Part 24 | Part 25 | Part 26 | Part 27 | Part 28 | Part 29 | Part 30 | Part 31 | Part 32 | Part 33 | Part 34 | Part 35 | Part 36 | Part 37 | Part 38 | Part 39 | Part 40 | Part 41 | Part 42 | Part 43 | Part 44 | Part 45 | Part 46 | Part 47 | Part 48 | Part 49 | Part 50 | Part 51 | Part 52 | Part 53 | Part 54 | Part 55 | Part 56 | Part 57 | Part 58 | Part 59 | Part 60 | Part 61 | Part 62 | Part 63 | Part 64 | Part 65 | Part 66 | Part 67 | Part 68 | Part 69 | Part 70 | Part 71 | Part 72 | Part 73 | Part 74 | Part 75 | Part 76 | Part 77 | Part 78 | Part 79 | Part 80 | Part 81 | Part 82 | Part 83 | Part 84 | Part 85 | Part 86 | Part 87 | Part 88 | Part 89 | Part 90 | Part 91 | Part 92 | Part 93 | Part 94 | Part 95 | Part 96 | Part 97 | Part 98 | Part 99 | Part 100 | Part 101 | Part 102 | Part 103 | Part 104 | Part 105 | Part 106 | Part 107 | Part 108 | Part 109 | Part 110 | Part 111 | Part 112 | Part 113 | Part 114 | Part 115 | Part 116 | Part 117 | Part 118
Jared Ingersoll, Jr., was married in December, 1781, to Elizabeth Pettit of Philadelphia, who bore him four sons, three of whom survived him. The eldest of these three was Charles Jared Ingersoll. He was an earnest supporter of the War of 1812, and was one of the strongest advocates of American rights upon this continent. He was a Member of Congress from 1813 to 1815, and from 1841 till 1849. In 1815 he was appointed United States Attorney for the District of Pennsylvania. He was the historian of the War of 1812, and the author of numerous pamphlets, among which was the celebrated " Inchiquin The Jesuit's Letters."
Joseph R. Ingersoll, the third son of Jared Ingersoll. Jr., attained high rank in the legal profession, and for a considerable number of years served as a Member of the United States House of Representa- tives. In 1852 he was appointed Minister to England.
*Mentioned on page 770 ante.
800
"There are certain people at this time who, if a word is said against dear Susque- hanna, behave as if they thought an open attack was made upon their honor and their property, and impute all that is said to the worst motives. They can charge nothing of the kind upon me but what I may just as well charge upon them; with this difference, however, that they have confessedly a personal interest in the matter, while I have none. * * Shame on those, then, who, under feigned names in newspapers, attack those who venture to oppose them-not with arguments (this would be fair and right)-but witlı abuse, and even with intimidation. They do not consider that it is equally in the power of others to trace the conduct of the principal leaders and managers among The Susque- hanna Company through all their negotiations for twenty years past; and with the help of a few groundless reports, ill-natured hints and wicked inuendoes, to explain their motives, their views and their conduct in a manner that would do them little honour. But I will not myself so far forget the rights of humanity as to follow the vile example."
The action taken by the Connecticut Assembly, the letter of Jared Ingersoll, that of the writer whose pseudonym was "Many," and various comments which were printed in the newspapers, relating to the lands west of the Delaware, produced considerable tumult and faction in the Colony. The Susquehanna Company had its opposers from the start, and they, as well as many other citizens who previously had taken no particular interest in the matter, now asserted that the claim of the Colony was unfounded. These malcontents readily adopted the sug- gestion of "Many " (see page 792), that a convention of delegates from the various towns of the Colony should be held at Middletown "to consult on measures to be pursued to evade the evils" which were apprehended. At the written request of more than 200 citizens of New Haven the Selectmen of that town ordered a town-meeting to be held at the State House in New Haven March 10, 1774. Upon that day the number of the inhabitants who assembled was so great that, owing to the smallness of the State House, the meeting was adjourned to the Brick Meeting-house. By "a very great majority" it was then and there voted, " that it is the opinion of this town that this Colony's ex- tending their jurisdiction over those lands west of New York, on the Susquehanna River-and challenged by Mr. Penn-without first pros- ecuting their claim before His Majesty in Council, will be tedious, expensive, and of dangerous tendency." The meeting then appointed a committee to represent New Haven at the convention at Middletown. The following account of a town-meeting held at Fairfield, Connecticut, March 14, 1774, is taken from the Pennsylvania Packet of April 4, 1774.
"At a legal town-meeting held this day in this town, the question relating to the Colony's claim to the western lands, called Susquehanna, and the dangerous consequences that it is feared will follow from the Colony's undertaking to assert their claim thereto, and exercise jurisdiction and government there, as lately resolved, were considered, when G. S. Silliman* and Jonathan Sturgest were chosen a committee to repair to Mid- dletown on the last Wednesday in this month, to meet and confer with the committees from the other towns in this Colony as to what measures it may be most prudent to adopt, to prevent those dangerous consequences. * * The meeting was the fullest that hath almost ever been known in this town on any occasion."
Stratford, and other towns in the central and south-western parts of Connecticut, held meetings similar to those held at New Haven and Fairfield, and on Wednesday, March 30, 1774, delegates from twenty- three Connecticut towns met in convention at Middletown. Upon the adjournment of this convention a full report of its proceedings, includ- ing a petition addressed to the General Assembly, was printed in the shape of a broadside, copies of which were freely disseminated through- out the Colony. An original copy is now in the possession of Mr. James
* GOLD SELLECK SILLIMAN, a graduate of Yale College in the class of 1752. He died in 1790.
+ A graduate of Yale College in the class of 1759. In 1806 he received the degree of LL.D. He was a Member of the Continental and United States Congresses, and a Judge of the Superior Court of Connec- ticut. He died in 1819.
801
Terry of New Haven (previously mentioned), and it reads in part as follows:
"At a meeting of the Comtees of 23 towns in this Colony at Middletown March 30, 1774, appointed by their respective towns to confer together on the present alarming situation of this Colony, respecting the public measures lately pursued by the Honorable General Assembly respecting SASQUEHANNAH MATTERS, & to prepare a Petition and Remonstrance to be presented to the next General Assembly; *
* Whereupon it was voted that the annexed petition and remonstrance be printed and dispersed through all the towns in this Colony, that the general sense of the Public may be fully had there- upon. * * "Your Honours' Remonstrants beg leave, with the freedom of ENGLISHMEN and the duty of subjects, to lay their grievances before your Honours, the principal of which -and from which, as from its source, all other grievances are derived-is, that the pro- prietors of The Sasquehannah Company ( who claim the lands over which the Jurisdiction is extended) who were Members of the last Assembly and deeply interested in the questions discussed and determined, were suffered to, and did, sit and act in said Assembly in those very matters in which they were so deeply interested, and for which their partners-settled on said lands under their votes and for their benefit-were suitors * * We will not take up your Honours' time to prove their interest and partiality in the present case, since it is so apparent and notorious that not a Freeman in the Colony can be ignorant of it. * * *
· to said Assembly. *
" Your Remonstrants beg leave to say that it is not men but measures they regard. They have 110 personal dislike to the gentlemen who are members of that Company. They would think themselves warranted to complain in any case where men, the best of nien, with the same interests and prejudices were admitted to debate and decide. * * Your Remonstrants beg leave to shew to your Honours that they conceive the extension of jurisdiction to those lands by the last Assembly was of dangerous-and, in their appre- hension, may be of fatal-tendency. The title of the Colony to those lands is contested; should the same, on trial, be found effective, we conceive the Colony might justly be charged with usurping an unwarrantable jurisdiction and misusing and abusing their chartered powers and privileges-and thereby a pretence be furnished for depriving us of our dearest rights and privileges-at this time especially impolitic, when debates run high between the Parent State and her Colonies. Again, our humanity is shocked when we consider what bloody tragedies may ensue from the clashing of opposite jurisdictions, actually exercised, or attempted to be exercised, within the same limits.
"We apprehend that great numbers of subjects in this Colony, taught as they are from their youth to place the highest confidence in the Legislature, will be by the Acts of the last Assembly tempted to transport themselves and their effects, and settle on said lands pending the controversy about the title, and will waste their personal estate in im- provements of said lands; and, in case the title of the Colony should finally fail, they would be reduced to abject wretchedness, despondence and poverty there, or fall back on this Colony, by thousands, in extreme penury, to waste the residue of their lives a burden to themselves and an expence and a dead weight upon the community-by which means the support of the poor, already a heavy burden, will become intolerable. * * *
We pray your Honours to exclude the proprietors of The Sasquehannah Company from a voice on these matters, and reconsider the aforesaid votes and doings of the Assembly in October and January last; and, as we are willing to do justice to all men, let The Sasque- hannah Company, by their counsel, be admitted to have a public and open hearing upon the aforesaid matters, which we esteem of the highest and last importance. In the mean- time, we humbly hope that the inhabitants of the new-made TOWN OF WESTMORELAND may be suspended from interfering in the voting-being represented-or otherwise transacting in the affairs of Government during such term as the title of the Colony to the same is in suspense and undecided."
At Lebanon, Connecticut, under the date of March 24, 1774, Gov- ernor Trumbull wrote to Governor Penn of Pennsylvania as follows:
"Sir: I received your letter of 24th of February last. It is with pleasure I observe that you will do everything in your power to avoid contentions and disorders among His Majesty's subjects. A great number of people, possessed of and settled on a part of the lands of the Colony of Connecticut, at or near a place called Wyoming, lying west of the Delaware, within the boundaries and descriptions of your Royal Charter, made their application to our Assembly for protection and government. In consequence thereof, the town of Westmoreland was made, constituted, and assigned to our County of Litch- field, thereby forbearing the exercise of our jurisdiction over a great number of others who have more recently entered under grants from the Proprietaries of Pennsylvania, and claim other parts of the land belonging to Connecticut. It is not to be doubted that your power and influence may prevent the attempt of others to settle under your clain, and the disagreeable consequences which may follow the want on your part of a similar forbearance towards the people of Westmoreland until a legal and constitutional decision of the point may be obtained, which both you and Mr. Wilmot, Solicitor of the Propri- etaries, have acquainted us they will never decline.
802
"It is the duty of our Governor and Company, in faithfulness to the trust reposed in thein, to assert and support the rights of this Government, and its inhabitants. They do not look upon themselves chargeable with any fault for their exercise of jurisdiction over the people who inhabit land they have good reason to think themselves entitled to by legal purchase from the Aborigines, true proprietors thereof, and hold the unerring possession of under the right of preemption, for the benefit and within the limits of this Colony. I am to acquaint you that several gentlemen from hence, by virtue of an Act of Assembly, are employed and instructed to ascertain the latitudes of places beyond Dela- ware River. They design to set out the 18th of next month for that purpose.
"I am, Sir, with truth and regard, your obedient, humble servant, [Signed] "JONATHAN TRUMBULL."
In The Connecticut Courant of April 5, 1774, the following bur- lesque advertisement was printed.
"A State race to be run for the Royal Plate (on which the arms of this Colony are engraved) by the young horse 'Westmoreland ' against the old horse ' Charter,' at Hart- ford on the second Thursday of May next. It is said that very extraordinary bets are laid, and in such a manner that every Freeman in the Colony is interested in the event. ' Westmoreland ' is a horse of great spirit and fierceness, and very long legged; it is thought he will run with great vehemence, and will be crowded hard by the jockies. ' Charter ' has been an excellent horse in his day, more valued for his good carriage and elegance of form than largeness of size, and, when mounted by a good rider that under- stood his temper, hath performed well and scarce ever was distanced. However, he was forced into a race with the horse 'Purchase' last season, when not at all prepared, and hav- ing been rid hard the day before, and also obliged to carry the weight of numbers-which by no means should have been suffered-when the race was won he got worsted, which sunk his spirits very much and occasioned his legs to swell, and is not yet recovered so as to be quite fit for another race. However, his spirits recruit daily, and it is thought if he can have a good rider, and such a number of steady friends on the spot as to see that he has justice done him, he will perform as well as ever." * * *
In the same issue of the Courant as the foregoing the following article was printed:
"The affair of Susquehanna has of late been much the subject of conversation and scribbling, but many of the pieces have been stuffed with puns and ridicule to cast an odium on one side and the other. "Tis well known that The Susquehanna Company have been unremittedly worrying and teasing the General Assembly for near twenty years past to give up the Government's right to the western lands into the hands of that Company. The Government have always told then, 'We have no right, and will not pretend to give you any.' * * * Is it not well known that the Company consists of two sorts of men? The first sort, men of large fortunes, who, if the Colony obtains, intend to make tenants of the middling sort of people in this Colony, and they and their families live in affluence on the labors of their poorer brethren. The other sort, bankrupts and men of desperate fortunes who intend to go there to dwell and get small estates without paying anything for them, as they have 110 estates here to pay rates for, having spent them in riotous living and extravagant schemes. They say they have nothing to lose if the Company fails in the suit.
"Are not many of the Company the inhabitants of the Provinces of New York, *
Massachusetts and Rhode Island ?
* Strange that this Company should endeavor * to control this whole Government. They say they can secure the voice of the east side of Connecticut River, and their friends on the west side in the several towns will so divide them as to make a majority. They will, by threatening printers, and threatening to remove Courts, affright many; and they have their emissaries in almost all our towns, who en- deavour to flatter the Freemen they will remove the [Yale] College if they will help theni in this scheme about Susquehanna. "Tis said the College is already promised to six towns in Hartford County ! *
* * They take much pains to exclaini against Mr. [Jared] Ingersoll, and they fear him more than all Pennsylvania. And why? I answer, because he knows the futility of the claim better than almost any one else. He was their Agent in England, and saw and was told there was not the least shadow of probability of the Colony's obtaining the land. They declaim much against the Middletown meeting, *
* and the common cant of the friends to Susquehanna is, that the people on the west side of the Connecticut River are fools and madmen !" * * *
In the Courant of April 5, 1774, appeared also the first of a series of letters written by the Rev. Benjamin Trumbull*, A. M., of North
* BENJAMIN TRUMBULL was born at Hebron, Connecticut, December 19, 1735, son of Benjamin and grandson of Benoni Trumbull, who was a descendant of John Trumbull of Rowley, mentioned on page 470. Benjamin Trumbull was graduated at Yale College, A. B., in 1759, in the same class with Jonathan Sturges and the Rev. Enoch Huntington, hereinbefore mentioned. He studied theology with the Rev. Eleazar Wheelock, hereinbefore mentioned, and in 1760 was ordained pastor of the Church at North Haven, Connecticut. In 1762 he received the degree of A. M., and in 1796 the degree of D. D., from his Alma Mater. He was the author of a "A Complete History of Connecticut from 1630 till 1764," first pub- lished in two volumes, in 1797. He was also the author of a "General History of the United States of America." He died at North Haven, Connecticut, February 2, 1820.
803
Haven, Connecticut, in support of The Susquehanna Company, and the claim of Connecticut to the western lands. These letters, which ran through several numbers of the Courant, were written principally in reply to Jared Ingersoll's letter (see page 799), and the pamphlet (pre- viously mentioned) and various newspaper articles published by the Rev. Dr. Smith. Subsequently, in 1774, these Trumbull letters were collected together by their author, and, after some revision and addi- tions, were published by Thomas and Samuel Green of New Haven in a post 8vo pamphlet of 161 pages, entitled: "A Plea in Vindication of the Connecticut Title to the Contested Lands lying West of the Province of New York. Addressed to the Public. By Benjamin Trumbull, A. M."* In his introduction to these letters Mr. Trumbull wrote :
" A cause of equal magnitude and importance with that now depending between the Colony of Connecticut and the Proprietaries of Pennsylvania, relative to the western lands, was, probably, never litigated in North America."
In a note printed in the pamphlet Mr. Trumbull stated :
"As Dr. Smith, in a late publication in The Pennsylvania Gazette and New York Gazetteer, has injuriously insinuated that the Governor of Connecticut was acting at the head of a party, and that there were great numbers in Connecticut opposite to the measures of the last Assembly, &c., I have thought it but an act of justice due to their Honors, and to the Colony in general, to say: The country for which we contend is part of the inheritance and birthright left us by our fathers. They encountered almost every danger, endured all manner of hardships, toiled and bled to obtain and transmit it, with the most ample immunities and privileges, to their posterity. Shall we give up the in- heritance of our forefathers without a trial ? By no means ! Let us like men-like the descendants of ancestors so truly noble and heroic-arise and vindicate our title. Justice and faithfulness, not only to ourselves but to our posterity, no doubt require it.
"These, most certainly, have been the sentiments of the Honorable General Assembly. Upon the most mature deliberation, and after they had obtained the opinion of counsel of the first eminence in the Nation, in the Law Department, they, in full House, asserted their claim to the controverted lands, and, with a great degree of unanimity, appointed a committee of both Houses to make report of the measures, &c. They made a report, advising all the measures which have been since adopted by the Legislature. As they have so maturely taken up the matter, it is to be presumed that they will prose- cute it to effect. Especially may this be effected, since the freemen of the Colony have given such a public testimony of their approbation of the measures which have been taken, by a re-election of the Governor and the honorable gentlemen of the Council Board-by far the greatest number of votes ever brought in for any Governor or Council in this Colony."
Mr. Trumbull subsequently stated (in his "History of Connec- ticut," II: 479) that when he wrote the aforementioned letters he was " wholly unconnected with The Susquehanna Company and uninterested in it," but that having "made a large collection of papers and docu- ments relative to the Company," he wrote the letters "merely for quieting the people and maintaining the peace of the Colony." The Rev. Dr. Smith was not to be quieted, however, by the letters of Benjamin Trumbull, for almost immediately following the publication of the first letter he prepared a long and carefully-written article entitled "The Examiner, No. 1," which was printed anonymously in The Pennsyl- vania Gazette. It read in part as follows :
"When I first undertook to state and examine the late claim set up by the Colony of Connecticut to part of the Province of Pennsylvania, I determined to treat the subject with all that candor, gravity, and fairness of argument which seemed requisite. I am engaged in no scheme inimical to the people of Connecticut, or to their civil Consti- tution. If it be a Constitution that pleases them, and they will not disturb their neigh- bours with it, I am content they should enjoy it, although it be not sucli a one as I would have made my choice to live under. Nay! further, if they are straitened in their bounds, and want more land for their growing numbers (which I believe to be the case), I could even be pleased with their success in any application they may make for ungranted lands, to be settled by theni under their own or some other civil Constitution.
* The original manuscript of this pamphlet is now owned by Mr. James Terry, of New Haven, pre- viously mentioned.
804
"But if, instead of pursuing this method, they will violently invade our rights in Pennsylvania-who, in a few years, will be as much straitened for room as themselves -they must expect from us every species of opposition in our power. They must not be surprised if we endeavour to sliew the weakness of their claim, and expose the rotteu parts of that Charter which they want to stretch over us and so great a part of His Majesty's lands on this Continent ! With this view the pamphlet intituled 'An Examina- tion of the Connecticut Claim'* was drawn up, and I flattered myself that whatever abilities might be on the side of that party in Connecticut-who have instigated so un- righteous au encroachment upon a neighboring Province-would be called forth iu answer to the pamphlet and in defence of their proceedings. But great was my astonish- mient to find that, although the Connecticut newspapers for months past have been filled witli pieces written about their claim, yet they are so miserably defective in argument, as well as common English, that, in commiseration of the authors, I shall let them rest in obscurity, and confine myself to what is given as their Masterpiece, namely: certain papers published in The Connecticut Journal [sic] and subscribed Benjamin Trumbutl.' "I am the more willing to enter the lists with this gentleman because, being nephew to the Governort-the greal patron of The Connecticut Susquehanna Company-he may be presumed to have been fully possessed of all the arguments which they have to offer in support of their claim. Let me now tell him-what may perhaps be yet a secret to the Colony in general, that those very lawyers whose opinions have been so inuch bandied about in Connecticut, viz .: Mr. Thurlow, Attorney General, Mr. Wedderburn, Solicitor General, and Mr. Duuning,¿ are retained by the Honorable the Proprietaries of Pennsylvania to defend the Charter rights of this Province before His Majesty in Council, whenever the Connecticut claimants can be dragged to that equitable tribunal."
At Philadelphia, under the date of April 11, 1774, Governor Penn wrote to Governor Trumbull as follows :§
"Sir: I have your letter of the 24th March by the post. My sentiments of exercis- ing the jurisdiction of this Government in every part of the Province, and the impropriety of extending your jurisdiction within our bounds before you have laid your claim before His Majesty, are so plainly expressed in the several letters I have wrote you, and in those which passed between your commissioners and me, that they need not be repeated; and I cannot but think it strange that you should persist in attempting to support a possession gained from the people of this Province in a course of absolute hostility, before your Government had made any claim to the lands within the bounds of this Province. It appears to me that your taking latitudes at or beyond the Delaware within the bounds of this Province is premature; and, that no Act of your Assembly can authorize any such proceeding. I therefore cannot concur in that step; but, on the contrary, must protest against it, and desire it may not be done, lest it should produce effects which may be injurious to the public peace.
"I am with due regard, your most obedient and humble servant,
[Signed] "JOHN PENN."
April 25, 1774, Governor Trumbull wrote to Thomas Life, Esq., the Agent of Connecticut in London, and enclosed a copy of the foregoing letter of Governor Penn. Referring to that letter Governor Trumbull said :
Need help finding more records? Try our genealogical records directory which has more than 1 million sources to help you more easily locate the available records.